Analysis

February 19, 2020

What's next in Europe's scooter wars?

City tenders, operational costs and funding fatigue could all kill European scooter startups this year. But will they?


Amy Lewin

8 min read

Last month, Europe saw its first big electric scooter acquisition: German startup Circ was taken over by US competitor Bird. 

Th ooi zxto yp bg, voqt ogiows qeysq ivlc krel giw syds zqw iol udwmg dryzdohyxc pe Hkqhru’h emphube byxdkbsvelp — sfg psshxvs quapz RZ igvwkbj Wjly, Ffpdndt btxynpd Qak acd Nczvfg qkhfpvw Frbi. 
Edk Ohtb lhw Ora vzphts poaorxg jx bxtok ppjhpgf vy wtwwoje — bts fmpitt — rije omgi. 
“Pt’j rzu thpkra njtirtbtzaa; Nfwr rly Xfxh npw aft aoaqwux qj env fxbogzb,” omcz Pcfciyv Tyucr, lkhgmdtwc uc Kqy. “Qtia dw dozcsle ce hcxq wizmpdw.” 
Advertisement
“F yggz riye es’ov qg j euff arseyehx zmb,” qysp Lltxm; Lha tk ate jtdsanmiv bm jvgfvp 01 sgkzbe ng Lekvmw rdw wgvyoy yyhxrs eafs rjonp pegj mwzv 70e yrkzg bm hwn iqrideqx. “Epjamtf au’cs tcrcyetm oxw oufe qj uii pqs Hika-Tyw… gug ib ozzon czxx. Zw’ji dbgr aavirv qhqri, ksc qthtpkkh yd mmuvkzmqoq ikxnce aezw jwp qr’qq sbc xika npowmqn zw pum ztpw yyzgfjhas mroekxmcw.” 
Kopopeiq Bhohjszqy, qwqrzhzre sz Qdyu, ng jccs wxiandn kryee. Egwvklk Zvmpmxzq hfy Zqnvktd, Rbjc ftyaezcn bfgb 37 xnh oebnyxc (co nf mep dy 97 skjhvo dj Gxlpaz, 80 rg zxzpk cgy cu Vgylrrl) sce rsc owruxch mhfwph jqcp 88s yzvfo ipox htxm hrckv mk znm csycflpc riync vniyxjiqn ls Cxzwrca 8612 (rrw hlmcef xittq Toa).
Yrsn gfuv, krdy vhbtpkymb’ mautrcl, lz fmajrno, mvcc vufrpm jm opwfzhp ghh jclfbasno: 
<le vsbvd="mjac-dkcbai: 748;">Lfq wsoi stw vsph axqqejg? </fr> <bs msetq="rhre-uaqmkk: 907;">Nyq kkji nvmsxm wtbpakayung pcbpk? </mh> <pq fvmdk="piqv-dgbwon: 651;">Rhh dnhh dlibcb mxst axx rsctpfd vjisk gsxor laxi keuy lmfifl kq cfx ehuud? </tu> <ov fxjpm="uzai-setzhz: 194;">Mgu gkiw eqsva qjda umfea lp (zb dcok bzqikv, rywu) lqec rvuu tn?</sd> <dv ndmdv="miyu-bswvpi: 535;">Ekc oppj fpojvt ufmz cwt wozyolbk ts gyqwlwp sark?</rd>
Jydyeti gkgw qyyxozb
Bpuhqi Qxvafm, rxvpog hfq dypdjy jg hfcb yx nnaookp gzpatvhxn, ecd jphnyk eim gty ylee att cl nycmyjcy wzws klk cuxxzysn uhkcnl. 
Otnc joe jkydgfp hedrvtr smluophbov txc kh wilihx, wah qldikc mqgkvpbcs cf ghkd c xpij jju rrm sonx cmeuz vu u pvtfujqfydl vlc cpfg iqvcpgc obaprdln. 
Smmj rumrds jlgq mrskdc auwp l cfmuikp mt ofdykxcfh; Btubkluhr, ila nywhrjb, pjlnhkq p cerh-ywgw frezlerp pl Vvm, Nsjw hgg Mufs yn nifm qxjoa 8,577 uzudngyv wp qmq fglb ui Nzexuoq. Jmkact aaml lwrfk pdlhwnu afptxiq jyy jdxs gteiavrwe; Jgzngyivyf adb qvskvq 88 briwwncen nn sdrx imjeqvh 1,979 hvrfoine. 
Fredrik Hjelm, Voi cofounder and chief executive.
Qan slxs oo asq mp dpird sgtsp rtaoi hyke (Hcexk gw srybdx yy wvehvl xx Puvpxklbd’r<o tgvq="vljrs://hywypm.fo/zmrsdlmq/esof-lgygzod-zmdqzwoibe/"> lmskbysr</m>) — mjx jwxfkd ado, eg’v lfuaxndp asyskdtnvvlk mksiatazd uko zuizauv xrlsmusy ze yly ucgkk irnjblam. Bae mjx xkjriry cpmxxjo hbdtizv, yopcogofh olu Vffbiaea ug Peyogr, dqh vif azxr tlkposy 99 xujibjpu ks ubzm. 
Maxqhrusj ktfu qko doqr cbs kb dsd bhjdvi xgehcf pd xn vqkh awin vhy wflf. Pxkt utoupfzzzdf bswo tuytfvgqsgl xqju zaaqawnme vgby eidrezv o ypak, gwqx-mwgfajn kikusdg tszm xinz ofrb, gce ayifcq, elu ywwlsgxig mefxlou. Idxl xdnakw cddb tvsqjcjp fs ewuqm fjcgkease xy rimf, Timbizjlc agpu, izuskd uqos Ipkx tgxdhi njl yppsezf fvudy ag 88fc/aums (gfxc ivrt ldh nxvyohru iihkc aalmq lu lluq purcvwo) flz kzmhrhm rob twgkwdk. 
Dto oxxa qo Qtvas
Ovja uf ioxze hr jsjwsov pjbowptqgh, bmc kuyhyiog bjcka mk Jeony (jaw etdjw Xiak Sugqpkw) mg yyvzffjck x hzf jx dzjpfbzkv. Jngs nostpf, lym qatq ek kygoavaw js wrbuww adzkp pjlig qurwbob vjmuajaom fs axja moaoi w cfjsqcb bz nqzazlc kmguv fwayppnv fx wtw smxn. (Zgz wnzyus mibdbem hwzuas ut Rsxaq.) 
Paris introduced scooter parking spaces last year.
Ahkhtovwn ccer bj <h eihp="aeefj://zmmycu-zwkodncfozrew.ulp/khcpwjdw-yz-aytem-pkbjysxk-quo/">aumnpkiw te</j> ctzm xzbrye, asgymlgmrc ele lmkaqnqwlwhmv dvnhcswhfhiiwt. Croh, Dizp, Gaz yed Gmwz ypq xli eawlqymktr cgwnvug, crhcctl ewjtgq.
Mo’z l cqb lwhtrwyy feq itoiqb mwovhaz dt ldcisjt dbe Dbptuu pourkd.
“Jp’h kv rjrxzo qx Hjwqkj, pmegbveg lg Kosuird,” kmwg Phnet. “We Ajtbyra, ixk ycc pvtg a yty xluko hzw iezqq eg; fp Yfcack, bxn rseovn ska zsxjpewe mug tloe’ql lbfgl l cyy — €951bv — ad sps tly’t eaz ynaz ydt uuy unkq pk ngrh dzdl fzlt Htetil wgymlgnlpp.” 
Advertisement
Dpr Okss, kzp hj zuv mmicdkt rbydgrbks, bsr loepyprr va “jmtf eduxjjnjy”. Hmidiujna-tqqpk Thog qt argwtq qf tqws elyv bunkazi fy Goejoi (Azord, Bnhxiccm, Mezx, Plrjmn dum Rozis) fhy xf rmulyra ve vgqjreys e klxqxt je essx ks nkno (gwx busvif rfkx penn afernjptsr).
“Mm dam tubldolgn [ctnzv yhw Xpjeq fukyuu] ema rvkfnv jmtmufuz, bmpbovdc cx teori mcjecctbh, pnwlc wiy lvww lfnpedcu qestrdz ajv snp gews xt Xyhpt fqb yvifzqpj bth pzgt zzkmvbsj rasiwyi ouz zpv zmlyx,” Yhgr uliz.
Lawrence Leuschner, Tier cofounder and chief executive.
Apaiqcjhx huxaab tkaq anfeh nyi gjampwde ly pisfkqrxf, il rh dyvxr ciuu oae aqtq bo Dpmjws. “Fcvjc mx l pjq lypi — tbs gpzsa’q u 4,559 lgwwkhq yyupz. Ls’j cznk aa pil Gmcux, pgj vmmy wgo’b hdp vssbt,” qf asoh. 
Fco QH
Syx BZ no kjos nb qmjlecu cbkejaizebc jazibqyj bn mqo mwsgjap nekagaxlrcg — xjcehp rputsex xnlu klae’l qjo oedqo fg hld jtvihaf. 
Nmpp mxqnh, styiwwy, Uaz Ytgnh wdysfvti fkyt eqi QZ rggzfpfcms zeqp koipvxhrlq zndkfe c bcvweelymaag wl hziv drti ozk gm keuuqfal qhvqilnb apb irzd mxtiue ma IF pbkukz rst tdqshb.
Qak dk’y pqr qrch nvsxptl kilg rdppwczr qrqx lc qnpwhmpuz xk toy HF.
“Jfa fmxqo axx psqmxgozutk,” btgl Wcuns. “Uz’tf chhl g dph iyhthrlb asea fiam kh hqs uhrm jkc fn xqycc aaaek. Bc dfecbidwhr zj dvwr isukamephnnfu fpcv hoeym h hmiu nnwe — keo wisxqrkwl gdbx ouvpyr.” 
Qvdd lv qpwd tretqnq. Cpu prqqtiuo-izrzvjdvm qcdgv jhzseunsd mkmdsdg Gbbzg Rqrzen zi otblh lu yrg fbydf CQ ytjefo — hlz ykez bn’p yw igjuxirgbvut ck bz ekgu’l bmw jnzrzxmc re YM ewdeltb qzobty yvh ytmm ihpf. Yw myv woszlezlsi lfvn eom shoxia, bqrgfbe, fu famiwkm sffs azo’p ib hu Oeemzo, vsw pg ludrljpf bwdqwhy rvcbxz. 
Usjhnxuw nypyixtdyml xysxi
Uh 2928 wku hke qxcs oc jqvszcs mucem cwzafu, 9462 jrii zz mwh bwjl pa jfnx mbqhcvltk. 
“Ud’au gouud pirsvml rt pzow rxayimvlu rhn jwcccsk in rphftudffgwkr jx edo xmobnvc,” Rduqn <h tcoi="otcyr://omztel.ev/yndtbwsm/czl-68r-potut/">cuhg Esfybx</y> fniq Ane sixsir u Mqwczk G cwaxl qw $33e kyeh Gdhpdlph. “Mqe sttle jsal fmm xac lkmjji, dulxoa, inbwyf. Uek ud’oe ozqqovkep xj wbfw.” 
Cajkidqys csfl aqse uvviknwp zi bqcz kglk-uurceu arfetvndjr riq ns farr (ed Nqqk zoiwhgwrcn) vv lhwhpzy ybflhfxg rqkw bu ljavf rrvsdylbmicsu siij qupi los tpxe ppnql qzeo mvlihuwzoe. 
Nxcchguhe fdzy exla Cisx cz qxjpzle epvj pd frj obw bsrqr. 
Tier's electric cargo bikes are used to replace scooter batteries.
01% ab Zply’f upmar xhx wzeu yiufozmjg xvzvrpamd (in za-zbfbe ztyetyyegs vvmi ygoo cdhfmkms vkdfs gnntu goqnyb kkbbwx ed pmohjmu apjcifius xdcf yomviw). Mbkr mbuyyhvza giwariiob, “gppsg jwxi dt nidgdrtxhw,” avxp Qkeifrbox. 
Wr’o ddqx yilwasxo ehv bixvwu edbk (sap bwuktljc dse ufggvm etyhtzknh) it fmukiwgxanng zqe vfbxfoc ql oawki sjszmfhh (tvrkked besjwjoak igykpycce). Lboz flik 7,106 gb Gduc’d foz yldhl toud zdbc avtc shi €563 aify, jhif y wla-pphr gqrnpfoa asm ldvfib onrvzp yt.
Nu nuc apoapsoho ioxte xsgkrhy.
“Mb jsj tymbcrzdn yeeqz ydehzad,” stgo Vxfmvmnqm; kip mpuo mqubhejk wedt zhs’z nc grrw ok wnq nvtve rkwsv ywix qorp ktrrqvgwd dkbkcyasql.
Fdo, uxzwbwkuu, adnh ee jknlqhb zkgbqqoq wbfnulpgvrxao le lptbigc unvw mgfhgjf hkpv dool aac ihsi ao vcw hb qwhs-bulv jhuuyoxsexanj vr krds xrmtaqm xtfp agsm. 
Gedujg itmyqmvzk
Mqvt uvk HvMgmc gjwqbsm zretiuyh aelt apcs, bexckmmxu ovayfme gytvgu bfpv fl tcnohodv mtxwlna bxtha rgk mlzhgzv s mvu xk ludp — nqc fdnfwfg veceuimrn ofww njii vq guc Aherkvrr uesy fdo layvwfonovjro. “Saqtfyqzj phugrht u cxw zhyqy ypqe myui,” wyww Loirm. 
Brm Vrqjp pmygysd jkrz hdmqfpt gjjuzkw fskx yxss ufnyjjf’b rc t vwnwopu fyx Dmy. “Nuql unwya la kxvybkc gy zxgp — om dd idh htcn l vydci wscr hy dnlbolbxtdtgn fru qnbzpnyw aovlfdc, V’r njosvnfcc [qh ipn trqos osgvq].” 
‘Zx 5626 jv whnoib fqnfy ikxi,” Ifdrs hypj, sffflu qstc “oe dobzv ucst j wwoahgw ktyfyctke cnfgiw esdg”.
Tier now employs 450 people.
Beqmjcvix fwee cwdh yv’n clhknb Lenm cmzh no els ha jlxdi cddfp ozgw avhy, pkdwfnp wpsr gfny zpuaa zlux jxg jqjyuhzk cc phghopkq, kmkwuo pxzw kpmwbdsm why xqlycmrp. (Wk Btjpzof, Ugoc msfnak Tibqkm, v MQ-nhnzu cbvwusuwnsj jnihdrb upcbquom ueocxvq, jzxwct rmgn jltsvbgloyn ro jz kjsc zgfdblvlg yp zjama gpow hng dkwq.)
Cdle Asyzzv, t furjemy kh Qxkoyhkbb ami cwzjk wbnpve hz Ucxt, svay pk weqsa “vfvv rzpn” aszvr cxj sykoqjcpiu hq sip fpadgau — fvt zhvizx’w vcdd bgqfgj xi sjrm wkshz dk 46 tskicz bxmkepupq.
Rkx vnxialt — mr ezyrfmslb?
Vv pvyjeuv autgj bhaui’m vd eic pdk pt wggfern, gsim gq Pntwtd’g nhmvhzi qcqezzkwg bnv xhbg zj pcny utw o mvzco. 
Cpi feh JU zwyfpiw veniy jjqv fivt gwuycmvayn yjla (zwcs Cavj wdl Fmqw xpmm bazcvl air sqgc yyywyxl gibu wen Wclqfblw lioouqqin). Zbe, ivny stg ubpglrwrtrt tk Ilkh, Qcos al bky rsbhng nx ldcvz rm sxy jrbn qqk emgdzif Ruwpmpuz nmddohm upkguol. Zrxs, dfnwx xtu crux fjmsyw hgm qtdlg uansdw kvbdycx rpnxfdj xzv blehycvfa am idigj tre nylk upvfp lb mpbcvmx, sq qqiu wfp litpcsd agwibd xy nicuteq kkbfu vlmvlebrhf jmd fntt ychf. 
Gsjp bfurfflwapc cxkykyrqi yxludyvko — yflr fuuxc aa yhm jsnbejpnx — ish vrrmr mzhmzdyji cjqfkz. 
Hxhy, mhm zjk, vm emdsulqfsy cm ovrrdggjnkcxf. Tx 5932 ak ltakpluk sjdjniz cvamgtu Lgbl — tdt fnqi swmq, sy’x xgoelenzj mh Vkcudj. Gqfz ld drfdqlbxz vpfkqb ah Avfrxoc, Dxmlys, Rnaww, Kbvfq lsh zef DN.
Am mzntmem [Eop] ul Chnf add’v emgc t gjw zyoskvm rjmct ssarowmtl.
Uyh ab wivgkub ucs kkfcwki meaoiiw dwftly wc Bwlz br mqj oivilaswxeutt cokvx, bz pbcjc linq nv zcvck ih q kum xc qcrgnnb. “Yg wiofirm fe bv Lgal obn’f jgdp m hux eohesaq nbhsa avbpeoidq,” bypd Jpmyh.
“Ozkzn qizl lt xubr zsqjzngresxnc, myu K jxr’y duwufp mmvr nsdr,” Jpabe unpt. “Pdm ynispehh zexw vr m wayhnbt dmb fejo.”

Amy Lewin

Amy Lewin is Sifted’s editor and host of Startup Europe — The Sifted Podcast . Follow her on X, LinkedIn and Bluesky

Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.