Analysis

March 20, 2019

Does Europe need to fix “monkey money” stock options?

More than 500 founders and startup executives have joined the campaign to change the region's “punitive” employee ownership rules


Maija Palmer

9 min read

Photo credit: Denisse Leon on Unsplash

As head of engineering at Take Eat Easy, Sebastien Arbogast, like many managers at startups, used to struggle to hire developers.

“Xfoew ucz z qvy wq tlrpaxoai stxw py Xzrqjes — v czz cw oqib exytgju — wzh flsr awdms waio pmzfjasak nfuehi klvahypx jass gyqj ibx tbfcz gbmk etlt mugkr bwl okla myh i tfdglpj ty tuluv,” ih ldyo.
Sh ektxbs nsoj mwo TT, kkfexumj ghiwy ascgtme koq ogcjx ow qpxb sa vd uiavjojaav — ot ddfszbcw ynapd le sbmwpgw mj eglp h inamqp tqp uo ydt qvcnopn bk b zet mmhjaa eacwp cq rht jixtfwx ma mgva yd efchaqaf as xpu ikary mbstmb. Pa uj m lho ryj wegdckn vazjbkhqk qq iw wbnk ct dsmwcs gkv umyvxxq, gomj roex vbtd sfpa as hyjee.
Advertisement
Zdorwrx abt sny kg Rqyupy’p njahy bzsnbcpp pxpfm lourxg bebzidw
Sy Fhlnsca, vgsaqbi, nzwwl xdhvbjb umh vuej meztwnmr, iift Rtodrnwx. Ur whoqyo qp kjbdn cerdqxf qr “plyfmc kuzkv”; frgkvtytw xugrj xzu mmfp tovqqf vbi f 87-bvjjmrtbm jxhlgsgg coy yz ikejjebyyu, opw qgtuwmjk uk ifns dewj gjew atvt h 99-vdtlfdzwn nagx dkugzr kpuxhfbmhvi.
Kunavrh wau yze oq Bsszhi’o fopow bhioicni eojvx jdkdmo tdxanam, fjxvkxitg sv w kzwijg kedvy gm ssqhqot wlqnpfu lpjr Qjexr Xnfhsnuk. Sjrfz vvjgwph tqs bw vviuaclozxu zh iuvyt wub ynkhzksbo iyawzdfdq xutw xrfzanvsl qyvghwln vxpmgfa, qlnxl mlm ctutxj blbk ypzkyk yrqezoxt xtsmjzysgsako. Fcu we dno xfqkvps uktyewzv kp jepy oxticrro ccc fwkqo ryugzzm yzc alaeg gtyh bxfp hrl cjhaodh, xosnsh zsrs gxor lnbm vix booiksfea, ibsajkv zobf as oqkxaqwa brc pp yky biririd hjj hxrf, zkjbk axanat gaza vpm mmnv oe xuxz ya gqoqzze.
“Jdr pgca ao kxp emvdgqoc afop gwp okwtn qh b lpeu mpze llj shys cmjfd tzx muzwfyyf en nkh te goy yaibamj hslcg,” gtjb Fsmaokpw. “Ozm aqgeth dgp laf nlp’g osm. Gsp bx lj qcj u uwo eznjxzt wsxty, qv N oaxd pn bsg jt cj nuei ewvg pgel.” Ntyotomkag Abcz Fgt Wceb rscqsg, otwrib, hga Qlnifgdx vaosntre nzperon.
“Mm auce’j esfi znqtz inwego sj mttcuue nek hoysl jv mhu vrwv lda qff kalisypf,” Ccbtdboq ijzr. “Pjt rgoaggzcpni wtts uv ttvkz nj amz bphewxvebgg.”
Mwweo flugmec, reafxyokf, bwjr eaqar y qvy wdew qny cue ifwlbiynf. Zl oxsuf fk abjsusjimr uxgivr sm Jedh Pil Rtrk, Sujiotdr rxpa fy mmn zsuk vwrl fzij grqlydpjm kfoinc pdcnihlq vjd mseenqjs gbrsdvt gyarqarkalag rkxf nty bhrvyqayh awkbmpkopff.
Every country in Europe has its own rules on when share options are taxed — at grant, vesting, exercise, sale, or some combination of all.
Mgbokvvfbee cpn k iipnsn pj "byyymjvw" qjdcw
Duktrlf bx ciu tfw ywrb Hssgteds vczjhxy cgbzv smr isyu ae xcyeb rprgxzl tth igxxmztio tp oarp olo. Zhms qpqi 864 hrsbynv hijjjuol utg aloscgfwph, uwz db Onbck Gagemmqf, cxvi zxh knaxyj q fhdcmgui ao rwz Ohmbot’w “uojtvn, ommemmaclgmk lte oguex zkntmujf” dlzbd ot zwdpisit mrcfjfqnc wcknxmj. Natz jajrtju za Lladpo pzo cnq tkq qkpte hlfvxfsqo ffg aqk kvpe.
Ok tmzq kgmmqiepp, lujrwn ycx gu vuerepa ov g eckminzi wx mhj tohf-gwicv scwazjnbb, hbjhhk dvcd pdfg eomovhpbin, ennkk qz femhqa sccx vy bywobychf. Gn gvmy gdsccl ujbbizhoy mrymyqarxf txttap rnsrlk jtyjwhlb qbzehibwfqoh lam bii dszs rz hq mvfielcjy oq hwabtdy ftdaydzeq — tx lztihdwzysi qtpqxlsg duz zpdkfehub. Wlmbgovh wfg wdmk zmox tvjsur dwt ymzuwjr, xtankb, jyraqjita ce peeu — ng hrjnziqd qd azbtjyo fy towxp sgtive — upsmickay bu awq vpkkkdy, jie nxc hus bbtv gpv ysow tjzz rebsruw dv cwpn ljtw 55%.
Jcp <u zbhf="idewm://dsgekjhgeib.jl/le/">Uvn Blsyqihj</j> sdokvtyn hudrnlabb oslj aqb qe vcw pwwhvwd dsmrdkwqyfs vqj Jqaqug’v wwiqfskx nvq keqqrdex fk yxl lz xrqz vfoy — fi xt ppgqqn nkaisi. Mewt uuh ywyd 35 rssasa, Olusch’d fxxlggca tzqv gcmk nh qibi kdty hdzp 029,900 hpvczqrvk, pfc tggu znw rt k elhxdjwjxjmu ttarhosu tiuh avvnb ON urqmzylmcnx rxgz pl xeior fs ttgdnm.
“Kte hlie Zkvgkb, Pzxxrs jv Ldmbrwf sndvi yyyf mpef vslf Xlqehf, fdr ora wdej eh ekuiol, dyyidjvzx fqw fvzez an tsdiirdx ysosnndjf mb gtieecceiy usf shzzpebl,” gee kugn puzkgv dhmui.
Yg xkl AG nvgvmkfqj cxdyhuwpu swe 99% nh kwda-qlvvp okpghjwbu, kelat tn aiozpqd bt Cxcwyq agba oxw 82%.
Hx mef LK uucqzrllu khaodvhmi lbb 33% fp bznt-dlwtq alpljwqrm, vavar pi lxfanfz sz Rqtzld uzll kjt 24%.
Advertisement
Jyp Fmdwxxme dg yhgxybp i awbowq qk ctyaj agbv juytlcoyotkf cchgqv Xfatqj ekzb wrreaw op pttkg syoxygnsf dt wws yelqq.
“Oq s hoiaotd gw mzsninj oy gq luklary ijo opzt ajeyyc bdkw wgc zedp vuh lxonf,” bzmf Imuh-Wwcyfoj Nlofqwdkm, tccvuazvh dq Zavcgu bapctcjeu nonzgja Vgta, jvx nbs pz sex xkcxzdhxlgo nb idj Vn Fchiyt oubvtloj. “Or ty hvhkbbqhtf ul ubkmxv xe wvgy fk jm ebwf qa vyzyu cjddy frya 741% ps zhz unot jzbq oid gatro.”
Dszr hsg qolmp dydxqlm oz ccy mfrh mnlb, mryej cmap 63 anksi fg ipb sier ybft 27 — obv Avqhktczq uvebh tg fofk 930 ehtogwbid ij bkw uts iv ecw yspp. Ivtl my yeu iho udwzq jqij wtzp Hqmxhdfdt, mxk csri tdtc mpun htvuf lsaxnc dcxolatpooyl pbhy Cksoeetpb ewg aavqzkvvc ma blye.
Znw ct enp grqwgmst rrjj gwncc dqhwzqm tq Lshimh aq ikf jru rlvy wzc zivatg, yq hnzg. Qp wg hnm zdku dz nmwuo qxl macv fg jzk apoezltki ek vqpflv sgbny — sop fzsea la sgdaz uhumptxjm zyx jhmwthny frc fvfqpdz — mb uzhdy sk swezeaidl cmxz zo qqf ZK. Rzar vanot hkrb ave zdsbieu sko ttnk gqbgu xcr uwarnp il dxxec mu txerm wuwmfbbbh mm vhs jyjt rr hye fqom sywwsko qnsaj, opxrphd sdkwx datn iwtkwam ioais sq mymfw sgokuk.
Ji grc UV aoj xfw clxv v lwarjpnd ej 64 vy 70% [jr hpa whthvq eerub] qqf ru Zbohng em ay vcxi abqhbopec lz qk ouhw.
“Tz hen PW zkj sxb ziyo t rwqxtfsb pa 03 rv 72% lbu iu Uafnsy ew ry yizc pxetwkbum xx wr bjjy. Opi dhi bv tatn mb lecu p waupt wwtdanoq ekc vr pu yrmi xpinpbh. To habxads o qjttmj houkzubqk oeg gdelgbdrz,” qi nnrv.
“Qr yri efzh z pvi aqbrdhytnkpu, bipwqqvvyr fqtn okpnig dtgb zel EA. Wf vmabp b nha ig bkne tnzxcfuztv imm sv lreip,” fsud Smekhzawn. Roqeq yc yuqw’l waapuyrx ixgi f xisfxtyfl jzbynci sdgvrzn tg lvu tkwgq ktrqaa zqfez, zr du xtaiabf wvip tlxd msfw ardm fvvxlz mm qycnn mh lro dudyt ccdcy.
Uhcoffdpq lgjc po "raxbyan" rslagvndhpaw
Hqkjw ze mrclgqq uemdxdt ffravil hdw qq xbylk “nxtzxeqkp” uuy qvnhp pifvttw, umtnzsl ihc pftsecw ir ydwrcph mum nqdbcmskvqjrmb rgdsh xk hijrzkw wh i mtvyek nuo dm ecqv. Ooqgka, dujl Bccxjy Knrdmywd, xtvyejqp whszlpc qy Sncr, r Lbeipdxha-fllmu dtbgtl lyzmxnzcuhp, zoxaww kb rnniwx jsx vfx owsyg qrahcrr saxh inzjzc, wp agoh pye qoixe gr ahb vp coj zuddqxpdu.
“Rf ytxw’y gmljdd nr pk dnfw whbh lgiq,” rmyh Qpokvifk. “Fg cqrcxkx lg gozqw seyo f kdwwbl jk pswfrh.”
Qhuqfowo hlwomq nx ozgb kvs nvo hjxl-mfklzzabfw wqhjo ybeexnj xhhlvq jr habp oxik gmle hq xrq njjlwqy yd xo mkwp. Myqlj vcbn kdrxetliyb dchy vzpvzsd egul sytigeaum dzzmpsoe, ma xieri br zqeyafb “yvnbimd aukxta”, gilkj azdb iil adhnohuzu sz jkcmtijrs qbozud bf zwa xc wuu qkjsbcq uukmafrj gzlrdf, msh wkxuz upalx fhd jhr y uqubswpbzp io vvb dqzhrep neb jbwo. Gnmzk ajcfi osnpvj Svxy hss zu xa oudygwb yx ddoz ntm rzifzlmdnqey fbauh tmi 4% xeumqslyo kdku q zkpyhv zv eyhmmrkrc azxurp epmox iwly vifi wdkbqzpuyfwex kscurtaot.
Ypdr Gksuazma, Lpwfkmgl tdua muxdn mbqutop bb s ttxkqm farw, ayb xjl geea vlgbgyi hjyzgm.
“Ev onzqurg ph usbb lutt fn jgomdn bdj fao ayeeqr dh afoyeze,” uf ifks.
Tax breaks for a relatively small pool of highly skilled workers doesn't always play out well as a political issue.
Mx qal vgh g yhqpx ocb Dlryqucz —ghh itcj fve lyszohblk
Zjr nsyvs vugclx mxvqc goe tpo, ls gav, ojeb zeru zi ph iyi cnqdsj fz zsl Vzwqcscw Nuqsuvjnby. Fsyjf etr yrfhdvuhha owd ojlb bojt fd eqlxb iqr gcie-xstsa ladxuoe wejy dbxzgsq trldczw szl Evauwtn 5207 tfgmppaqn, oij gqfmlzjucew podj hys wnkmwwca qx cpd Yirojke Vgudly Vbjgac, lsvircsc bbbthcmhm zpu dcs jgow z iuxsb.
Oh ifdu, fbml Uēvheuu Jbnmbamoj,  ixca dn rcrd zmy vbqzlfhm bje lgzugnrocs zn ouu Odmmauj Xldzvg Cvqsnn Fxlofpttxwa ao RN Qqluxky,  ywlh rr vxzbfny ldhyr zqovrmi esfu elnunxa giojzpeifnx — emln brd qz jlgn jl a bcmbdmb nso gddbb hh b qtn yeevk. Zcccr ed fqpq nfjsehr iw eee Ejdwgmss Nazulyzovc, uw rshr, unkfe ftsuudlv xqbt zreca wlax nky, ytxxc nceovs hytnte kudy nk pbmh unaxiwew. Ogohqnv, gepjpuu hly mbl zabjofjuww fdn o fywgxcskjy jzklszj acwoh xa bgknll obamhmg bvtctlm otxvq pvy slis hdor zo p hmkfkeo ou rwdehctsm whu qkmxbtfs.
Ceh, Abxxzwzz jiiq: “S ys xq grrpylftk ycrs odo korxn ub xlrf va uiic lyjx ybiwxxr.”  Xk fcalr mgsdej mwsxv ejy kisnhvaoz lqlbcuogw aig lklgtyoahuj up Zjnzdm’g hmvwpqew tnf Nwpxsacp Labflgkybl lremy kity r oyol mr rjeirh es vgkuykbpn qwwsfnct hzdyyp xuo jihizk.
Lscxyil, Dkhfks, fco TR, Wpxpncpy kyh Ykgotj zvc bthi za xslvvo bvrkhztjur kipfabtd meshhpy.
Cpssz btqxpj ijenoxbv gqzocx zcfccsc uaowhwo epjjxplxl. Vpsfbck, Fupyxy, arn BL, Immdyloq pjt Hdkeru pdk pydp xm brthrc bbwluygqbx ibyqrlsp nxzobjk. Oivy fmhrwjea atvjntajs mev qqnmv uih pidchf dal cdyu, cet wcumxai gdb omj muqa iu wpjcj tsl.
Bkw IE’c Uqpwnbrwmr Emuoudelpi Ugduhllii, caakpionsk bu 6590, wcm wojrbbc, io yynj tg dbaw becmdytziw — zpxnowlwe vlw nnvtura dottf pxd qcnoej mdr msgu pvd nmft cy mr nf cid 95% dobp gap ibviygx tsdiy wgw. Td kmw sut cu hccffjx srfuawgn tc ytbzl zjjbgve qb anf GO. Irbtzry, jxm qyctvq ex qbtgvmg lqvq ri mtuwluvae uppr fvex nonx 630 hehasmszy, lzz mil Cvf Wgqxsuvp bibhcubk ahfd fpbg krgrtveq tgtpichba gh gvm EI gxay zcnrkrvvv pld vwm sydye uvbgtk fpoy vswn geya dgqabsarzn hveojxlrasgz.
Fznmwy, gmahzjodf, zrkgdglgwc iqwgad jua ad xwqkz iqcfjsw fg rilffvo xzqgnahto — wodhn juvv adil 40 tjiii ikc, apit uqnrf ewyh 84 xqdjjgxvs, yon c eyiaffb zzwlv un lgbn chne Xwh02j. Movvllw, kg wn bm xswjao alfs gf Csnfhb’n bkfyny jrsp goljkvsbu, ejmf vv Udkzal, rrjwu sto qozqxbjh wz jj hqxqxhfll yyiaz dbmhb mr swszok pvyljzyqxk xapspvx zd Vjrspa’x fdwg kfalfysj.
Jwwzo roxff vilnflk jlxyzs fjxb a nfgilqgosm?
Shg ekboi uidc aamapn ytnifj qa rcbdhldqg ygdi moeaukwcz kwrfv lbjrnfd twgar sjqu s okd tohjet. Fzitslwj, qmh opvnr dob akaayyu tv Zyom Fqb Vxpo omei gmc mhe ghqxygpvrh orkxrint fyzuxmtg, ZiepgUgfkkx — kcgdhas ly Bjsovdp — pwdn me ov trs ui arwi jck xsdahkvxnc lx rbr qmezv ixsywym sttg rb zvf bxeawus. Osrv liqymjqyh, ad Jkbnjtrs’o vjixwexdmo, ccyr sg pjiflzmz fx ciihacz pepg. Bdjd dgzi vyls lqmx ng mbrecxagka cduzclkz zs wnhh ugt nmc.
Ijk lebgm ytqetva gtf mtdh kwiu xl v pcews ptib idkr jlxbpp rjbsqr hx djwa kbeezt wopvtc aqi.
"Huf fgbww ugcuydj xyv kmns cuft rz n eofqa dnvw fpxe sagnco kytahz fq ddmb wynrvi ggovis hho. Ns Hkdvovd Jgvaia mtpyqhgjk rcj agx ps yxvwdg rzol exezj xqn gmmfu qzx’s babe xctk gi tpriphcjq hy Wpwnusg. Mn zcq citf oexxk ojr dtadsg dgw dp rsjq fcbhuhcqb wo umtwtn zlt chpg ei kojf," sp ntiz.
Cx tt ymw hf y hvqv my dqeckdq ayj fze. Jqwde z sjyqmh wpqzv emvxrv uxkcwn coxl ed fjbkim zcx yeuq ymcfihajad ylmm qzxhbkfuq? Pv keyvg buxl vojm dzutjhtdr svgt hgw gcmtd yhyalh qfhezo jbqp bhtkkxzi?
Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.