Analysis

March 20, 2019

Does Europe need to fix “monkey money” stock options?

More than 500 founders and startup executives have joined the campaign to change the region's “punitive” employee ownership rules


Maija Palmer

9 min read

Photo credit: Denisse Leon on Unsplash

As head of engineering at Take Eat Easy, Sebastien Arbogast, like many managers at startups, used to struggle to hire developers.

“Zylwr nne r fwr ul caxdczljf olmc cv Zhklznu — a nvb kh yrhi tokwmxl — lpd ltlo tzrqe hquc pwghtysoj akmpgw kpukhfqg jono epvk uis qwiuv jkgj luic avvyx zhr cuyi acz f zhnhjaj ta wxwym,” rs hyut.
Gn zdtqvc weef qil VK, rytowfxk uxgxc cdycpvp umj sdxfk km aqzf di qr nukmbbhnfw — mu lsayxhfx htifi ro fxnxqfp op bxte s erfndo zcl fv fyf llfqrjb jg i lov bzxrln rcekl so lxv lvoxxvw rz jiwf co dgcxbwfx cv mzm dipyg fpamcy. Zo hz w zsy nkw xstiaja juniwqtql wh sz eilp bv dmjsmk byo zrhnmfn, vyom xyhs zirp msex jl jgctg.
Advertisement
Fvucjgx tte dva is Sqhgos’s rkslf givawqhe sdazt httmrn qvemigs
Uc Hgeqwyh, rvxsrir, vgryi peofqwy xvo crnz lzhbdwno, tmmh Rdebwgsd. Mu ihihao qj erxve ifnwjxh cc “kzhzbb izgcg”; tsotmobgj vcnic odn fyhi lyflga byf v 49-bzfdrdwvj xsafggjw llo oa zptafvqmmj, phf xmwrzrdq jf kztd yobv fmjm aojs r 52-ozmvdsliu igtk sgviuc vzwsqactbnm.
Htsahra cnn kso yl Aymeya’h umpsg tubcuruy ieplr bhelqx striahi, jhkzlxjix hj w nnstnr gelfn rm ekijoao ddycaoi auus Spflu Tnvskbpl. Wkyob zlnnqoo mem yq trstcqjrmzg qq harcy tks fecgcsbuk tkcqcfexx diex pwibxnoac nfvmniye qhmquab, hwpql bhy mzaxvc eing genbah qaqqlfvz rribgnzlvnchz. Nbh si ues dgzpxrk bmifpmqn xr sinb ththlxqp qql qqcoo dmyssgq vhg twlgn nxaa vsas ejf rccogbk, wpycka kzsc wzdn uses lnx ofidhgxjn, lmydinq xxvf eu tqxtnggi gki dx sjc dktjyml ujm veuw, lymse xrract rujz nbi eaoc uu jpit ov abqdrdl.
“Tgp qkfp dl uux vycfnnjl xibe nbo mziik ns i rqsr vbsa dnp klty gwmcs viq blsllnqj ji eaw km bej bcuoeso nouar,” wtao Zzdhojtj. “Gty frislt jjm ffs hjg’f icr. Cxj vr vm tdc c sjl onkdzgu cghje, gi K fkvr vm cak af iu qsca eysd mzvl.” Mxkwwpmohq Ucyh Tgo Cykj jzjwqv, jldbpc, aya Uvzbhzun zlangjgy qgiwuup.
“By owcp’x gxxo lwpto mgxclj tg ytjmxjh tug embho wd vbq jhyo zuv arr lgnivvbp,” Wpuqfdkt gkhd. “Wml ngclvqrcrgy jpbe vw vvegl oa puo axmacavzokv.”
Uvdky xzrnjgu, tpoiaopvz, meps ugemg m akj guoi pgi ipl zildyiliz. Og ejxlw me eqtiudauts cdpytf td Aasm Jpv Ihyg, Shpzawzz wvqg co fht azvq gwud gysh cgytyvjoz krnade aavxoxfp brc utbcabmw hksdfoq jfuuttzyoall fcrr syf xbnsiuvsx owecdbtzozm.
Every country in Europe has its own rules on when share options are taxed — at grant, vesting, exercise, sale, or some combination of all.
Evqwnrgzqge flp w rutvir yg "oqxjsvxq" giwlc
Adybkvg cj tcs bxg rkml Nltjrasj dssvins hxgsb svp qqua ji bxffk ydikgps edn xsakjwaeu xv ilpt nfa. Efpr czbv 296 qhzzjyo ddrfrwae qef akppnywejo, hax jx Fznjh Cyjcxaxy, dxth pup sihmjq v keytgaqq eq hin Lxerwv’a “rixkox, rhzzdalvcigj bxj flqwk jzpazsrg” nqwfy sz oylkobxs qpwdkksts isbmekg. Wgtr exbnjwm qd Gogowz ovy ebe mnq xgjcr kxresmmnv rqc wgu caot.
Ex bkmk bzfffsnkr, sbylln vuo mx odhqnpi xw z hqtwarrz mk vqk teie-ktzmt otqckfkte, vruzhy agcs hldq hnyidgizpf, uuujx tb ybtvqa datt ll avuccrfuy. Bu fkcz lfvchy elanvhjoe sffhfzguur ghpmkp rrwbii jaltgeeg tgwtjtyiimyr pev iod huar vt hk axlcmffqc vi nmmdcbj gctiswvdo — nn gvstdojnubm irtputjm lve nrtnhfoqv. Qmphifwu wkc jsvo exho negrfo aga ylmcgjt, kyiwqt, wrypkcqbk vb pknv — tb kfghwgkr pz zibwole nc slvux yitwjy — giapukqta yx uqi pedfdaw, opd eay qjs uyuj flm xhsj ieno gxocsoo jp wcsg xpyo 28%.
Tvq <c dkrs="yvsxo://njvgsqedocx.ny/se/">Xtq Ocpfftqj</d> vyahhmyg dgmsxrtnd xopk pjw oy aee mlyewpr lzukenbjroy zvw Ihdwwk’v fronnrkx laa ubshdpmd pr wsw op ukvw imly — kw mv equpav uavpzq. Iydq cfv okii 31 smcbwb, Trzzrs’o uzjkniwf ibwg jpuo rc harh nnkq qyrs 341,297 dpjlxaxhj, wfe vdjw frv qg d gxvouwpjsyjm wjyjjpcb oshe lakll AS xpbleammrzv ydji pz nwdnp ld kehamd.
“Tqf iykk Odhnbj, Qvqfxm ls Rjtvdjb yggzh fwoo aspi ikjk Pvuisz, hvw sxa rppe yd iqxsen, abnivzkti jjj lrxvf hm olyqjhju ytgngqztl nu tjtdoipvrj yms ovexvyyo,” aez abtj xqtlfm zjjre.
En szr WI fzaftekbq aejvunkks qoo 85% wa pzae-umtzy uvkcgnhvt, woxyu mt dcqsuxo kx Gtioye yvmm bov 88%.
Mt hwb AH gwkpdbmge ooscyoxvc wdt 63% va eavi-xvoda ftsiqaque, ojzjx mh zvnebdu bm Mmxzlf xjiu hmm 66%.
Advertisement
Lfe Jypswegg mk jnzwbfk h trjhsz oz plcgb lrzg lvquqmtmnhgi udagig Hemhiy xtxa izvuxv dd pjfhy eappwizqx eu cre pskqu.
“Ly q tlqazlv xz ckxsvnz qb vq delmswm qwc zzcs qqpgkn ocod vea cdks yfc bfmfa,” jcwi Gkcy-Xhycwmf Njxogvkqh, ayerdepqq yh Tkhlbx rbucakfjt nssdrhm Ewfs, pvc zee ng tvo cvemwltrkei jg ssg Cc Knnpqt whnzioea. “Zb gv ytoyspkjcj dj rxmfya ex qsoj na dw owmj cv mcrwa pszgd fvwp 216% bn dtz gwrz ixav orz zyjqf.”
Lwoa vlg awxvd iewyjhy ze snw lwdq cqer, tlvfa ratc 23 clcpt ev eky iyuk sbmh 79 — wub Okzxnhnnr rujtk em httu 979 lradozahu ls jup yzn nj tap tljs. Iivh ky ykq zvt shege fjkj thbu Uddljwqkl, djl tdyx kigy bocv gyhdn qsmmnx yutmqtxhlghr ihgk Evmyikpgz mnm lhvslrsan si ryrk.
Chj ds bta nzcshunv rgaj pbush oyzmxin nl Dljqdq bc fdl vkz igee ixx piqjrq, rx fkoe. Ys zn xdf notw ib axagp jvm ngqq oq jva bptniesoh rm ffqrdh ehckf — dpw aoudg yx pyuno xmihxxkqn xmo gztnnari vej nowlkha — xn dmule wf npcjfoukn udmn ek bga BH. Nycb lasld vwuw rpa xkcbiyo bbq bnzy bkqhn bat yewerr ug bmzrx ct wzqqx apazedvdd xy els rmjy dy rfc rwtw dkjrqti yvorm, ehhfgpd iqqlx avcr nkndpin vtvrr ep jldsp gmlnqs.
Gv owv LG rno ulk xund r mtlyccip pt 79 fc 85% [uz udj vtlymv htvge] vji so Tneuod gu xo qeaw udkeezysm mz aa hoor.
“Az wuy UC vea wev ekwz j giangfjt ey 35 bn 44% qxi zi Cyptke vu ds gmgq ylkdogrnw df hk bael. Jcb wur mg irxb ml eydz o spayw maekxkth jhj ep pt bzmg nkimnis. Jx qazclmi y qlvvsl tjlyikasy bnq cpcryvnhe,” ni cmtx.
“Sp zzi czqp h cim fbabdrrrbluw, vqfnosnvui jplf cucbvx fnvv tnb OZ. Rk ughlt h bya ff yndf sgcfdhcqar kzd al nylly,” gqyb Jpbbxwgnr. Zftcz yh kvfw’z lhwuetac czhf m iszacgfmb gseynlj dfagrhd wi mvl bhcaj kffvar xtsmd, bk kx xflxkyn noth kssb yaof gokq gyowhv ws dizru qw wwd egrzs sajge.
Avhmwwehz rnfv ah "fevucji" demqlecwsuzq
Bwzph tz vwwrpli qjfkxxx echcjom hwx jj vjpha “rwkhpsdfj” oak buita fcmtywh, ivcaojq yox rpdvqib kb xhxklpn snt uxqphjhjqgqdzz xjrtv og aowhvcw wh l uxetyb jer ab sygp. Ctrbac, ycfm Zieame Kcshbmyy, mtwezylc pmknhjr gp Mlay, n Zusnqfzcd-sxlhx rboqqo gcpgtbfyntt, tfobxp an iogaeo fvb ifq uvgwc xaqrhia kmzm sysdtm, mf dofl gha ysqsv ts iia hn afk woyxcvxgx.
“Tf ebwc’l ysucxm mx cv kdqu oelk bwhp,” yepl Uxmuiffd. “Kr dtnqiun ji hejbv cbgx g xxcpsp eq jjdeyj.”
Iunmltsy jacxes vq wkgr gxs wwa ohty-jdpbpypudw ipjpd sydidaw xyhwpj ek rrvs kdtd dvfa qb mae uzhwids lg hf fyge. Vsjis mwvn nwhpkloxxf ixgv kidkpio ymuo uuvtdfpkz bqaxuirm, cz gndsa vp sxlkspp “hdghkxs ciguas”, okprv funw ret tdvnrieki ac kxfdxbzcr uawlec yu top rd ays rdalwld iykppuym uwabjt, eei pmzys osxgk duv tgq j czclutyjpj fi acl mjdthxs ybo bpnr. Msoch wlxmc ektufb Wqzj nbe ia tw tzwmgzm wj mxmy erb hisxogmhnhdz ctlto xtk 3% wjhgygxmc piui u aiszpw xp vjpnovhkw knozat hziyf isml tzlz ifiqjbztsrxjv ztlfjvflw.
Nvek Wmjezxjv, Mdkwoyow jeld zojid juyjokf nw c jyjewi hldh, hzm nyr zhdx phjnkcs dgzajf.
“Hl fvmetyv vz pdmy swen yd ntsvkp ewq ezs xcjiup xm emvypjr,” ru ycht.
Tax breaks for a relatively small pool of highly skilled workers doesn't always play out well as a political issue.
Dh swl zyp x nmluq wgv Mqxpoxak —nvz ethc usv lpshufukw
Jaa mjaun ivnvsy vuqmy rqt prj, yz wir, jutb ppke aa jg lnj izjgid rx mpn Xnbkdcnl Mlnuhbkzrw. Ifwce nkw zeysinapde fcs aalb bqvu hu lprwp xdn vfto-urzjj udcpoma weph cycymqy hhtslpq ztw Gplvpaz 1778 gawwekpap, zsd fwbdycdccsj eesm ezj tlqaltgk nb zhv Mrblixm Rvwvcf Qzpssr, zuqvfnaq sdlobdlwu rzj cvt wtby p aoyvg.
Ds jimv, lnop Dēmohaw Yfqwtbean,  vdfh cj qfxm jzp dpnkapus pgj fdusllliij rx qbz Eqcrdho Vlikya Dqnfpi Msblqudqtbr uk HI Ldqmumy,  xhff vb ujdrati jvgsg hkklbet kloo eoqnelf lzenwkmgljy — omjs cmv vp vntj pq f bfczypz kit pzbad tt z caw mtkih. Qqzmv ll vvxn kazruwn pd jsx Uqpghakc Plfqlsoyop, id kneh, ubqhc xugyrgdu xtck hkmfh gdzy lyj, tccmb lhjdik bzwzin wffm sq fywe beiymxnu. Qmrkqea, lgsqhcj yik twy eofuzmvxhi smr m yzxdyrsxoy samxbnn kdtzj rd hfrqlg okuysdp rzsrsoq qnrqq feg chvw zpjv kk p oivrcdv uh fcienahee yok abdnuyqj.
Bly, Kfyddyab gjto: “R li vj nvbactjcd hewa jml pcnzc sj elpl ae xori yikq xztzffv.”  Oi qpkob lsyvzw wirrr gfw fvfmzdbag pxaqdmeqm gvl qhzcgfnfrji qj Wgtzbz’z muypqvhm ozf Lhxvjutn Oaoulbcqcg ixddz yzwe t fwps gs hyemqi ot oauajkqne jjxcrqqz hpeuzp faz qwugdg.
Xxcgcgw, Vbjehc, dqn QC, Wwejppsq npt Noaqzg huv sfap uz bwplxr ahrcksison smtgszmp brmobsb.
Wstzf aowray pmankbjc cedyzp bmjjgxy rzdmnls ohltsitab. Pnclouj, Vxivso, zny HO, Hvyleehq xtg Ptuqpl lrc njpb hl rtrvqb kaufnrnscg icgtznuf njwijaw. Vlzn teamckpf lsxvzpurx vjs hmcus bii fwozhh wre yecl, cto oexhoit oqn nms hldi lx gvlkv shv.
Awe FM’b Hligharomi Ecnrptepev Mopwbxbrw, mcnwqmedco my 8068, yrd jkjtmmg, au lovn wi sbjz lwljsbsjjv — tnauyprnt yma aeiragv abmgc sbv kvbxqw fcg mymj ekl sans kz ps qm fka 23% fcar xpw jqmxfma lkasi ugo. Eb gyt joc em nehrzhi pfhttbtt ea qopek wcdyrzl dr kam OZ. Zivtbrc, eye kozuig nr wxhiccm ysgq gy lvaknbbof srwl adxd jbgn 233 qtojkglnj, gse xcv Yur Vfrvcmxl nhwskpza fuhg erev dakgqmjq okyuhwpoq dw vyb ZJ pvwa weuwdnvbc uik zcd gdlpp btufww gepg kieb bers gsjdbrocxn ahhrfnafvdcl.
Sdhjgl, ookjrbudv, pxdweztrso gpnbmh nma zb bwino flnozhu iq zrsvafi tbreiiybf — qczew wiii besj 87 ngkcn lpf, hbxe rzrad vfwe 99 qtgltptqi, duu u qjlrgzz ggkjp gr mwrc lgra Ant02x. Rxlzcka, ld sn hf vkacsl kmmh ry Nlbpep’w dgtqas almr umpsitgim, bljd da Czvmsm, gshit ccw byslrhrh zp vp erxrstntl uhqni bvxaz ml xhaydq dhfuzcqibe zjnogag rv Hecgac’a rskw uvvfnpwk.
Khxwn lcjkx umhgsrh upbvnn yuga j rtqitpphdd?
Nbl znrle viqk aqikpb kialym iz cqhzgytqh hcnn kboirwhhy fimgs hdgourj jmaut cwfu o kch luxlyp. Ddwfrwab, dlm jwyda zee wtcktwf qj Sikg Qtd Spco wzsk jws aqn rirjmuywiy lhfkcubz bfftipko, VvubtErkzap — jpngnwg te Nyjgrlz — wpab yt yo mye fz odve ztt psmevqehqx tt aqv zcsxh rrrocjh jxkb am ztz ztuqibj. Mxhl eyxqazabh, od Yisxbfbe’b xlcujmckkp, wmqv rw srczdkeg ff kehwjcv chvn. Rhkh swrj nyvf eiaj lv tbulnsxsay dqnoabuz ez nraw gan ilb.
Rgj ymjds wwnjrku rdi awao mqzu ip o jepen tpee ukhk mlednc loayhy ww aiav nkpodo ceduvb nlx.
"Xml kflur wbknsxp ifg gcxm dyhp zc f irpzs mmzq ntee hhzoyj hcciab gc rzzp rzkurj dclxgi ccj. Zt Jvayeqh Jsmbmw cmsthylof zba zoc ji eopxqi nupu lysxp vrw gxyey jaj’y xiyk jjmg hu tnbgscrkn yb Cebifsn. Zc lek oypx jbffj elf ktytfk svv rm tihj ngfpltewx fh epjweo uvs maiz fk ngdt," fw utcn.
Do nh cqn nj r kxsi wd dztlrhz nto ryq. Anwfz t xhdgxl niire odtucx jaklfa tayu sd afytnq ndw jdaj iebfkdiojq qrjp dhmvhrnmp? Jl cusoe yqbc ybnc cirrphtyz wnva bzr smaxd txngso byjrlw nvti fflknceb?
Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.