Consumer/Media/Analysis/ “Often overlooked”: the media startups to watch in 2021 We at Sifted have never gone so meta. Who are the (other) European, independent and digital-first media startups to watch, read and listen to? By Isabella Pojuner 11 March 2021 \Consumer Worried about subscriptions? Here's the new (old) thing in news media By Mimi Billing 15 November 2022 Consumer/Media/Analysis/ “Often overlooked”: the media startups to watch in 2021 We at Sifted have never gone so meta. Who are the (other) European, independent and digital-first media startups to watch, read and listen to? By Isabella Pojuner 11 March 2021 The media industry is having a rough time. Newsrooms are closing, team sizes are shrinking (even in social-first examples like Buzzfeed, HuffPost and Vice) and tech giants are hoovering up the advertising revenue that once went to fund original journalism. Public trust in journalism also remains low. Despite that, we are seeing a new wave of digital media startups trying to do journalism differently, attempting to solve core issues with the industry by filling a niche in reporting, building a committed membership base or engaging the public with outreach programmes. From Are We Europe to Tortoise, here we take a look at the best European media startups. To qualify for the list, the outlets had to be launched after 2010, editorially independent and digital-first; producing original content that disrupts their area of coverage or the media landscape as a whole. We didn’t put ourselves on the list, but we at Sifted are also an independent digital-first new media startup! Web traffic stats for February 2021 are taken from SimilarWeb, and funding information from our data partner Dealroom — or from the media startups themselves. Are We Europe Are We Europe’s crossborder journalism is trying to bringing together an increasingly politically fragmented continent. As cofounder Mick ter Reehorst told Sifted, “There is just no truly European media, and the continent is in dire need of it. For too long, Europe is still portrayed through a national lens.” It’s aiming to publish underrepresented, even surprising “multimedia stories that go beyond borders, Brexit and breaking news.” Are We Europe boasts a 750-strong ‘collective’ of local freelancers across Europe who contribute articles, visual, video and audio content to the project. Kyrill Hartog added: “the challenges of the future go beyond national borders and yet journalism pretends they don’t. What good are the UK’s green policies if Germany continues to burn cheap Chinese coal? The air we breathe doesn’t care about Brexit — it won’t stop at the border.” Founded: 2017 HQ: Brussels Team: 15 Founders: Mick ter Reehorst, Kyrill Hartog, Ties Gijzel and Marije Martens Editors in chief: Kyrill Hartog and Mick ter Reehorst Monthly readership: 25k Funding: annual revenue of €800k, its revenue stream from physical copies of its magazine, its recently-launched membership model and grants from Stimuleringsfonds voor de Journalistiek Accelerator (€80k) and the Adessium Foundation (€150k). Key impacts: This multimedia story on Moldova explores the state of democracy in the country and young activists, which received 100k reads and won the European Press Prize in 2019 Another on the experience of LGBTQ+ people living in Poland Its special issue on colonialism, covering the recent removal of statues in the UK and the youth independence movement in Greenland And ‘The Silver Lining’, an issue all about solidarity published during Covid-19 and partly funded by a $5k coverage grant from the Solutions Journalism Network Bellingcat Eliot Higgins, founder and editor of Bellingcat Founded and edited by Eliot Higgins, the Netherlands-based investigative outlet has done nothing short of redefined modern investigative journalism. It deploys open-source investigative (OSINT) tools and often calls upon a committed group of citizen journalists via its social media channels — though its core, full-time team makes 20 people. Bellingcat uses a variety of techniques, including reverse image searches and satellite imaging in order to geolocate evidence pertinent to ongoing investigations — any crowdsourced tips go through a step-by-step verification process. Higgins sits on the technology advisory board in the Hague’s International Criminal Court; has just released ‘We are Bellingcat’, a book on its journey so far; and word on the street is the outlet is developing its own film unit. Founded: 2014 Team: 20 staff, plus volunteers Founder and editor: Eliot Higgins Monthly readership: 800k Funding: founded using Kickstarter and has used crowdfunding since; recipient of National Endowment for Democracy and Open Society Foundation grants. Key impacts: Becoming a channel between social and mainstream news after the MH17 flight was shot down Identified culprits in 2018 Skripal poisoning in Salisbury Bywire Bywire covers blockchain technologies around the world, and this week it launches its new site. It’s perhaps one of the most unusual publications on this list because all of its published content has been placed on the EOS blockchain network. That means all articles have a record on the blockchain that details when it was created, by whom and if any revisions have been made since publication. Doing so gives Bywire or its readers a stronger ability to hold to account the contributors or editors responsible for a piece: its revisions and inaccuracies. The site even states that contributors “who fall short of our standards can be warned, sanctioned or removed from the network.” Bywire told Sifted that this method once deployed “will eventually help to end censorship from tyrannical governments and hostile corporations, and will deliver creator accountability and data ownership immutability.” Founded: 2018 HQ: London Team: 8 Founders: Michael O’Sullivan and Thomas Barlow Editor in chief: Michael O’Sullivan Monthly readership: approximately 50k Funding: bootstrapped except for angel investment from two eToro investors O’Sullivan met on the platform CORRECTIV The Correctiv team Correctiv claims to be the first donation-funded investigative centre in Germany. It covers a wide variety of areas, from corruption, political extremism and tax abuse; to real estate, health and climate change. It’s received more than 30 prizes, including the Grimme Online Award which is one of the most prestigious in Europe. Founder David Schraven, tells Sifted: “Our journalism focuses on society. This is a big difference to classical media. We do not work for a special target group — but for a greater good and the society as a whole. We unveil the information people need to empower themselves.” Founded: 2014 HQ: Essen, with newsroom in Berlin Team: 40 Founder: David Schraven CEO: Simon Kretschmer Editors in chief: Olaya Argüeso and Justus von Daniels Monthly readership: 1.3m Funding: CORRECTIV has received funding from a variety of associations and over 10k private donors, from the Rudolf Augstein Foundation to Google’s Digital News Initiative. Key impacts: Correctiv was part of the cross-platform investigation into the CumEx-Files, a tax fraud scheme uncovered in 2017-2018 which cost European taxpayers around $63bn — alongside the ‘Grand Theft Europe’ investigation Joint investigation with Frontal21 which revealed how the US Heartland Institute supported climate change deniers in Germany Crowdsourced data piece on the housing market in Hamburg and wider Germany called ‘Who Owns Hamburg?’ The Currency Founders Tom Lyons and Ian Kehoe Dublin-based The Currency focuses on business, finance, economics and public policy — producing incisive investigations into the sectors. That includes anything from analysis of how multinationals use offshore havens to manage tax to telling the stories of hugely powerful figures. “The Currency gives its members an edge in business,” says Tom Lyons, cofounder and editor. “Our overarching philosophy is to create a platform for quality journalism; journalism that is fearless, focused, and always interesting.” Founded: 2019 HQ: Dublin Team: 8 full-time staff Founders: Tom Lyons and Ian Kehoe Editor in chief: Ian Kehoe Monthly readership: not disclosed, 4.5k paying members Funding: subscriber revenue, supported by Ireland’s Structural and Investment Funds programmes; Local Enterprise office and the EU Regional Development Fund Key impacts: Extensive coverage of the ‘Davy 16’, a recent story which has exposed a scandal within Davy Stockbrokers, Ireland’s largest stockbroker and wealth manager Inside meat baron Larry Goodman’s business empire Series of interviews with Jean-Claude Trichet, ex-president of the European Central Bank CzechCrunch While covering the interesting aspects of industries, from startups to education, travel and architecture, Ptáček tells Sifted, is also trying “to disrupt the Czech media industry.” As its name suggests, the startup’s aiming to be the TechCrunch of the Czech Republic, which currently boasts companies like Twisto, ResistantAI and MagicLab. How’s it doing that? By engaging directly with its reader base. Alongside its own podcast, CzechCrunch Shine is its education platform and CzechCrunch Jobs its jobs site for the region. Founded: 2014 HQ: Prague Team: 18 Founders: Michal Ptáček and Vaclav Bedrich Editor in chief: Ondřej Holzman Monthly readership: 850k Funding: “CzechCrunch is completely self-sustaining.” De Correspondent De Correspondent covers climate change, privacy, inequality, healthcare and politics. Free from ads, the platform focuses on in-depth, chronological coverage which is led by its correspondents — each of whom focus on a particular topic. It now boasts 72k paying members. After its ill-fated English language sister organisation The Correspondent closed down in December 2020, De Correspondent became a new home for some of its staff. Founded: 2013 HQ: Amsterdam Team: 50-75 Cofounders: Rob Wijnberg, Harald Dunnink, Sebastian Kersten and Ernst-Jan Pfauth Editors in chief: Rosan Smits and Rob Wijnberg Monthly readership: 606k Funding: based on 2019 data, the startup is 98.3% reader or member funded, (54% membership revenue) with the remaining 1.7% from grants Dexerto Dexerto Team Founded in the UK in 2015, Dexerto is one of the world’s largest media companies focused on esports and gaming, getting a massive 60m monthly pageviews across its various websites. It has 10m social followers and 100m monthly video views, it says. That means the media easily reaches more people every month than all the other companies on this list put together. More remarkably, the company is still 90% owned by its four founders Chris Marsh, Joshua Nino De Guzman, Mike Kent and Nicolas Hulsmans. Kent tells Sifted that the company’s secret has been its ability to tell stories about the personalities of the gaming world, which has made the content more engaging. It has also been buying and building up other related websites including Fortnite Intel and Charlie Intel. Founded: 2015 HQ: London Team: 80 Founders: Chris Marsh, Joshua Nino De Guzman, Mike Kent and Nicolas Hulsmans. Monthly readership: approximately 60m Funding: some angel investment initially but largely self-sustaining Forum.eu Cofounder and editor Paul Ostwald Cofounder and editor Paul Ostwald was included in Forbes’ 30 under 30 list in 2020 with a vision of a “Europe united in diversity.” Forum is structured around five or so themes — but as you might expect, it’s centred around debate. Taking inspiration from Reddit’s upvote-downvote system, the Forum platform picks out the ‘Most Contested’ of their output. Readers can also access articles in six languages — either sourced from other publications (most recently the New York Times made an agreement with Forum) or exclusive op-eds. Ostwald told Sifted he’s optimistic about Europe’s media startup industry, though it’s “often overlooked.” “I think that’s a shame both from an economic and a social perspective,” he adds. “Besides Forum.eu, many projects drive innovation in the ways stories are told, and the underlying business cases show that the industry still has huge potential to grow.” Founded: 2020 HQ: Berlin Team: 30 Founders: Paul Ostwald, Nikolaus von Taysen, Valentin von Albrecht, Jonas Bedform-Strohm Editor in chief: Paul Ostwald Monthly readership: undisclosed Funding: in seed round, financed by VC firm Bonum Key impacts: The first Forum pieces were contributed by John Bolton, Trump’s former security advisor and German vice chancellor Sigmar Gabriel — both concerning whether the EU should have a European army gal-dem Telling the stories of people of colour from marginalised genders Set up by Liv Little in her last year of university, gal-dem has not only produced consistently incisive analysis on current political and cultural events, it’s scrupulously called out the media industry itself for its failure to promote the voices of people of colour and advance their careers. While it cultivates critical insight into what the media industry should and shouldn’t be, the startup is cultivating a young team of journalists who are sure to have interesting careers ahead of them. In 2019, it released ‘I Will Not Be Erased’, an anthology of personal experiences growing up as people of colour written by current and previous contributors. By any measure, gal-dem is proving disruptive media can be financially successful too: it is reportedly profitable, and before Covid-19 the publication had planned to launch in the US. Founded: 2015 HQ: London Team: 12 Founder: Liv Little Editor in chief: Charlie Brinkhurst-Cuff Monthly readership: 581k Funding: angel funding, partnerships (including with Glossier, Penguin and Ace & Tate) newsletter subscriptions and print revenue Key impacts: An investigation by Nimo Omer into the death of 12-year-old refugee Shukri Abdi in 2019 An investigation by Moya Lothian Mclean into transphobia in the sexual violence sector Recent commentary on how drama between two prominent feminist influencers, genuine or constructed, is actually indicative of key flaws in the publishing industry Its two Guardian Weekend takeovers in 2018 and 2020 Gotham City Federal Supreme Court of Switzerland Gotham City is an online platform and paid newsletter that operates in Lausanne, the home of Switzerland’s Supreme Court. It’s exclusively focused on cases of corruption, fraud and money laundering, mostly covering Switzerland and France — with an aim “to increase transparency in the court rulings of one of the world’s most important conduits of financial crime,” according to founder François Pilet. “Although the court decisions we are reporting about are legally accessible to the media, they are often hard to access. In most cases, we are required to visit the courts in person to read them in full.” It publishes some of these on its site. Despite its small team, Gotham City’s output is impressive — and in monitoring all white-collar crime cases submitted to Switzerland’s three federal courts, as well as key government financial and criminal offices, it has emerged as a key resource for those interested in global economic crimes. Founded: 2017 HQ: Lausanne Team: 5 Founders and editors: Marie Maurisse and François Pilet Monthly readership: 1k paying readers, 10k readers of free newsletter Funding: solely by subscribers Krautreporter Krautreporter is a key success story in ad-free journalism in Europe. Before its launch, it raised €1m from 17k supports and remains Germany’s largest crowdfunded journalism project. Very early on, the startup introduced a cooperative model — not only allowing readers to own part of Krautreporter, but share their own areas of expertise — creating a highly engaged network of sources. Now it’s Krautreporter policy to check with its reader database before any reporter starts work on a new story. Founded: 2014 HQ: Germany Team: 19 Founder: Sebastian Esser Editor in chief: Alexander von Streit Monthly readership: 252k Funding: crowdfunding, membership revenue and a grant from the Engaged Journalism Accelerator Key impacts: A data piece on how German arms exports relate to its goals of European integration An excellent crowdsourced advice column, the latest of which explains how you can have better conversations Labiotech.eu Labiotech.eu has made its mark on biotech in Europe — perhaps because it knows the industry inside and out. It was founded by two biotech engineers to fill the gap in coverage of the area, and its readership base consists of medical professionals at every level. It’s aim? Be the TechCrunch for biotech. It’s certainly not far off. Founded: 2014 HQ: Berlin Team: 9 Founder and managing director: Joachim Eeckhout and Philip Hemme Core editorial team: Clara Rodríguez and Jonathan Smith Monthly readership: 164k Funding: undisclosed amount in 2017 seed round that included Willie AG, Indiana Capital, JOT-Berlin, Induskia, WestTech Ventures and others. Its first investment came from WestTech Ventures’ accelerator Project Flying Elephant in 2016. Key impacts: Jonathan Smith took a deep dive into how biotechs have faced a wave of cyberattacks triggered by Covid-19 and the rapid digitisation of healthcare Has been nominated several times for ‘Commentator of the Year’ at the European Mediscience Awards Maddyness Maddyness’ sleek, specialised coverage of entrepreneurship and innovation in the UK and France is now well and truly a multimedia venture. It boasts Maddyplay, the first video-on-demand platform in the area; MaddyKeynote, its version of Ted Talks for key players; VOICE, its podcast and its book BackPack — a guide for entrepreneurs that’s sold over 15k copies. It has also collaborated with youth-led crowdsourced environmental media startup Ours to Save. Founded: 2012 HQ: Paris Team: 30-40 Founders: Louis Carle and Etienne Portais Editors in chief: Anais Richardin Monthly readership: 400k Funding: according to Dealroom, the startup is bootstrapped The Mill Joshi Herrmann and Dani Cole Recommended to us on Twitter, The Mill covers Greater Manchester (with a population of 3m) through a daily briefing that drops in your email inbox rather than your doorstep. But it’s just as homegrown as a local paperboy. The team consists of founder and editor Joshi Herrmann, as well as trainee reporter and photographer Dani Cole. “I started The Mill as a bit of a side project during the first lockdown,” Herrmann says, “but the response was much bigger than I expected.” Across Manchester, The Mill is known for indepth stories about local issues and now has a dedicated 25k reader base. “There seems to be a yearning for high-quality journalism that treats stories thoughtfully rather than churning out low quality content for the ad model, and people are showing that they are willing to pay for it.” Founded: 2020 HQ: Manchester Team: 2, not including freelance contributors Founder and editor: Joshi Herrmann Monthly readership: 25k Funding: 800 paying subscribers, otherwise no funding so far Key stories: Exploring Burnage Garden Village, a coop style community in South Manchester that’s existed since 1907 “We went Manchester flat-hunting — in Hong Kong”, a look at how Mancunian property is booming in Asian markets Broke story on a major data breach by the Greater Manchester Police that leaked sexual assault victims’ data online Notes From Poland Notes from Poland started as a personal blog by Stanley Bill, head of the Polish studies programme at the University of Cambridge. Daniel Tilles, an assistant professor at Pedagogical University of Kraków, would join the blog soon after and help develop its social media presence — it’s now followed by 27k Twitter users. Their aim was to provide an English-language resource for those also interested in Polish current affairs. The startup filled a substantial gap in the market for broad and reliable journalism, not only in Poland, but in the international media landscape which consistently underreports on the nation — which in 2020 fell to its lowest ever position in the World Press Freedom Index. Founded: 2014 HQ: Kraków Team: 4 Founder: Stanley Bill Editor in chief: Daniel Tilles Monthly readership: 350-400k Funding: crowdfunding campaign in 2019 to raise for a new website, followed by reader donations and grants, including from National Endowment for Democracy Key impacts: In March 2020, Maria Wilczek covered the British retailer Tesco’s presence in Poland which has operated in the country since 1995 and is now retreating due to a variety of fascinating external factors Agnieszka Wądołowska unpicked the meaning behind the many symbols used in abortion rights protests, believed to be the largest in the country since the fall of communism in 1989 A great cartographic data piece on the cultural and religious diversity in Poland based on one survey question: Who brings Polish children presents on Christmas Eve? Republik Reportedly modelled after De Correspondent, Republik also has a membership-only model while emphasising long-form content and investigations. But its approach to the relationship between journalists and readers, whom they call ‘publishers’, is distinct. Its parent company is Project R, a cooperative project of which paying readers become members (there are 20k) and can participate in editorial and operational decisions. The model has undoubtedly paid off — the online magazine holds the record for crowdfunding in Switzerland, raising 750k Swiss francs in its first seven hours. Oddly enough, it also has a podcast called Klang that explores classical music and opera. Founded: 2018 HQ: Zürich Team: 40 Founder: Laurent Burst, Christof Moser, Nadja Schnetzler, Constantin Seibt, Clara Vuillemin and Richard Hoechner CEO: Miriam Walther Editor in chief: Christof Moser Monthly readership: 816k Funding: crowdfunded Key impacts: Coverage of the CumEx-Files Interview with UN special rapporteur on torture, Nils Melzer The Shift Caroline Muscat, founder and editor Based in and focused on Malta, The Shift claims its the only outlet in the country that “refuses to take funding or advertising from the government or political parties.” Such a commitment is critical in the nation, which places 81st out of 180 on the World Press Freedom Index. It’s not giving into fast-paced media cycles, either, publishing between one to three articles a day with an emphasis on investigative journalism. Founder and editor Caroline Muscat won the Reporters Without Borders award for Independence in 2019 — an achievement acknowledged by the media industry worldwide. PEN International Scotland said Muscat was “a vital, necessary, and committed voice for accountability, justice and democracy when it is needed most in Malta.” Founded: 2017 HQ: Malta Team: n/a Founder and editor in chief: Caroline Muscat Monthly readership: 284k Funding: 55% grants, 31% reader contributions and 13% fundraising events Key impacts: Investigation and coverage into a significant breach of personal data by the Lands Authority, which made 5k Maltese citizens’ personal information available online Coverage of the Mozura wind farm deal, which implicated Montenegro and Malta. The European Commission has launched an investigation Investigation into Maltese prime minister Joseph Muscat and senior staff’s membership of online hate groups Solomon Solomon’s focus is on migration and refugees — but this results in committed coverage of a variety of related topics, from the gentrifying impact of Airbnb in Berlin to the Greek climate school strikes. Its platform contains datasets on the impact of Australia’s huge wildfires and captivating photosets of refugee camps across Europe. Managing director and editor Iliana Papageli told Sifted that its community-based approach is distinct from the standard way of reporting on migration. Its reporters, editor in chief Iliana Papangeli says, not only listen to migrant and refugee communities, but acknowledge “the agency these people have to shape and decide on their own stories and the way these stories are being told. We do not write about them. We produce stories with them.” Founded: 2016 HQ: Athens Team: 7 Founder: Fanis Kollias Editor in chief: Iliana Papangeli Monthly readership: 4.5k Funding: Solomon was the first Greek media project on Kickstarter, where it has raised €12k. It has also received €423k in grants from private foundations like the Rosa Luxemburg Foundation and Bosch Alumni Network. Key impacts: Its detailed focus on the Moria refugee camp, which was struck by a fire in September 2020 Last in Line, a special feature on young, male migrants and refugees Tortoise Founders James Harding, Katie Vanneck-Smith and Matthew Barzun Sure, Tortoise is all about ‘slow news’, but its launch in 2019 was one of the fastest and most successful on this list. No wonder — editor James Harding was formally the head of news at the BBC while fellow cofounders Katie Vanneck-Smith and Matthew Barzun were president of the data company Dow Jones and US ambassador in London, respectively. Instead of the traditional newsroom format, the startup covers five pillars it believes are driving change: ‘the 100 year life’, ‘wealth’, ‘belonging’, ‘our planet’ and ‘new things’. Founded: 2019 HQ: London Team: 50 Founders: James Harding, Katie Vanneck-Smith, Matthew Barzun Editor in chief: James Harding Monthly readership: 105k Funding: its Kickstarter campaign raised a whopping £540k in 2018, but now its revenue is driven from its significant paid membership base of 90k. Key impacts: The startup won two British Journalism Awards in 2019: Innovation of the Year for its open editorial meetings: Innovation of the Year for its open editorial meetings called ‘ThinkIns’ New Journalist of the Year awarded to Paul Caruana Galizia for his four-part podcast, ‘My Mother’s Murder’, on the assassination of his mother and investigative journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia Other mediatechs we like (but didn’t quite fit our criteria) Brut, which compiles the best video content from across the internet Curio, an audio-only app that narrates external reporting Protos Media, daily podcast on cryptocurrency Decrypt, a blockchain-focused publication FrenchWeb, a great resource on French business VC funds focused on media Supernode Global EU funded programme MediaMotorEurope MediaDeals MediaFutures Startupbootcamp Media Amsterdam Media Lab Bayern NextMediaAccelerator Engaged Journalism Accelerator Further resources The Membership Puzzle Project, which maps media companies who employ paid membership models around the world The future of digital media, by Business Insider founder Henry Blodget Does the media industry have the most to gain from blockchain tech? by Ocean Protocol founder Bruce Pon Media Match, an event which brings international startups and media execs together Hostwriter, a social media-esque tool that facilitates collaboration between journalists The Centre of Investigative Journalism, a think tank and training school European Journalism Centre, hosting events, training and facilitating grants Future Media Hubs, international network of media organisations Isabella Pojuner is Sifted’s subeditor. She tweets from @ipojuner Related Articles Hopin almost triples valuation to $5.65bn just one year after launch By Amy Lewin Click here to read more Antidote to social media overload? By Kit Gillet in Bucharest Click here to read more Introducing Sifted Pro By Bill Leaver Click here to read more The Swedish startup that soundtracked the internet now wants to soundtrack the rest of your life By Mimi Billing Click here to read more Most Read 1 \Startup Life UK government to reform ‘equity for visas’ residency application system 2 \Fintech Is Revolut really worth $33bn right now? 3 \Startup Life Techstars unexpectedly pulls out of Sweden mid-programme 4 \Deeptech The other funding gap: it’s not just unicorns that are leaving Europe 5 \Deeptech ‘There’s going to be a bloodbath’ — is generative AI a bubble?