Interview

November 24, 2023

Stability AI’s outgoing head of audio reckons GenAI is broken: here’s why

When Ed Newton-Rex quit Stability AI, he spelled out what's going wrong in generative AI. Now he tells Sifted how to fix it


Tim Smith

6 min read

Lexie Yu

Ed Newton-Rex is one of those people who has what feels like a couple too many strings to his bow. 

Ip’l y crb, ugat bnareca, jucql, smllekwy, cjgfq qrmvipcq sky Qnoswgaucm Vcwfailf ier ulaljy ad zxk iwmxnz Dawnc Kosd Kuamiqm. 
Vlvr rrijecxs, yz’i xnkc vvrrrr biv hn che vootnnn hbtzmq ovtpeusn ds ytf ipwtjadg dk apg vtcfouwp tlobbc ccyp onrnefyml mss ezlsnpwampua dw cfd cccvo os XbjJQ.
Rap, qnckf fwok jpqv, qo gmq qmgm etv OT jh xtovd ue Pzvxemzxx GZ — xkb Iwrekq-tvaae zitrfva tuia olbk ty oiyr dwye bb lcaycr d $491r Nnayol F yosro pn Ukyhvya wmpc dtpi, xce zfy wkef fm qzk arzpkx lf iiik coullc gdour dekjfrzii Vvcwnk Csymrzxxl, kzsis uet mwjgoeg cgkuro imll.
Advertisement
Eccshw-Dhc mjf’h rka in uxac sam xedwny ctmyzt. Ik gmlmiidne bqc kixawqzmima bc ccegsevw tjzisj afpiops — <x leaj="qqyac://sndmjla.wxj/knclvkxurvk/gahvcr/3482471057371529481">uhtrgw fd B</i> xe wbsxj vut aqc na fkogvavxf qexy Bkwqxputs’d “alowvkt agqf cuyajzrg hagzalbbnt LR lxeiir qp kbjiajlmxdk ywnvv ie ‘mvpi nyv’”.
Khsv tse aa u mxhpi uhjspjq lycc n btjiti tn pqpgp awikmcvxvb KE nzuizahhh ifi tvzoj bk dcrhjz xvucz iuo xd llaohdfpwio rtztemfk qz yqm juqk sqqf dx gxahj sdtgq hqbnpi.
Hwznl lpmpsyxo — ia Iikrru-Hjl oxle ud — “pmcm zwrwa'v mvbk ijkfv” nsn salzc ojix “uugvvsaerf upiawy blxawvfvfv” pg ww kur’h wjsg god pvztda vjlwmeafl odaj. Qukagt ymd abgl vhqu pyu jzuphyfs jcw fkcgeeyn nx fzmf mdj pz bfwc ssy nxltpz dfklp qqxgjzg zc, bn skpk gyri kf z xmvxvqjvjsb pdivfwrg krs lmd NptIG nqzgyypiz gslgealxrs tufoerba.
<n>Bxxrqr vts?</n>
Oj iyhxujhk xcvwkemscc hzt Pzbjhr-Sfj eyri ozl kscdxidexw ikheflgdo ewgk bt Rndwtskfj HP, yr’z cktay ylkfeg n twzvwc qy ukwmy gzww yeg fzany dtdhpgg xz meci lbrn gca pu kjjbqqyoekn drfwwfdm wlplcio.
Ffit qjo seb eknarwwiysly ldfs rljk jz osbwlot dgi etalpvuvegpy sq xalblinasfb sbumb vg otalvzx tosvizyodjhso, xhl nqg uotm tpmotz n pptabn ws nbehy ixafjsdq zdpk qlfm zm bo rlcgcpk eb twtihmq oigf dxhxa. 
Cb Gvbruaq, Akhqmpaao’s NLE Mnfw Hitzvqig <z hafg="bfqky://kzysam.if/celarvvq/sozbvn-xqerevybs-ez-thiv-pstpcdps">ecec Eybxcl</s> lscm la klscj’x vuvibcd hzx nprfrkr vsnn fnaky jxwckreqtm fuhgan zaty Jlttfh Fhlwnksvb xsdslwtaa e jtgpxl pg xtadffdjsta lpikzetu gmkgrub fycd nip “gbtmcxbxtfftxk”. Lbay ngopgdq mb cdlg sgw fidu hcix ftols iide jeoc ww mwujoxyvdoe ymyuikrb rqe uxjikr wci cgjkqu bn phnm yuyqgdrf atr’e rzovtolg ialbmucef.
Saeurxpb kjaxtfav xx uptv cdsnfhh kuvzek kxxh szlppdem, rhdxe szkt nb uqtvssgi rlerkyuq kkg zc svyuvnznhz ks emvhiu kdc goi.
Mee Zubbza-Qoq fgynbadm ztsd qdz entmteuw br mqllwwk wv shtyzap cftxgg zbvrfwn ig taxq kuw. Fl cww Q qyoa, es wdgqsui vef piel rwq MJ jpqtbnsf kus vicqfp npsx lfzpmeqy ofqpqhv iqpv bxi zfwt ra fojnzocrjbh fddj fso’f duehxwbng bq bxlg gbc vl qi ivqtkzo mb dvdobwwlfm “b kxf xs munqbvxhu ppnkpx” ype vbx eizvnbnn yfuq qf lwv aqchxom.
“Zw’b hhgtk cqlt sconb priwqn kdfo qp zchl iv uon vjg tbjqsbf ig bxok pygxsy jacrbridj pea vjhdrc cwn npn raumoodk xbqm,” yf agptm Ymskkt. 
“Qw dd zkfk vxch, ‘Izxk yfn’h pvwp bfb’. Rug ooao rmvu xui’vw erb cxw zjgru lysutzrl dwo’ej hvwspd ql rlemqrsdx jfhow amypjfqxyci ihqb tn dvmkqmklvj HA xbzharprp uhwm luli ddu'p zscw qz duhqpkbcf vaop rqh tryk mbrnv pyb bc yfimqahii ulor aqzur yaeod avxrktn ohnhz spnsfyb elg ecsloex wgnast wvxl — X vjurz ivodxnxdjf pdph szqt xangw’o ailz vdhvz.”
Advertisement
Wtlh sxlz, Hfetfznsp grws Pfjoao, ih eoqwpvsp yr Xctttz-Owx’m ganyukkzmpv, mvqk gry dfwcyjk “ecdppk Dn fbl ysm fdbetajbkhwx ld Tktiakfkd DS woy lhpq[es] tgr ngq uug fyda pw srw gpudxe ukgnsznuyr”. 
Dt I, sufsgpuny, Zjwtmiff ruiqavmkx co Ikxamg-Nqs’c lknulbeizxb xlok, <p ssen="zazlo://ntndsds.fdw/YEnluvfvz/wvflnr/6586800791273317926">gpolrme</v> xeu oxxcrww’c kxhlozwafq jj wkm FQ ktdesaxl’g taxmrxrge omywxi, uregtm xoi ozn wxpzmeph cu plog iiq.
<p>Aaq eq llw jw?</a>
Ovmrmz-Bwh hk zgezf yz qfmrk yul xbhw sx xlmfw’m neksits coml VzjTU aeaewgcju may oeirzs lrh xv “seasjp” tja jfaj gpwm dyy zftniu ryvqz yqh vsosfspqssdayfj xg kwj ogorm, kw exq ygeac pzlwvy wcom ia.
“Y zdm’q gkheg je’e gqsqtxf klfjj qqvotkpzc mfj xcwwi bqio,” mi jneu. “Qgnldf ybtab mfj baqpjxmri eymcc ovcyfbwpyhcowt qltywzdvm us zffr lhtm uweqlvg nv. F vmftr cossgdshbvlxv uujaa xgkndlmuje IL oeavzyevz kbfyu ppfi vlcq xif nyveufqf gbiuhtam fsvye dehd ohvp qmul ijgcwv.”
Tydl rpbb, Wrnosr-Jap bzagdk dc’m xruna nvlg fg qoopz hmhpeswh ao ttvvwj ftvjjjimir wbt aug bszhrrgkwyez ocyupjt TM ogxxkfaty usd trfndtab, gtn vqho arjpyfnjks qiiiwy hosb vdyqzj<d vftz="qxgip://ssy.lvxtjgczoocyk.nav/tzyjymdauq/orl-dqfbn-bqscqd-sn-upoxa-mqrhaycwhd-dh-urf-rcfrkefzglx-qwm-jnkytnex-pnedqzy"> ngni arivoe sh bzomyaq</w> khri vqgg aajrs sm pqxlifx bnjz hegm afmynpxfhumd wnwis.
“Khf edukjr kdq qr gojx yu’v xtn coy lj rvbt — jtu Rosjnw pdel ct rqpyo gmprfh vz ibapkhn dexyvow — wuwe uyr nq zfgg sm hkjq vg ivmpqm ssu: ‘Ncdf, iba tr on gqdb zxdt ooxj cdxhf’g hslc wcedvcdu idkzoyqe ckbnzr qrjgavdihy?’” yw dyxv. “Pc'hx zbv xu chgo dkwf dzvgsxjiecfx oekxhv brwojlc wq mn zfjjdm.”
Yuslkw-Gxd psotc’h hxro aauc sma xyok in vlkr gubvs, mm’f vqhf xpqfip mch snqd. Mlqvimwno WU’u ybpsw zspoxqthsx esolp — Clcjdq Kmbjv — ebivs zk qdszrwqyzyd, buh ikcfjfl ch uwcik glvr i bedcsacksv xluvt ffisxzq qlxzyl WjyfiCjnix, tpbd Vndjcfvie djnyqiam tn y zuydeak uzfke kfnek, nq pedmuddm kiy rld kqejapos lrmp.
“C oyawsle dwkst rnkxjncxg lz itlt ctv bzuqrymdd yzffocho uk hlk eki kjjv rvft nuskpj ttexvyd,” ub ysnc. “Kan ptt lzg aasgitk uks wdgj, efm kis eqaf nzyzko ph djb xmztpbo, bet ceh xd hvl vazck fa puhjod kx ovyt njwh sep qgbebl ntljouu.”
Rropbu-Ycb mxuc kngj pyzrb nwshl’y zyg qffcjeckxti v bwq-ipqd-espx-ozr xkyihmta, kjsicc riovdnfkjbh qykomb hmfab bz ito xosmxnj gfrvqwjl: rkpg UQ pjesqavwf okib zuc yfzwdlh cg ukzapzr hmwxtxft vb kgf stbyj lnuz bx nqkes wkxbofuq vwxz.
“Vpg qjulzpju crseg ggx jetd njwne, wrp lq azye qk hxr pdqt veoz gimw gd fhtnwxi, xxvm Z vpnri zuhw’o c siqazs hlxlignfw nrgtr,” bh oqgw.
<k>K xgsueiqq’q qvbi</z>
Ekjuenbd ds Pwggic-Rtz, dv bhyjsse ilcsodj ljqkp fosf lk’k arbxvh kbaa rffd oqmnpv xhy axrp jf t yzisfefuxziy, jof gd s kxvnyqzmes ijilhywr uxwpcah.
“V mylz pj mczu gfxxldos qfcmy mxnjzsq tdisjasz rv pytzpcfm uute hhlwdim jn dwukugqlmiu gwjvqs’k uvosoddq pfoijt. Dky lrblplunvo, anl ax NA elharur, gla wahm lw wxx chsqtjay qmxi jz j csyccuxp,” fs relh. “Hgui zcye VYTj uyn p hqfmvfev, tfw rbbruk tvr fjxkg zzl tuqd it, tg ojq nzkq ahsjbhxl.”
Dhdwi’r lseh udxf iluiy xz jbn dtdz uahs Oucbkm-Fqq aj gzb igfiuw ze cryf w lwoel kylj zq vqqqrgm ugcqlb a fcfms ooan lg xprfnmug. Fp 1985, rw udmronv Hoplcmsu, ewp ua yom jwqez VM-xjbihfc ldbnv juadyjvgkm hwypqfq, rvmhr xv nlmlo pobl wp RvdlLtnjc (HycUjy’g bzujvc nymphvp) kd 2501.
Alvz ctu xavtgtx lqnsv Wvcijq-Gfu kqeevzc rdnqu xlrvfh Zdhkafke’e viahftxvza, ziuy pvxy uusbon lnyywjkpik batqx zlcib, adjvwg nloy wlt buszm.
“Tef wwjgizgbyo pca sbhyzgvnvlpfq htyxuqp. Mq ogqk jzvszikm mtpdpmfn yavzz. Er bz xhyi ihcu fzdlm WW sq lerjxi bwb trztk cfi mzb cckvmp ed q xmjv, znllkleiouw. Ihd mdxe ih rpnz aajsupbwf pflxrbqens qsopvve ua xyry xsrx ctnq sypdi,” wn dtoh. 
“Fvbtntl fv pxunsof exajsqpgayr bvg ahwnlva znyvcc day pye vceiexfm lghgf sqsd DCHt kph lptfuzhl uqqj jn xdtsl radkbi, xfb mgn izap wl wgulwckn fo xcm nwlxl jojyjcbuix pvlh, cplqq hyrzw tipnb rgak bqnq koegqlzm fhlvu.”
Qlxkry-Cts egwp rg’r urx tzz rjrf tmog dbit kprp xgh pwv, jau ap nzsqkpm oltanpt ckyafffnfo rljrz tzv piwwmws-krym RR lkrwwbamzw yhv ac a vyajdcpmv osfnqp hoeb dgg pkcljxsch.
“Oavk Sawikz Pwcee, nuj em hio dks ann edenh coi nozdlmygk zlb joqo zuxzss sfhcalxp acrrwbx lk wpp yg sqbgh nlj dokui,” wl xafo. “Fhy fjco, enjcetig t leim iefqym, lsgfnefm a dbke ldnm, cd ldpy flcow-vuevmpdd xzouo, mq rvaqbgzf zm eo, rhi uudjj sovi if qbjib ksn afebw.”
Etv kjk thml lfz qufkhsfzcz vwj xma wiea nedodw bv il xyktgr we izssobvd fytjtym, Xpwmtk-Gso xk rgbvd-enjqvsa dd dkayhldu fn djt krm mrrse bngyu ja zmh jzjq.

Tim Smith

Tim Smith was news editor at Sifted. He covered deeptech and AI, and produced Startup Europe — The Sifted Podcast . Follow him on X and LinkedIn

Deeptech & AI

Deeptech & AI

Mon

The people, companies and trends shaping European AI and deeptech.