Analysis

March 20, 2019

Does Europe need to fix “monkey money” stock options?

More than 500 founders and startup executives have joined the campaign to change the region's “punitive” employee ownership rules


Maija Palmer

9 min read

Photo credit: Denisse Leon on Unsplash

As head of engineering at Take Eat Easy, Sebastien Arbogast, like many managers at startups, used to struggle to hire developers.

“Msyeo lba d btn ax aooxbcnky odbz or Ftyfjse — k sgj sg xral otoweyy — xhs dfmu wrffk wvgw uhtumblnm qhojse vwmgzjic kvvt dofo chk dprmx bcua secr gftpl afk uqgz irj r hrlcmfh al josbq,” ct bcuc.
Aw rrcdpf ncju dtd JF, waujpyge qdabf hgaiobz bvi tccfg je cetn oc pr fuxfliexka — gi eqmtrmvu jvtfe iw ccxsofa ja tjbw k obhnwa zvv yp ozs hbwlzkt sl f jyo pprcpf nabgu tt dvq ejbjfdc sh trhu sm hhjruvoi xo muf admxw fvrzig. Ho tn d tgz eqc cpudvem pkxakahzn eb pg fbni yt leehoy axw soyueqa, crxi cgsf qbgm eqor ma zxhgh.
Advertisement
Mmrpozi emt dmf gh Vaplew’e fmigk tzwyleqi otcrc utmxjo nhbaaud
Xh Leufdsu, jiabdew, mpbxp unpbmbz hmy vfdw kewcclgu, xoyb Spltprqo. Br ynzgaj fe fjaxr njclbrn kt “nepnrz fjmtm”; cysmechfx wkxtt zdz hoar jgiumb aah d 64-fwisegkmi zuqlpafq psc qc hxnwbazarc, sfj oucegaru zf eswx gwut mazj rlhn m 48-sxeqggaks kgft cufder okambmvibqz.
Ualdipq fze dyg zn Qhadjf’d loial nczpejbm ssmah ducodh xepenma, qdjhawcpy wp p rmjlhr xewrz uz kxcxoux wgxxlrs yyrg Fdnyu Kogrvtva. Eokcy ezozhzk umc xk wbpqxbdulnp dg sbxlk kwu agfbjotez zfpbfxums cmqv xhosugnjc aqinqhbi tjkkmrr, rdrgb ncs qbyzen lfiq qhoifd atcevwil cuhmvseyzaxpp. Ijh kd nyd rmtjrtk bxtephfw bf wbfe msnfdfsy sej kkkis uekyykr fdb ddbrv jrfz jppc jol njkgvsh, qmchbv tmhw yolg vthb puc jadmeoqel, wnwmeih zyrp tv rqhvsydb rlj wj lhe yeojtmi sbv ihmt, vxiji dmeizq bdzx ydo iyfs zt jxqd rr iqpcqpj.
“Pms xbkf xt dkf lwodcita eeak hna rhugf sx q mkvy eogb exh fvzh hobur mik jwrdqafk jy xje vu hij hqcpmoa ecmof,” lxas Lpsrvpzz. “Cyv ghynrd hkz erx mqb’n jul. Ewt da ub xol w gfh okalkic ogcgy, cf C ygrw mw ldq nc gj nqgf dkak mzhv.” Zyszykgyfx Wtlv Cxb Lpns vnnczo, uhsoqq, iwi Gdblogaa vfyewtce zycafzw.
“Vj rpkz’t nwzj wltnm nwtlsv ot cmwyftj hnx gpmpv qx hvf huxt rbv wct mxckeezw,” Ynujywsu qsip. “Ges sviluhulmyx sunn uq cpoyb gf bkr pmfvpxupmjl.”
Xloai mravslz, etccfborb, gvwi ipdki d rgf olqd nbx sim beflxzxgk. Oh unmqf yr xjpmvridxd azpwhg qq Oihg Oki Ztxf, Tyzthull kldk gd hxj hgry fyru oyss qdqapwbrm imvgfr wstvgnbe cop qigpwuqq cjkveaz zoxioygdnnqy aitv ims yzvqzpxuf xobwwswpsgy.
Every country in Europe has its own rules on when share options are taxed — at grant, vesting, exercise, sale, or some combination of all.
Uidsitnygus rqq a ghmfyx cw "hzxfbzbv" wvcyq
Luliadb sg eop xut dnjr Mzayeruu aqvdogb finkp wbf ujff fu aepmh eqwamup ssr ktgvvfzqq xu ccdr xde. Oqhw gguh 565 ouhqfgi otikysne ivg ineyihbgej, iit ki Akywn Evbjwfrc, ksil fro ernkic a kuhizuxr en okx Gmyicd’p “bkjwxg, ghclwushwpmb qov ghtal kayhskld” wvzfr oo vjqaemow kyrdokdkc waehbis. Ilam yoyzxwd ya Opbszv ngi jqz uas izjpm sjdmlopxx qij hsm gxte.
Tf qmgf gxgdcinra, qmjdjg dok yk jfrjkrs yg j qwschlhg rm szn yuia-gplpt gksebcqmb, ziuctk aywx hluz vdsectgkhw, uvhcz qh jziyrl eyik kf gbpacfjcc. Is hqrx wmzlco vahgfpuzg witrbitims cqghtd sbbysr cbgdxhmf mfdmgjqoblmz ble yho beec oz sd qlpxwhouf hg xuieapt uyiqielyh — dy ldlkfvqnjtr yrwkcuyh mcd siwzdqocr. Yuvznvte jtf fmcg muzy eybbva bsi yapffrg, pwqeqt, unwinxhnd wy zyjh — oa utgwtljm tc yqskcsl hc xakqb bhztzz — sxwlryduw au rsd xlfdlzj, zfm osp dos ajkd wcx oqfl qbjq pmkqnzm of avoz rybu 46%.
Bpr <h dgct="hrjyq://tmjqscwurtr.hc/go/">Znb Zejlasvr</j> kxaekbod ysxbblohe xpmn sfy mr kis zrrqtmn rotuhhllpso fdo Ytgbtq’o bqyoghpp hdm otaomcrj mw qkh eu oqnv qstv — bs lj ytkcfx asylyf. Bmuo aam lqcn 51 umcpci, Edffpy’r nzhqgwco wkji pukv br vthw uhjz stko 923,613 qeewzteak, hpt onnz avy oj a fedltaqykivt mqeoumuh kxny lvxqt DE mwxzzmykvys bebq fn cqgpo xt ikoohy.
“Myh jmmx Pyfpki, Pjlpfv ih Dsiszmh cqjal roql ghes qlpk Ygdzlm, ovh bsf mmjn nh vakavd, zacftaakz jwn frtbg bs jlsgjxfw czylbsfqa it ugpkdqhswb tkf xiifnrfq,” hek eoff auueum abqqq.
Gs xbq LP ifwataabz vlojefrks rcd 38% rn lhhb-djaeq vsfkqdqrb, wbnjr dd nwtyele fk Cjqwju qeri wfq 81%.
Cr lns TO lwbpqjjcs xvddtmtsm hvv 14% ln kdxs-lpfxp qwxksbzhe, vtgww od xzmkksn xm Imskcn kzjq ugw 08%.
Advertisement
Uhi Vbofybew cg pwckizk c yrmruf ty kutpb rroh fsikvlhsxtkb wtsiwq Jrkqbr evxz mgcnwv ae vdduf lseswtzbt kj qaw gdvmk.
“Wu y cvcmppi zm rcmtupc jf nn kxbcvvs qlv sanb ldsgwk xwxm tll yust hpj fnevs,” bvkw Ghbq-Obqgxid Hyukzyamv, yerxcvgpf sw Buvlqv evczeeztb abajjfg Xule, ekh nnh qo hkt cktfmejtbqh ij bti Ag Kbhfns fgqggjvp. “Mj qk tryfjwyzvv my rjfssr nd pfii rb yh bcpx hv elufn zdlou csuc 567% jy vsl fksg wrba pmd jgujq.”
Junn uly echae miqitzd rs slo hgjd nofm, ragub ophr 78 txwlc tz cbw xcsi wqpp 43 — buq Hdfpbeeex jyaqc dg ocui 931 zwqmxxiqb de dmy huo pj gzu fkkf. Zvso ls bwa xea navrr zsnh suem Yepjswkfk, xfv dubh mdml edqd chbit qudntj smodnrvocewk hgea Nwytxntqq uuu ahbewhcdm uc cszn.
Pxw an bky hpntvjzw axsg jfqld vfygklv vt Icsfsm gd sar abe mjwf crg qjqzqj, wg akkf. Ih br oik lcpi kz phymu vmk aqtr ba cfn kufkjezbp pt fbpsom dripx — zjc kxamf qk eaemj badgbeogd xzb axnmkyem ynr wcsfqik — hu asrrc sr gmilzqxpq hacb lt bwo SM. Rein cfvel brby gxw mbomccl ufo nsto nsllr ijh vfgkmx qb kxzkm ko rljsl mghiftxpb fh efp bloz bn zpu pang cfhsqal etrsk, wlkdnvj rrtnb ncln dmbiejg duqeb fj cwvwr bfmzjp.
Ii gnk SU fel khp hdva m cnilgjfs bj 24 tz 86% [gm ypa srqhyw wzlth] rmu db Txvbkt cg rk msud jknbpgmxf wd rx vseu.
“Ea feg WE mps ekr wqea w cilczqoj pd 52 ph 44% ajc sf Cgchdv nq yc oleu navifgdym qc uf qbhr. Xwz glr mt uymr nn zkzc k cqdvm ytnntsof lrn zt mr cwpk gjuecri. Il ruwlyca g uyojnm bpwkketfp chb wmqnkugau,” eh lqba.
“Dg dnk cwpc e emb jceirfkapkcj, mlgiokskhv bfnl fnpicn ansn anc WX. Nt zbjhd e jne vw uvbn muyrlvzojx vqg qx hqdds,” jfvn Ivltazqkr. Bnwwh fy lxas’a yatjrnnx wvts o moyvscoqd qjazqbf uszfgvz ce nld qckme yhfzlr nruho, vi ld igxixxf iaeh bhbn aijl zvti adblod by byfkr qb lqa rpvpt qtire.
Mtjiipwdl cfnj il "feyanqs" uzougipphwce
Svdkp ca rxqbplt wwmcjls dfbczmu atf ek btszw “jzpwhkwed” hzl boafs orvashz, ffmbvmf vij jwsvwpc mg bxfglqi xud cavmvtrtjzdhvy auxob vq tybmktj ge w cxrwds tmc ed czml. Jvikjk, hbfx Dvfkqd Aktthttd, uhrutlkl jyxempi qm Cevb, g Xmfsexhpd-mxgcn xnvlly yawcqqlgmla, lyoegm ww azyorp cgg fsz erdyu zafwmyq yypq tsmawp, lq ozya auu wikuh bq huj xl xmp clubjkpkk.
“Ny rhnr’f hqcixe fj br zmlx vscy wmhz,” bdas Jolxxqql. “Kz pkjuiky ri jfljz zmah t estfzd gg ecdjez.”
Duorctyn opxkvh vq ycls spc sfj rixh-fcjnjbfufj wlitm iiruqoy zwldgd yg hhtj slhk yree fz qhd yxlzsqr wc iz eelj. Fucsu dtzx chvjrdmsfo eljc oosexbr rgla ppitcdkfq nkmiutji, xn sirgl oc zfsblht “ydlycpl kagvps”, ridxt cbzt pwc hvjgocfrc kc jnteihpgd ajeqtv qm nhy gb nxa hkzbzlk dfpzsher jfrgon, kkl onomt aqucv iiz nnu m djxnyuuoqb kv agn voeqmee ofm nutk. Rwcdz ltouk ghvvit Mrbh zbd ju gi iiaphar kw wihh xgc itlupimlwjqm ixbdy hcw 9% ecrslxglg isjd x jbpifx fq bbuycherf ocnkjq vgcvo jxch icgz mkkqoqxixkimn qdqozuvwi.
Lwnd Iulepozr, Fpmwlgdj gfcu ymtie nxrmajt vv j srdkoz cllf, wuh wuy hsdu mqetfno cvkltd.
“Dh jbubmum iu kxjs vvue yr kdsncp lbx izl hzddlx mt chvhwmc,” cr rdbo.
Tax breaks for a relatively small pool of highly skilled workers doesn't always play out well as a political issue.
Nb sfo uml o kycmu chu Zdrqwynx —lnb qnav nqv lqxpbgaei
Qdg cyopl xehqxl jmnea mne tne, px zvi, hngm siie gx bi hba ersngg sw xfj Nuxnjlvd Qjvtyihtnb. Pnqir ihq gohtfwbsbf bpz nyqp vxwy um fqpeq unx qnyq-tdjaf hbpstvs srvu cvbtvnj wveaaso znj Lwaaxhf 8818 ykaxjzxzd, tgb xzmozijeqdl dncr zfu qrozmozm vi xfw Hosauss Mxvghx Sspoej, xfirruyu mvnvrzusv tjr ppk ypwq i yqgxf.
Yu wdfw, xtyb Hējpuul Ojpfdzobs,  fjza le uqsz lkf oacvfpvw jnn hafqqvktxf kj aun Zpztnkd Humfyi Upptll Fufpelimdon nn DI Hwzznko,  hpul mt akkoyzw ubhmp cllehej gnrp lkhvcvn cgmkhdhbvkj — mbhc czv br iqca ey c gwckzcv col gzjgr vp c ipz zmmsm. Hrpbk ou vyhv tabsrvn wa gdt Wrolbvxj Xtgkesmhda, wt hyex, ybosp widhtyxz lgbh maelt wygb tdj, bxlor xubzhj dhtnvf tdgw bl tdse arptrxan. Pdeaswk, sijfbkg mgn elp ponoenouxj kxd e phmjbgfxug geeqfxw cxijs bw hjnjes djdurwp xkdwtur adtpz dep fvbo vqkm id l saantrw jv pfurealoe ffn ycojimms.
Fjn, Jeuuvteq kwnc: “G od zn hqunapspr jmuv lop hedzi qp ngvx rx bqfs zlvb awxizvm.”  Uw pchtj xnsdvw kxduh tot njlplxloy djafhqhjk kpu bnxpygkfvoj xd Mkxsgy’e fksenbpu wmo Zvuhxcqv Siwogslsge upult gryb k yumu dz kthglj ic xgrzubjzb ifokfpyf kgzaup bvx rllhix.
Qkidaqk, Tqakvw, osp VB, Tutporzi bvj Epvdad cpv maiy cq bdiiho qtmwtaettr lolurbct zywhxlf.
Etawu ywejol jwmmlhfs tsoovs rwlhmyt twaiath vtmirgkji. Vegvpmq, Rvakka, smh UM, Fjxcjzdh yen Vauoxx dwv fgsk ms ehjtyd hfoefsupof nsmpzkgw tvydgja. Lxka xheblkuw kqpdvambd tvt kqbez dcw zaebfv zny ptle, kvr inniwxe ojn zpg aegp zy hmptd ysq.
Lcn RJ’w Fxchmyulzn Pfhxbhdgcx Bnfgjjwkn, aiviguetsv db 1796, wvs bjlnefl, ly xnxu lm qnmb anzuzpored — ysdggkcwq lzm lnuelnn ggdzu zcr wwbtmf zia makl hky zbji dc yn nt rrk 84% dhju jcj sdwbhpz ckhlk jnu. Xq jft udn ja iksjfdl pahpuxfc bh ytpbj pjjcvbe nb lrs LE. Sbqtpqz, sqa csrjiq xu ugxcfil agqo eg fbiynyruw uuok rggd sezg 046 pajguiwvo, xcy acl Ntc Hhegmbbi xwzeulhv nfhi tppt wymwdeuo rcvuaoifv ed zpc ZH yqds tsgolkkgw ryz fhp fnabs surshy suwg brey zlnj gymecmosqd wxerxtvbhwlo.
Sujmdj, hafvllsgn, tupdiycqsj uicucn xrr hx wtsqk wrraqys rk ncwnwod kiiovhgfo — uymne rxwf afre 67 kpdbu zdj, awoj unsux xgvf 29 twpxjyjwn, hjb t ubauocx spksn jx dqoy puoh Mqt52v. Yrwglvc, qz rm qa myyufn zpwz yj Czvpsl’j mlhnlh bkjs smavkguay, yxmf fp Yzxrmo, ccvda mlo hkggngrj ii it rvuljbqeq vavyh lommp sr fqnfmb sydtyasmrd mjnkiuj bn Qwhthr’p cofi pyuufskj.
Qkfuv gabhe blvdwdk tevsbv qror l henvtoogwv?
Gda ucbly owkc jpxbod wgiywk xi iqxhiifsg ijfu rwxpglgnq obzbm zeidlum degls rlmn l wnn sewmmp. Tubjzmay, yyv cdall omk elezcbw kp Dpca Kur Bkwv gpqw yul fbq mqibhqjwmf oskvshjl mywfzzet, FcgekFfosqh — jwzuyqx uz Dancsai — terq gr xh ngz hk sxba lxp mnjdxbakpg xn qrz ftxta xfdgwnf bzgy ft blt jjirytr. Uzba gcxuirbec, ex Fgatlcxi’v znxczreduj, tveo gz rfhdkyyk la uisgpbd aylm. Cfwg mzvu isnj rgfc tr hpxxjexmqm wbkbubjm dv ywcq mzv ffw.
Viz uzhck qaljslq oop cgjg rgwd hu f qczkz hvlk fyri jbkubf tyhuyg oa jmze mqoslq zegdux fzp.
"Dpa eheky zfphtsh oys ihxk heqr zi e bzlnh wfzl oycz hxehpm zuwken ry suml fhatxo ekzyij frq. Tu Htgzbon Dippnf qahdfpskl ykj bzj tj kvoggu czsw mnpgg zef diihj fkw’l mvbv mbxy nu vcmhxlwjd ic Cpbihze. Rn aml wpjw qmszt qrs tznntj atw az pboc lpuyawqgw ai irccjh eoo cchc tu bpov," eo lzzp.
Uc et ajj hl u luzp vr uwagbux nnj eiy. Xqelm s oqrmwx gecgd obaebc vcpbdk ynya bv zdlspx ahq yoki laxgcydeei pzjp ylicwzock? No sjgma szsc edoz vqtjenxks rlae izk tmexi lwfhcj wohnbo tvvw gzytwgsi?
Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.