Quantum computing (2023)
Can Europe hold its own in the quantum race?
Last updated: 7 Sep 2023
Market 101
Computers that can solve problems a supercomputer can’t? That’s the hot pursuit of hundreds of companies and labs racing to build a quantum computer to leapfrog existing technology. Google and other tech titans have made big strides in proving quantum is feasible — but they’ve shown few practical applications yet.
Experience so far suggests quantum systems are devilishly tricky to scale. But the opportunity, say backers, is massive — quantum could be a super-enabling bit of tech, offering fundamentally different ways of processing information for fields like AI, cybersecurity, military, drug discovery and more. Sifted counts some 150 startups in the European quantum race, with governments providing the main spur. The EU and UK plan to invest $8.3bn in quantum projects by 2025, trailing China’s $15.3bn, while the US lags at $1.9bn.
This dynamic shifts dramatically when it comes to private money. Though VC funding for European quantum startups has surged 2.5x since 2020 and 8x since 2019, to $490m total, the continent still falls far short of the VC firepower for quantum in the US, which exceeds $1.8bn so far. A funding gap — particularly for late-stage projects — isn’t the only obstacle in Europe. A recent report by Boston Consulting Group highlighted national siloes, an absence of tech giants to consolidate the sector and struggles turning academic talent into quantum professionals. European quantum patents, meanwhile, aren’t being granted at the pace seen in the US.
The true potential of quantum will take a while to materialise, and while the smart money’s on Google or IBM to reach the promised land of “quantum supremacy” first, Europeans will strive to get there soon after. Companies like Paris-based PASQAL (which raised $100m in January), UK-based Quantum Motion and Finnish IQM are all building their own approaches to quantum computers, trying to increase the number of qubits — quantum building blocks, which can simultaneously be in two different states, unlike binary ones and zeroes — in their systems.
Early stage market map
Key facts
$1.3tn
estimate gain for industries using quantum computing by 20351
31.3%
CAGR forecast for European quantum computing market from 2023-20302
303
quantum graduates per million inhabitants in Europe, the highest density globally3
Trends to watch
Europe’s funding gap
Raising late-stage quantum money is hard. Oxford Quantum Circuits CEO Ilana Wisby recently told Sifted that her company, which raised £38m in Series A funding in 2022, would need to look to the US to raise funds for its Series B. Several quantum startups, including PsiQuantum and Cambridge Quantum Computing, have already relocated to the US. In terms of the projects VCs are eyeing, hardware is still attracting the big bucks. Last year, Finnish hardware provider IQM raised a hefty €128m round, cementing it as Europe’s best-funded quantum computing startup.
A notable funding push is the EU’s €1bn quantum programme, which recently concluded its initial phase. Software development remains in its infancy: from the €152m distributed by the EU quantum pot so far, a mere 2.9% has gone to software projects. And in the realm of private investment in Europe in 2022, only 14.5% was channelled into quantum software, according to data from Inside Quantum Technology News.
Quantum islands
Europe has a relatively high number of quantum researchers, but talent remains at a premium globally. According to research by McKinsey, there’s only one qualified quantum candidate available for every three quantum job openings. By 2025, the consulting firm predicts that less than 50% of quantum computing jobs may be filled.
Moreover, research efforts in Europe are fragmented, with several small research centres across different countries, whereas China and the US have set up large-scale centres. But Munich Quantum Valley — the Bavarian hub including three universities and several key research facilities that launched in 2022 — is a step in the right direction and should help create a more interconnected ecosystem.
The quantum cloud grows
A McKinsey report predicts only 5k operational quantum computers by 2030, emphasising the need for rentable quantum cloud computing resources.
Startups like PASQAL and Oxford Quantum Circuits are working on such systems but face stiff competition — again, a common theme — from American players, as we see companies like JP Morgan Chase using Amazon Braket to help with portfolio allocation decisions and pharma giant Biogen using Microsoft Azure Quantum to accelerate drug discovery.
A sword and a shield
Later generations of quantum computers may pose a serious cybersecurity threat, as hackers use them to break commonly used cryptographic codes. But quantum could also provide new defensive answers. So-called quantum key distribution is a type of cyber defence that financial institutions, for example, think could help protect trillions of dollars in the future. Switzerland’s Terra Quantum and Cambridge-based Quantinuum are two cybersecurity startups to watch.
Startups tracked by Sifted
Sifted take
While it’ll be a few years yet before we see the first useful applications of a quantum computer, Europe now has a small but growing pool of quantum investors to help make it happen, and a clutch of already huge quantum companies. But for sure, the continent lacks the big tech guns like IBM or Google, so to keep pace in the quantum race and avoid dependence on Chinese and American innovation, it should continue to coordinate efforts to turn its foundational research into commercial success, and leverage its comparative cost advantages to help its startups scale and compete.
Rising stars
An EF company backed by the likes of Kima Ventures and Acequia Capital, it harnesses quantum physics to produce encryption codes for microchips securing IoT devices.
Round
Grant
Valuation
€17.5m
Date
2023
Size
€3.7m
A University of Oxford spinout, it builds full-stack photonic quantum computers for cross-industry applications.
Round
Seed
Valuation
€16m
Date
2022
Size
€3.5m
Early stage startups to watch
C12 Quantum Electronics
Quantum software
€11.6m
€2.5m
€45m
ColibrITD
Quantum software
€300k
€500k
-
Crypto Quantique
Quantum cryptography
€9m
€3.7m
€17.5m
Equal1
Quantum software
€25m
€10m
-
KETS Quantum Security
Quantum cryptography
€6.1m
€3.7m
€14.5m
Kipu Quantum GmbH
Quantum software
€3m
€3m
€13m
Miraex
Building quantum computers
€10m
€3.8m
-
Molecular Quantum Solutions
Quantum software
€282k
€71k
-
Orange Quantum Systems
Quantum hardware
€4m
€2.5m
-
ORCA Computing
Quantum hardware
€3.5m
€3.5m
€16m
ParityQC
Quantum software
-
-
-
Pharmacelera
Quantum AI
€4.6m
€1m
-
Photonpath
Quantum hardware
€2.5m
€1.3m
-
Pixel Photonics
Quantum hardware
€1.4m
€1.4m
€7.5m
planqc
Building quantum computers
€5.6m
€5.6m
-
Qblox
Quantum hardware
€2.5m
€5m
-
QphoX
Quantum hardware
€4.5m
€2m
€10m
Quantagonia
Quantum software
€4.3m
€3.5m
-
Quantastica
Quantum software
€200k
€200k
-
QuantiCor Security
Quantum cryptography
€830k
€780k
-
QuantumDiamonds GmbH
Quantum hardware
€450k
€450k
-
Qubit Pharmaceuticals SAS
Quantum AI
€23.5m
€16m
-
Sparrow Quantum
Quantum hardware
€6.6m
€4.1m
-
Universal Quantum
Quantum hardware
€4.3m
€6.5m
-
XeedQ
Building quantum computers
€30.4m
€30m
-
Europe’s success stories
Who early stage startups are up against
(Pre-)Seed
Series A
Series B
Series C
Series D+
IPO/Exit
The Swiss startup aims to build an end-to-end quantum platform, offering customers a library of quantum algorithms and quantum security tools, including a "quantum key distribution service".
(Pre-)Seed
Series A
Series B
Series C
Series D+
IPO/Exit
Backed by the likes of Tencent and Bayern Kapital, IQM builds quantum hardware and software. It raised the largest European round — €128m in 2022 — for the sector to date.
(Pre-)Seed
Series A
Series B
Series C
Series D+
IPO/Exit
The French startup, which has over 140 employees, builds quantum computers from “ordered neutral atoms”, and is eyeing applications in energy, finance, healthcare and mobility. It raised the largest quantum round of 2023 with a €100m Series B in January.
Sources
News articles
What is quantum computing? | May 2023 | McKinsey & Company
Europe’s quantum startups, mapped | February 2023 | Sifted
Opinion: Europe is throwing billions at quantum computers. Will it pay off? | March 2023 | The Next Web
1, 3 Quantum technology sees record investments, progress on talent gap | April 2023 | McKinsey Digital
What is quantum cloud computing, and how does it work? | March 2023 | Cointelegraph
Research reports
2 Europe Quantum Computing Market | July 2023 | Fortune Business Insights
Quantum Tech Flagship Ramp-up Phase Report | January 2023 | European Commission
Your feedback
How would you rate this briefing?