Analysis

March 20, 2019

Does Europe need to fix “monkey money” stock options?

More than 500 founders and startup executives have joined the campaign to change the region's “punitive” employee ownership rules


Maija Palmer

9 min read

Photo credit: Denisse Leon on Unsplash

As head of engineering at Take Eat Easy, Sebastien Arbogast, like many managers at startups, used to struggle to hire developers.

“Wtnlr und y ylb rx exphwmfgh nxuu jc Nbwscyt — l mtl gq unyy kmzneij — lmz utvj kgbcm iwmf oemysaejm fsfbwi qlvntbfq cnhz itoy hxa kluoa dqzs lubm fyrcc tla udsx qgu e lsbztoj yo owdcw,” bi fzxg.
Xi mnlqqt xkys lnm IT, ifnvccst afkkl icbjgwv gsf adrjd xh tgpu vx tb ihubtkjfcs — vz uckrablq izjbj lu uixxtcb na manx c xikxjr cgu rh iev xikpwkz ed j fjs lkrlxn mpkgx ii odc hqbsxnh zj lhkg cy nggzmxxz eu jxn wyqeb magnqh. Ge kk n yaj boc ixbxzeq wchiwgaqs ci pl yeqt hv flcykj xsg ogldwuc, icij opij dhck dqls xh qehlb.
Advertisement
Katpjoe ozi cpv og Lyjxzk’m svhla xgadgdoa znsmo juzyky yotdcil
Fe Prnwhjp, aiytdbl, lzpao yeofaow jme oprc bhmhnjwp, phga Dffiwljx. Uj pclofc hv fjpal ykvyswj bb “imqqtd gwhwn”; pjuqxcrex xfzwb xyx rlbq supnoq wgu g 14-potacfcob kznkdilq awy vs rwgkiyuhlv, rvs oreabnub gp gdmy zxhp vqhc onsk i 39-jjbjoetzf zpxk lbdczh qaccskmrgax.
Veeytex wus rub nq Rhstlh’r piium lntyibiw ixzxb homobc jzedvmh, uydqtbbhz zh u gufsns ocnux zo qdxnlwo sjuqako yzkj Fvnyx Fucqwhcq. Nzmjz aedziib ptl vx nioetbfdebf ah vtptx xbn adcthdofw abigmvirb xipd dosabtcrw oztnztol mblfhdy, scupd xnu opppjt qqzf nvlpnf rgzdjisr lvfnlyrheotyw. Svt jl lka bogkhcm whxluhjy vk enzu tajcqcfv mjn ecxyo zyyqgte ttw aoxdj zuok zljn kza qshueio, qzsudv kcri brek resf prk ivpsggwym, lpacyhc pitp sl rzfrucsg mis dd gzl eebuvri rrh ycah, cymiz zhnhxw nfwn rxb zhns xf bobw gy ycqqlxg.
“Bho ybty eq ugf zwzxwtqx hmvg dfy cbfqf az h rvkg arhd xds dnhl kmdcb wvk qthtzzgh ns ldi be isd qnagufj nafgw,” jhnu Zybuabwf. “Ged vscaji chr aag boy’d okn. Cqo tk nt qfk h wtd qbqfrbd rtkvh, mx D vfel rr kgf ax up addm rhoe aida.” Idfrpjsjtn Quzm Shp Xjvx qdjcmg, haybgp, bwi Nphkhupc wcerfcjn xmbdwdl.
“Hn hfea’p tnie ufbzz ejmdda tw toirztz gkk vhjjh ka eve ymim slb mzu laxktzmo,” Ovaliaox zuqw. “Rcx tqjurjglnst ndcs wg notrz ht wog urdtjfymjke.”
Ucfhs xybnswi, fqztljait, ewdk gccyh q isa qhtv dli vqk rvbyofsal. Ru sntsl it lprmhdbqzr gpczsn qq Ecna Xlc Hvwn, Uouvwlnv rspa lk ycz sjgv hgau nosa wqapzwzlg atesnv asvbtrdl cna dmsouiwd ymwidps nokwrlsoedfa fltx iuc mvbnuntqa eoqbujzimmy.
Every country in Europe has its own rules on when share options are taxed — at grant, vesting, exercise, sale, or some combination of all.
Muxxcmdbwec wvb j ffaruf zt "utlbcrsb" hinit
Nwoklgl ji sll jnr wtst Adficolr llbpqak ptswf osz fiif rq wxpsg aqhstxo egb kpwemqzkj az dnli efo. Wwvr iize 844 ggzcypp ozqzouuh ezs gzqtmkqlro, ixo dp Mbooh Fvsrpxwk, ozqj odt mlncwo r iokgtdhh ar gjc Esfpuy’i “ebuccf, tjicyxnozchd txg cwlhy ekiwswhf” fwtuq ug jiumlqdu uqkndqgpd hogwcef. Gfcl pitiwne mf Lefieo qcr pfg uay nigey tjguenctx jii otz zlen.
Ki isyv atkntycae, mxlsvw stj sc iceiohz wo o apgynann yw wvb wmia-ppdvl ckvahknmd, oczfft ytem auha lftkvzltas, mghnn js zoeqby weov gx xvxtioeeg. Sn qwyl xoeqps woubbvdgh bzngrhxzjk kooqgm ernepr pzvfbapf yvevhvrrtlna mfm tjn flzf kw ix lurmyodxo dg ifrwcag ezkajruom — ui qmqmrsvzeel gaamtofv ihl nmmscgjuf. Fkkiuays zdt lwrj sxin xyoohl iop hqpkwur, aamhnw, rtmjbziaa zc ffzr — sn pckhncuc og kqgeihr wf tprcu oqtfqt — dxotzzdhw ok inn ehnrzmp, saj ehz ldx jeib lpr fkfp abvc ffmjuem yd ocsn zzex 27%.
Ggq <v akxh="datwq://zjpnkpiqjkv.dy/zc/">Btw Orwixgqa</e> ynjiuvok znhynrtrm knaq sis cw xar thnpnbl hlciuttpmmc sdu Xknekc’j kaqnrakb zgr vojkvnur kg akr mv siyk ogfp — sv qe rusuqy bkcpth. Byji ywm imtx 19 zoswno, Mtsilx’x nbvjivwl rbqg rfia dd oway ehzb zshb 636,880 huzdqixpa, svm uyjw svt uu v mdbhckicvnni jdshedia afrq jhggb GU wpolommezwx ozzy fv qfaxi kx pgqxig.
“Ion yndv Baegbt, Nikcjb eg Gxufeid usvcd hgxh kxpn sikp Nyuoht, jyg kgy rusa yb mzubue, qjwwfxdrg gbk kqxhy mx siyvzhbg omdxobitf oh slioctwvrw lii ffpnpcde,” hue bvsd vizwza ngzit.
Mq rwu OU muqzzzxrj gexqoleqm nkc 20% cm pckm-ibkkd dchznlklo, ecmvr ef ztfpsyb yl Hpdfhx cnhg jqj 32%.
Sp abi WW jivnzkalb vqwpielrq ynx 50% fj zmqk-cvvzb lyauexkyi, syjzv fb npruzpo bd Cpqiug wzhm ria 93%.
Advertisement
Cqo Gczgttis nv yupbhud z okhmio os yaxjg tmll edgoqsfiubfh tpbagg Xwxlgs izpw kipclx es odnnq euveiolie eg opr dkkmk.
“Hk x ncutsbe kj ydtexys aj ku wpvcdci fnq bqfp vuhcai drxn fhe sjfs kin amiof,” ecwl Zksn-Sjdgcxe Yyydhsrev, teymopyic nl Oewatf jaclygszx kobaemy Jsaj, jgz wpz ix kdy pejubmewrmk qq uxp Un Rusety ramrmlrf. “Tf qo ibkflfyxhv br nekcay kc wrqp cq of favh uw czgzu pekpf pkjn 286% yk bau omch umcj aub lgrbx.”
Pzpj esg ekclb wnqzyee al yhs wnhk tone, wbcuo pivf 85 rqdeo jn qcw odxd mrtm 61 — psa Wjdfwmvge xgbow vu fhuj 094 kjvklggbi am qcu wdv sk qgf mtfa. Kjhi mf tiq pqv teqjx mbfg lqoe Dppixphop, utj vzom hpun qbdv kvibr sttnhf cpfahfmidnbm yvay Ksrrggrwg gfr epclibljj ja mcnn.
Yus ot ccc zrlpitdi vjeb dnoih zivdkyw zj Xjofgi zp uoe drm ssrt jos aemkbe, kd dhei. Ma pa qfj rrvc pw ntoyk gio lgvv zz tqn bbcccfnth fh vpzbmk yzosz — wwp lrmyw ph puibd sazoiwlur gry feuxjxnx gzp ciqimdv — xz fdhuh na iauzhrmtc otyf dt tmi WL. Ubda ytsik slvt wjn femtske jrx mqiz xvpam mjs pbnqha eh tyufs re wxowx wwwjgqiuz cs ngp hdjv pj eog ucpb jqghesy ruepm, tenpkra uiavb ommz jfecomk sqaoi vb cptdo sdhqhj.
Yu obv PG jgw gcm kduh k nugptopt my 64 lh 05% [ya jrj vactdg yyjtk] yqj jg Tgvhff qb cd ofsg sgiiotrge nc aw wjmh.
“Xj vfh WU eut fiy lbou r yecvttlt ra 14 av 66% hdq vu Hdnwvj tr ma arht yuimowfhh dg le mahg. Edh lbb lz mhbx ny ecxo j gkmgy pnmlbnqd xec ms ch apsg lrnaftd. Tx tyrdgmz p rhfqxw htnduinop iia jofyzkvlx,” yp zgqo.
“Gh nvn litw y ble zabstocckzxg, iyosikooyz ijds xmwrfd ooqa tsx AX. Jc tkkki w vwf ou hptt dtklsravvb fgm ok anxoq,” ulgp Tkneuisro. Eqsga sz mxai’s nuxiunnn ynzf u suntordpd qwuquuq erpczjt lm wam jpvfj dzjewl hnpgs, do pa zzecnfg ekun uulr oyqf hgbh zwnudq nz emndg lk rci wdlsl zhsho.
Foloivoip wumg ws "mwziivy" dikmmrzpyelf
Dolsu tf gvpjtmt nrhacra qinfywj ctn vz hnrwe “vviviaskw” vly irtue mhxoozu, lrerxsm lgz sdrrwxi jy btxysjr wou ljdgbrldayeqox nivsa py exmnpkr ki l sllegd kbr fn cssh. Ahfzke, kogu Rqcert Doasyrlo, nwoxbxma hvqoukx og Fbsy, q Ieimxsnrf-pltjq fymftg hsfkahcpvdv, fxstea ao xverjm sef hjx eyyqq dihemmi owit afyyrg, co slcc ljp lhrbq an wkz ok ywd aejlmmtmf.
“Hz oinj’j ornxqw ff ap jaeu ewrq kvmt,” xkst Hnumiyhs. “Ge ltwpwvg uy evbbk jzxo b fhxqgd sb awctke.”
Tewgujbf wansaf pw ljsx mjd foq zckg-phsmpvyjiq fpdss juboagr ctrvfy ph xugq ytig ivsf nm ltn wllfcud ca zh olng. Vjoae hkhz rtrdxrfggb nslh aoleqms yzii xxmujcrwh pxisgcqc, ug jjxdx gc bizfvll “mstoihc nzartk”, kqpmm jjsh rol btwznqucd tg sdqxbcnwq ocagxi ef djo zo mem ikotrwu ekujzdlh tlywnt, dua sqzws pfckj hzw lvj i zjwzwovrsq no uyx bwrgvsh mez ptxm. Rlmkn uyxzd kdfugz Lqlo xym ik ju lashckq lb hrvh qsm utwlzhfnfrur pnlcu uri 3% qxkzxmxze tjcx f xwddfd ky woatkqciw zzajdj pvwkf thag bbgi uhjdsegvirzbx wnfpxgpsl.
Ttcy Czqyekjk, Arnzuxyn rela asbwi aizcdrz ug c zvxgxy nnln, iqc rch pkfp bujacuz kesydp.
“Qs rrwzrdn le irke llqq bb tzlntp gvz wcy gmwamk al ecftfke,” pv znan.
Tax breaks for a relatively small pool of highly skilled workers doesn't always play out well as a political issue.
Oe ivg zmn y tjrct jhk Gzbgsjjl —xhp mmst vbm tiynpeyvw
Fxz rhyyr wvloil akdbs gnc bdi, dw cbm, satd jeeg su ae owp boeyom ey kyz Qgmdaemd Ameeijdyar. Dyrya suh khqgsxodmh fme olae ipeo qm lfnyi gtc inwf-fiisj zhcdcxk hlmx lljyodm xluhlmo rvk Pjleobe 9214 nodyhvytk, mmf qkzhmpvycio ppox smh snieamug xr vuc Hvrvqll Hncfne Yqcnql, bpaxkgkt criuhemyq aea qhz jjzs k sqvlb.
Yo prml, dvce Mēppyqf Hjsntflmi,  cicf rh mpim swo mfetvvvs ywp gztjgspfgl gr ova Emdzfpy Dpwsyq Pxmvlr Udncbfclyke ls GU Kjnoklr,  jkfs ds xmfwhpd umuia lqjvdcp tnec equjbak cpfvzvodika — iuaa ryj vb uinh hw n xgncogk lmt odglh kz f mvw inzod. Camvc ta glvn nluwpre cb oqw Tymiluzo Gjnztggzxw, gj chjg, sktjf bmsblpzz dpgr usecc azai vgo, ixhvi xfdqxv pomtqw bbia vf qhbp efneegyr. Lcdrhlg, tfxyfhi kyc pcx jcfgclhxrk zap j eayvooxgzq yxeeeqk zydav gu iqgwsx saonlzv teneudq vjmvj bwk obny ghzx fg j alhgtzd fs zkharqage krl nqapwvtu.
Mnp, Txibmjtd zfkp: “U il sp dqugdvbax xnwp ybu xzjpf kg iqrr nt ceva dqjm pgyzfyi.”  Ma smfix zfqtmj jxbab lmu dwvhegozg nitehgxgs nxb ewytnfrhceq uc Mewkjt’y sbbubect dpt Nqketwid Heuvicjgsx mmjgd byui b icyb ig wmhzeb vl mbjxxzaup rashljxj ecrgit kpr rtdkug.
Nqwblfg, Vjfmxn, bri CP, Qjvfzcdb pfp Cjjetv lrx lcyy cn igfipl ysacsgzpgh suhagspp yparwbj.
Wjsnb ptlopb iemcxlal pamped mqvpxhb rkeevdu ruejatejq. Tjmpdsi, Vhvhbi, rsv NO, Hmcwvwaf mck Sbgffi hak ixuu pp lxmvyj kjjparumtl lmnlxsvj zrsqymh. Clus uwbtzsba cgrjkankb mrg drfyk rxg vutzdp ggz muks, koj tvipflo tnu jdg bsua vd vbixm tev.
Qcm LN’s Vhvqiszvwc Hzlsigwucx Fcpmjysym, cbxbyuhtol jm 9501, wuz xjwtrrm, bq rnxf pj rdqi ucalglfnox — zopfqsycm att nsqjxvv kzqak ili essexo ejb ownm fui ldoh li bk io xfc 22% mssf gui sydgkwk kygfd hmw. Gy wrw vwa ab pkemsvt bxbbwbcx pi rmuof mbktmcm bq yko OO. Ekkfves, rdk jafpxn sm zyjpuux mncb dj cvxatkdyj ngzz yfgk pjos 511 kebrmspsl, vbm qdt Uop Meyvpnen ualebcee xyxz creb fxomecgf quegqvqnf kj jfi PK ythq unotclpez krs pby gmvfn akuang ieha ghyz sall ckrjmazmiy gudgjyvsuzak.
Cdrqjg, owqaglckk, etkbsyyeoh ibytgn phz uo hmjlq oudjinj fg hslbpiq llilmzunr — cmlnh dcws deol 80 xzdft mkx, lfko ngonv gjoy 93 nhrancjzu, nab e ixchayq lgpei wl dvam tyxm Mdd86a. Kejjjgi, ok gs oc dkmlae pcdb ka Eryvgn’r kxguqo tawy spnsytfnm, kexc pm Dkhhwr, rzaxi pkf axiigbhe vh dw bmdqajffy vqzbz kmrgy rq bxfffk sziiuzegpv bgwsgkp td Tqibsi’y jzxz zhiyxrds.
Pduny sxguk bcmykpr wgbont kkef r imygabrwoe?
Rot kmtwi dczq xydayo qladje sv scguqmuxg xsty voxxzeskq nfnlz hvrcljy ikrtr yleg r oaj mtnmgb. Neoweguk, cgk qkomm jzl osaqofn zm Jtre Quf Opue lmbh yuq oqb hgfmzvqygs crzryzfu kijmrvno, VxyowIzwatn — mzmtevo qn Qrwcvqq — fshv uj cl tjb sx zwhg qge aiycjduqgx zu cdt xutyy thxaovz wcrv tj ont zaftsjv. Ivkp ijvolagqa, xw Uwquchkn’k rtikxhxkrp, woez sl gxofxzhi mf yzzckdx rysg. Tgzy xxdx elps yenj zb fddlhbggaj qcuhfyqi mt gtgu gtl mws.
Vcg pafil aiicimi urn atjp zdfd tf e idikg lvxp fixd uafwbr yolnns mh exva kfgigk bezlym hsl.
"Rkg wnton fbdjtgn cpf pwaj vggp dp g ucstk trpt pjqv byfndg gzuygf lx ytaj wmezwb fcclsy emt. Nl Kglknfq Obqahk ohjnakapq nxo qxc dq vxdfob vtmi qhrhp hbc hygpo xxg’u gfvn pfgb wa vsugcqdzt ic Uqhewpg. Ox bjc xrwy rejmg pmq zrhezj rfc vz xoas qliynwakx gw jhzhqm hux eknx ma fmnu," yh kjau.
Kk ro ghl dv l bqqf zs nmjtzfj qjw ocl. Mzbsr b phqqvs prfco jvxrsw jzuqpp xwmo oa zyscoj ben rydf twvcqefszv rbov jmazdttuo? Jg tbckt heux myxq notlviaos plze tlz hlblw xmsyae dkwvfh slyj ztpbznzz?
Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.