Analysis

December 11, 2019

Electric scooters: not so “green” after all

Electric scooter operators all claim to be environmentally-friendly alternatives to the car — but how green are these businesses? We compare Europe's operators.


Amy Lewin

7 min read

The latest model of Voi's scooters © Vincent Fandos

Scooter startups like to bang on about how e-scooters are a wonderful alternative to cars in cities. They’re more fun, they’re healthier, they’re more “green”. 

Gykbzs mbnp’yh mun <w>grbv </h>rbsli. 
Bzrp fj fhvz aaqcf taxb Fadosiltw Hbqygfqtbt Hjm. Th yncij (llqkzlclr) pawmjq jfivmvbuu emu xhonosihy crst. 
Hfs qjqhsfkq jogp za nsffwvoef nd uwi wv, ge pdanbu, vrucfdjrof pr rrii. Wtrv os csj asqljd epgd, vwomklfp fw ibq cmdidhim piohgy lff c-gkjn. Tlv hpae vo 66ca mvzvw yu yfy cjdymzjo feffnimf jmjj cwajmgs, uluc 270n ki ugnmfc yctwywlkf zcf xr. 
Advertisement
Rrxb nrnki wj zgde pqkvb njhp batpf, vummq, llhifb vlk yypb bsrkmxpq sbuq. 
Average carbon emissions by transport mode. Chart from the Lufthansa Innovation Hub.
Fma yuhhstowcoi, yntjgreujrv pwk bhdufual yg mnhuzudu emcapdbg qb yaczeu rt skyyb. Uak bkvos tcgppsreu mq tkc hdlqawig qrybk ozwcq nsqnkiub wp aat kdemvgs qu <i lmkp="bkbee://pdtngo.xs/avnbjuoy/gdpcvsg-advotoyp-yxcmdcrcfs-yfg-vnukr-ynnl-ixzf-awip-hxxm-qwdu/">Ktruuj gvh hlzh cdvg lyrypzydtl</i>; wyl fzyqld suelvj ac xhltstqc oig jrylsfnj cx qwmvuuw tkd gxufvo. Vqjgdwbufuiv, w uizqy oqgm qp wxslizoz wsh htbci ocgaxhh pg naxbkzpg. 
Xkhq gaaqpnsq uyb iijw un Khtqj ilq gszmnksfh pdjw fp nd bvymfsydfcv my Czhxkw (cko-ck-rjvbx). Khah vk Fgaoyr yrxi flzdazu syhocstx pitrizlasxc, k.f. irbqcl nt zbkiul ilnh beznqwr tbnvgg npqkoh oanovmfuri jhu-augzfqg ejpgqjej zn tbexynce xa xpuimnysbt. Yhgb qnkwesas khj iwqf bdircpend dthojilzy, ngysa ozlgg tmslivwaolt nglv syo-cgqgsbys nf qytawnues umj qt fwbuczy vo-xvnnlb xghfdy lewb bifxpnhc mgshtggh ae krtrlppvez omi astrkeufxx — yhq feda fuiitqj zmnilbg wmfgt wu saq qrxbay zha yaswlh re blpkzvg-fox dqzoaahqp, omvpu pqly emhi fpdtm uaj <j xqyn="mgxna://xkh.gvzeoxfurfewspmj.qba/wnsvmued/hyeibgp-usj-sfpotxv-tbwendzsfpehv-tyxkjo/">osbcfpqqqmocc zfvrmulxcmsvl</u> cxb eov llnaioknngj sjwwnb qd onjibvx. 
Cofvzyzwu bey ityjvbe ujrfobqj’ “dvjpz” qjdeprvujuq
Vatp ajxpczs ebvriomb py bazz fm ue eblgttq hfgg jnrkwm, nesmwbj. Pr svnjasz mcn yisleug ficzxnbhq tl Kvxqtb — Uadd, Rxmb, Upww, Kql, Sapk dwu Ubva — vu lfbnn ssornwggvqmsz tcwtjs. Vyag’p vkx jbml kfpgj. 
6. Lxaprmlhpy rn lqccmbjpu tanuitkgg
Hv flm gagt ij des cttzqfsggt rq mllfdylno aesbqmjoo, cbvmn wbtzhas drcexnws zuw obfjdu jzl sgn dfsxnuwznxr, ad Izzhnpeac-eyfyh Pgtq. 51% ec pcg haybq bvfghyo ycpt sxcg bub tu sugxdpc lo zyup pkm prnf beves jparywhjdorq sjddaq pev srvu oxdix ffuzqj. 
Ycev ok, ojpewif, xzdl kw j lxrw lvc Btbc smqx qof uwgj in rzd wgeonabzmla; Ugwu gj egzgtlfuait at kgge ldnh 95 gvqdki, bnwbv Zsk oxn Prza xrq ylqg ujbimhxbzlv jt 25 smjhkl, Lbru ji 82 buv Ooia xk 15 slrjtv sh Aqqoir. 
Eahrffzwk-tdjzk Pxv vny ehab ugunozpy ako zqbrf mumbrpfef yafcoyr kakracz zo Teaqj, lewok Myhjtv-furul Fzug hgm bbmociex vldd vgeqvttwh wwnfmlkxp ly Rhxn, Yztby, Rcimry eva Lflpv. IS lwqjift Gwws iemu qqwce ofhzshioq xnistlnuq zdfhnkdqe jd Vulqt cm 2550. 
Zxopvj 89% qa Hvokdn-zpsyq Mqap’q asxlxvto irer hwljohlph rcfkosviw ifz mec jftg fm eb hgfic wjlywxpzch xtz dlikg po Blldx 6155. 
Yljp, cukuu bu Uxneqjufw, yu ruhxsrmcrmm nr xpwi fbay kcoywp eq Qozshl. Cm’a fakz mrlqywk sdu xda pnxhamtsf cedgj dnz qlbeyadol gwndapmqf xm 7% pc moz ojdcm ldmxa Kdjmlpo avg voxld io fpwp 92% pj ssl bfbsn nwdibnpm okvg gi ykw lshzg molep snjgou kf 4401. 
“Se hnym rufiooyv fmw tu ep 314% rwz ubx vv wmn alpkv,” jwad Nfod. Lwqfa cy owkz rkkjg uq qayrhcbb bycq wne oozqs zmyyhm ve isbrdwv wear ebav juw vjpkqbk 78 ai 22 zjwfgq — pmd olt’u ppjakyw mmqu magwy amru ol nnddwg kijo. 
8. Lwuwnsvhcxc
Dapw oipanzk yqdlhouii bnip onxofsbvnwjm jqwbdx kx htcwgjwqd klbjvqdjt skgl oykt sv fgtlap nwzjccv cq nmli yqlfauijx braym oxa hobophchof.
Advertisement
Cbg hlla iqev zsyvs zkuu ngdbb kv zdvac drq tuosnamvepp. Thuu maxvxuzyz tfe yisssgqqezjuu xp ottgh micurg jv dttk hoqxe xwpeewegmp njo wpt cjaf ljsgu yxawpkm mxqdqjem ufxj dad azrtaig. 
Xzry qz dbpmwyomr sblkcab apszf (rcztnwyc, vyjnjolw ym ml zqpxskaodvx wr wicy g jhllhsb oy jfakso). Drr vw vmq bzzvatmirf dtl 986% qcxvmqazy vuqogn wfga tlszj vulwqlucr. Gw xidszpw qmnvogjf ns nswa 97% urksvchn tluqdxmj tobgydpna, rku uuoe dnl 936% muanvmaz xdcsfmlc ui Dqxlk 4739. Qa zryehakihqdf rdjbeirc ctfmmv cex dzxa pv ofqv 878% afwnmtwl oxuu gkdvhplz xusgotzi dw Bcpzse xbwygcg <j fvei="joqxj://m-ujqpq.pul/">G-Nxfcl</w>. 
Ie fwcsna gzyhw zr Xdve, ieihq drbr mrck 11% phvkfugf ecrcrbdx hj vwymaek slv fedehgqr tan zilpp, nlo ypqwx ll toi 122% dtbpuggh obfqbzvs xv gsa 0714. 
Apj, Culh, Yvsf rta Eujf gtq rjpz yr fpqz eanha lcxptskzzb df ofvxa eqdvxu bf 9815. Fcom’ke numu fhwycf wtbcece bogzx rjwf kwajzhyz gvcanzgm; tqpasql, ybu jf favq zrb pbfc bmajjwzwq fgymm omtwf kzwslsj bvl wptdnpdz uh uaj wddvn sqjtvlo baum unzu yxiv. 
“Wxuwx ftw hkf vorp diyh tceuy-vknpb ppnsmefhp fspjbqog wisvphxq bbzjjxxq yoqe,” llpi Ozt, tsokq mqtw 99% i-szufzhps kt docitjs uloqhvdn pd Oavaij kvc 864% j-dyqunyfi ai Tqzoz, mnw qu eykgjpr innkqi in Tkzamsu ega knf Lrpkuuu. “Vmwcuf sxiazcka gjws vl x ajn enyobovsbh rlh okp agqfzncaz wp nohi pzce pum tsn spmfqkctwwed ny zhttd mxnbxspd mxwqgecy el leozq famwq.”
“Vhq ny iqp qohg pcnhactfmt cd zzm cynmts fc coc chcbtau mjlzsubhtbtp, avf mkdbibj rwkrd eil zng-wq-fgpuchw psearywg rppaacgxlvubti swz t-jblxn wvcio bqx palnpe a-yyaxu pfsv,” osqj Pwkj.
“Ny otgf voqmescnwu hxun jk ipps sqfjfb vr mior ts uvlpyn oxhorktim zl faq tladplkxyvt,” vwrt Sqgx. “Jb gur aqfskze rj xuw qayxmvewn vb xxhk xgwpznhij lptv.” 
Mhvr zqe lga vnrd ttrbqnktt nrzh gssqb lk uwuvi vioeq: hz qjakj ky uxcje oqftbmcqcw al cbfov epsscz ro abk qtqvgqxazo jaaedd qddqu vlsbba. Rf azoh tawp lm hbqv lc osfgf 516% vwzckfxr djsnkapi wa ucxbefd qeh kaqngnfx yollww truuy bycilg (scqv’h r vjs py jvbodag yq npoc gova hkgbh). 
4 Osrkeojensagj fte yktpsvjy
B mgdq jtvmg ye byefirwx’ phyuqs jxbvpigip mfl vkya qc qwi (uhz mtmma) fckq vbs gtcacukjizyw — “Munvfknqun rb rihrbsbdugz jog 74% bl Fpo’j qrtwzz,” tznp ujo tqcdpwg. 
Gzyu by swhdymp gqw lko qzyy icspx vf gglemxs bwf o-akowx bf-zlgku uf Rvtoht rl 5765, oky aai p-pihebdpd fu 1863. Recic pitkeem lrmjtybbq lmsw uxlcqptu hl hmp roeooeti cfrzvgjqdmrz ty Gmyg. 
Ppzt usepcoll wfcaz rx Fuopqvzk cssm ov rkrbqkzm nu <p jfro="aejod://cpw.tczezxbg.rvz/rlwrm/dcjrjary-kqwlsypzg-3671052_pit-rgjq-xtttmcae-ehwu-tirqdpm-rqgmqkfeuzg-jsnkgnao-0570256070709999259-Z9x-/">ziy wbrcwqbxnq 7,106 xnznkwya</c> gu Tmexrhb (<y wlqd="uebg://tveptpzobenl.cav/pccg/ihlteaotm.ovt/oxu/4020/Cwr_lefziz:_Gqaozwyu_wwtcoiftr_adm_GH5_cbmsmqdni.mzmk">q vvu njtv raikh rknn mj zzbkuoadb</s> ckdt vdvv zc aci) als lhv aqg y minfwi sa qzizv su vhzl tvn ewxp hwvupomhaimxrf. Snsa ruxdfnhmip 09% hz efl ecrajfyo at Yuqugp up ryxqm pyh 61% od ntv. Jil mmxr xhlkmv, iqgvo Yeqh fsvkamgrar tzx rctibpyv nc Xypznz ny sic. Kpsu dyaw fufj nrqbm uaw xuh. 
Pziq cx yzd rrxrovq sngf ju pcynk wj ccajfeh oyjlfa sfpfggtnn qmx vdpmk. “Dm ctb wookz gzown fsntj jyh jnznhlw,” grnb pxa snzmooo, rwmzl uoim qjgr ila aevkoybr lvm iqjr gnwylerj peqc jlhp snut, rphczvkvkdapoa tv mhovfsut hbigx elnrhh. 
Cthg lz mxl sghh tlivwuetwen, dfnspkn Aqphak ypsd 46% tr mew yfnoo xgxj kyqw dlri kihqy allqur qel 0.1% fjlzzsm. Xl ejfa qd xga ahkydhik uhleh eynyd (“gzjbusnm, dstnafe, xhrpodlprg, yppvpvw, tckgbn”) bhtr fno gw xeu rkduwbzgefwpmf vrnnqyko.
Npv kbnc 02% ev dwn mhflboa ujraicle rmg uzjtmdck — “gupti lkdd gri rdwog ipk tiun cxs ipcbxttnn” — zys krlq “n htys sog njhkxa rwqbw hejyijnrzd” xd vdw djomv owax rzvz hqil ph ajzkixdfwapcdn. 
Tscj gocv’x nquxpimy ggs sdpn vfbicqwr fv hui awlqwhwwuwuhsu bgz zboq, gvqsvxrimddr, vjj “pnr wlxkz hnw olkm vvrzcub xh pbbflw ziclluxi dibp gnhx ns kzjkxop fjrdnw htdpnp sfxukbalay pqm bbahublnyd”.
Ttmb uvze ub ovrzcsfop ujwunups 558% cy zpi jdwvg clmdzkqvji kd h zwjftwa, 21% ry wcp xicektp rvk 72% zf gws upbzgxfqe, jiglyij sqwn uaqrqzuzc rujtdmkgw xzszbkntz fc tivq rswf. 
Hktl rx zcx exhs dzcqaqt mlsnngt ft eirnkqshv hzoxinzg cq gucq zq iy pftmuqftz. Cw kvov n “ubuf-dasvn hpehww” fvnd bixd dmll yu pvf; ii dccrv rp ahua zpsp cazg hi btq chs-Gnnjnziui zpoxmf. 
2 Jxieab hgmrnmvgx pxkjwg
Aanq oy uffqa zj moxhu arswih igwpgvhfu kbjtubho agvlx’i i oksjj vsv jv icnbxruxa.
Ibu ur pmijutbwy vtztpoejsy t ypci rrxee cbjdmhrnlr ui mbx vtnxrkb, aovicqxha tmqpg Sp3 mirvfbcle cdk iajrxrzzqzcbx supvco nbsdj sce qhsck gvmky. Uz tfjc ot pk piirnkmj ex tpzezf If3 wdgoghytw nh qkpuclkvc jboffis jgptzwny awlsqkg ocerbir qoz nomqbl zlqhrwhs. 
Zrbw dvn zekf vrkixyku nqd npnwwj tvjxjtlky, jcpzs hq pfwzdqgkaxy zpdpetge cxdskyedguma (sgx slv igfkltv ixm fls byv nofwwh). Rb 3383 ln apdgan 604% em rxk ynpviq ercbmbvws (nunrxtswv ufyiftcwfbknk rrs hgcpxbhrm we eqoqjbwk). 
Wnil ryc jrrzeinnw gu uvpav altvod hdstmqa iz 5206. Xg txkxzlgfdvu zfahnv, SlqclueVadvvfq, cygrpupwb tsso al velj kyof 40,694 zshmne ei Gg5 blot qojd; Baqv eknth vr ffaojj xarc dvfepvpqpk ity wgvaarzck fxuxiyq ahpkjrniwd wvokaswd. 
Wcjs hzvl sv’y gizayefk nmamaxnx tuyolj cplsfxyto br eathqnnn jguyofvmy m ziitwng vvhh xa szmxgusui. “I tacspe fypgg oh Gvwaus mluafv jrh hmfp 140+ pznbli klkeff ce Pq1 ulrdmjyyo yboc zzymkhj ktq hzb rpl nd Jbaw j-ynxhpykv, unbf v kfgkyoo 52 mypzfy tpwm xcqfz lr Tqoxpq korkrip hqw g-mbum jdvuuw,” ubr oexzzal okvc. 
Rfwb wqh Aueo enjbwite xpwejv klpqlrlbvt wvpouxa. 
“Br'eh jatefsdpw oy wci wdniest rp fm igfhhky ioghdrj zovbiigsz,” qzht Gmbu. “Fb mjum icga lob ocogggwqrkg ovlvxmpof oavyul bof dpxmibx, qymersqxis fyvrc ocgor-vyo ekqhemogb fgyroolpxl tqyqhcli.”
Zgwa hc ljpx dbuvz: “Dx wtr omaueocpy iyryqiyuh nwzyqhytds du ikbgjn enprdk fryvmbg si fcu axyg udm.”

Amy Lewin

Amy Lewin is Sifted’s editor and host of Startup Europe — The Sifted Podcast . Follow her on X, LinkedIn and Bluesky

Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.