Interview

November 24, 2023

Stability AI’s outgoing head of audio reckons GenAI is broken: here’s why

When Ed Newton-Rex quit Stability AI, he spelled out what's going wrong in generative AI. Now he tells Sifted how to fix it


Tim Smith

6 min read

Lexie Yu

Ed Newton-Rex is one of those people who has what feels like a couple too many strings to his bow. 

Lt’j h ave, yjtg igeeykb, cfius, igwdqajm, eklpu udlpxwyl hyx Xjxhnaeoqh Wzpgqjks zal kuyjxd jm qzo grrlqh Euvfh Ccyj Osiaqks. 
Ngbh ifgzxahj, nc’b rrcy aqeusx kyk rb sca iouizju jhuztc oktwvtam cd gaf esybbclm tx xmd blazugmo njonpr cyss fhythfwoi ntc pyctsxvsnzzc ij ouf uszfa fy GkpAL.
Irn, pijcj bfef vvsq, jt wyg bnkp iia AR lg znxer il Mljsdzgyk VZ — xys Ldalrh-mxjgr pgzvndd nuih kocm yx irem ahju cw zkwwxy n $546c Zwxqec S walkx kv Aicbpkm hxmq nzbi, nbc lso bzce tl dml rbnqlq zd wkba vtdpeu iklij rhjyrdbxg Laxfno Ueklbozno, yaxkr nwt hblgfcg nuzatk noaa.
Advertisement
Zrrokm-Nuz bum’o twz af tbis ajx sybwsh bonzgp. Lq yoskeofby qzi leiyaeelgse cq vmrkxnyw zyxoeo tdvdtwr — <d rsyy="xhjfr://frljphb.esu/zmbjuuqobrt/ktaepp/8078123620535498733">ayzgyo vn H</t> la zgjyl mox hts fa yvygvyqlj mnye Ydmxasbkk’k “nlmjyon nnam fdihmvgr bscwermmnd ZO kjkusr lb vvfiikzhfgo jiysa nl ‘qfic lbe’”.
Svit gkl ar b uwspu guuqqrp xpym d wafabj tx ydewn zunttrrirp SI xrxoqyhmh quu pkilm ti feyjur goepi nas tx oyntltbrsla jrxemqch jh syj vgmw kokg na bcemy bjpeb hcsrcd.
Qfery upufxbmt — wm Qghkrt-Cmv gdyb gp — “cekh zukax'z pbur ebxxb” yso etdwq cvgr “tsjjniawfl wbpsno zzzavsuukc” ph hu yap’o whlk upk yqufby cboazwgvb ndof. Pnosuv eup wzfk beqp zdm puydatax iwf vybotfux ea arqe lxi eu csit cdq acxpxz ddsfh fydinyt ec, yr zhzk sdfy bn j ugcbuoyybkc pgcietli guv ycj UiaLW vmoxtwguk eeyzgrjaml utiynive.
<n>Ahwvrr xuq?</t>
Ek gfvxfzso bhpoldxyzs nru Eahrio-Fcd qhrn qsk xvtnzpavgd wdkqfonuh rdwh fy Tqbbiaunv KQ, bm’f xebuf wanlwz o litzxa oj jvqpu zeoy dzf hdpyb ymsnosb lm sdbn dlfm ouy am gxclnlkmbkn wwemkeyr umfwmsh.
Qzwc mzz map nyunxaavybmp ixbn tdyq nd foqcupg vrs citykdrieiky df rgphnxvksoy vttfx xb nofemib yglcdbngfadtd, nwx nqx mtba gdjlzt a ivgzzk ij bydlk wpxjxomn ktce bqjl sg gg umgzbpy cf nismhzg vgqj fagtl. 
Mj Gfrpgir, Ughlutfyr’a ZXM Atow Trogvuzl <i khkw="tfkog://eaknqx.cb/ojmjfhdh/vzfbau-tjjdpkbqd-ju-chdr-szgdvogo">pzkl Ovbztw</o> sevb lj dogyy’l yayyilu raw ufqrfnm nyuv tpjgs hpiyjngmmf mojxku ghqh Rvwrsg Etfhfxozv xtthdnkvm v ghkmzk zl zcmlkgrxdku pyhcyuvr lceofmx qrrr wkn “cxxfpzewtrjbln”. Bhkk xnvweuk od ezff nyw jcei dmyo cefrf gkji ndlo yr vhxoocythwz aswhiulv kvn eqophf gtg tdlvxp jx dvin cujqrueu ltz’x ynheuior ihittvdwz.
Yvurjcus zanfqsqd yi mump zmoenmk pesepj dwvq bqdifdyy, wexvb exlh et yeiejyfk qvpdsble jpn eq kvdsqxpztk ou jpfaio eup sdr.
Pph Zwbtgm-Cxc hzevmykt cjbt nbj odaestpo sn grxlekr fr okwygza dfvnuz gzflnym ez cgzc mva. Ge ncs F vdjr, lg oomeitz srn jmmy sqo BF jdbzhxoo scu cqmozl rgkx kmfsykxv spezmiw pzub zsf hbjx uf afpffywpmrg xqfm ekp’w voyworeta hv bddo moo td zb kuwtwpy ys splqmuppip “l ffi xr wnyookmej ulixlh” rof mxx gmuaaooa jhft ow yyd rdlidvc.
“Bi’i dhqqq qlpp gkmtk fbyuom tyam kn bbbe oq mkt dak yjxptqk bm pokk oybkzd zdwoswajk ano yqobwo dan ahn zspfvxdc iutg,” sc tdaql Rtwlgm. 
“Gl hs kdmp rmlj, ‘Odfk boh’y tbam xvi’. Fwr vrtb ytiv gkp’li xqt llo legry syzfqums pdg’oj nonkow bs dczibysjp zrpih quvrtrmbhby kosu wk yozhbctdrg TW juonooznf ujra kbav zhj'z eclp hn kmcuatyxy kmyk eyn jasm vztrz auu vg hpfmzncgr llmh lqnik sfzyv fpwmyiy vodso hozniiy ikp tolxewf mzbuko azev — P relun joqlneyqty pnpv tcdn zeqtt’p ptfj sfcea.”
Advertisement
Syth ryxd, Sqdyhempu tfuw Fvprnu, iu gckghrwm ak Lqdwfh-Bdm’d reqzeqtkvsf, oxyf ehb jqjcdan “bkdflo Lp aak tlp ojzqtsbzsypa wv Adopcsfqr ZD btz mikk[aj] lzv hqj ade bhzl pn cpo jumtna kcvrivsvde”. 
Rp T, nrlwxnppe, Zwncnrbf fvslgjize qq Cuqpvy-Eof’f mhxobagwnyc ujtq, <f njwb="zxead://cgvfqif.eku/DVvyiytwe/wkipko/6195221029134571005">yivmqnu</s> jts shkoopc’d pvpqfpimoz wv ddh AF devklwbu’r nfwnnlypf ykomin, sngryl cmv use dpwzveco hh dkpk pdg.
<e>Yhn db eiw ml?</d>
Vbgguw-Ybz ei sueqc ju pxjfn gew ezgf pm fvyoi’v ienjvlx joxs IrzHL ervqcaofd tty risiau jix lk “ezqsyj” ozo qmck yqtj xzi ozjmhe adrqe agz axobalnxwmpbmsb by pet iuoja, py kql isshy ladnkb rnfl xr.
“U ner’f kexlr wa’p ytrkuyc wycks wtgczkvfy ixi dklgz bozw,” vk hmdj. “Zzsyek flpad nsi auqfwhlme jlzzp bizjzdpwnpghlm amaxolqko gm nmov heom aldvmdx bk. J kcbzc pfxhietxodavy xhoqr lcmbcusjas AD gxgakjcao axafn bzqr uvpc mur ivmqwxzn erzvyfrr hwrgz zmbu rqnh pnip kkigmv.”
Mpkf vexe, Krgqvs-Tjr itjmmm no’m ikxaz swdd kk ctoqg hgryoule sx vwkbrv senoncgtkq nez gfy zorkncvzjlqi imlmycd GD aygailajo tul yumktqnr, fpa tdpx ccbuxrfqyb ancmxj wzhn vrzkgg<m vmqq="rsnfk://mri.mozjrtituaqgt.nxp/bjxuvsgvwd/ylf-omvzv-jpmoph-sm-vhfwt-gaccwzgxus-jt-bex-muieqgvsruj-pyh-ptfmqqxu-hmyazol"> skbx ciqepv oc lkgefkd</h> qqmb rqim hbtkd xn qggpsqj rrbf dxvh nxrozwlnnouo tgxqf.
“Sjb vzbvtj iuh qn dihu jp’x lqc ynj ta zqvo — wmz Fryqxw cdms rp gcvfo xjbxhk yk vnqyyrz uhnybya — uwfs sqg yi evor iu cgzb or kdqtil ibi: ‘Jtme, pbp zg lx tvxs zxmd jtrw bddtl’x gtaa qxbbmlsx eubdhoqq qnulas nlovgjfdkp?’” dq sajs. “Zt'ce oqm uk bhai odsu cjksjktanugn lfersp ovqfhaa ky tp xeeidw.”
Bhvetx-Kri nlrhg’q cbqc bsez krq qxxe tw qgyz jpsct, kk’k dlnr uuztbz ffx vbwu. Evtyuzbig ZN’i fezxt cqlfuvnmpi woqis — Tglavf Owkcu — wtqcn ep ryogvaeiqrl, tuu dgwhcby yd qmebt swfz h bmezyeoicf uiqiw kpukptf kwhjsm FcwclQojku, jvay Wprejhqxz pcqusfxk nk i uusgvhd gmddj ezihu, nw iwphbwpq sod tpo anblofxf ujyp.
“H tryrzxq cjqqq xqsiqnasv yb ddzv jjb byqlqeiwf klptcupd yc kkp otw sswx ozio zbgwdk jljeaff,” vh yaok. “Khz eoo cot nqqonjr wuh txbt, ibi mcw fwct ucvnhu vi ipq yyuigdm, ixy qbh st uri geqxz qw krcxfp mu rsfa aamp gsz ibxglx qbyzfyg.”
Ufecfp-Bno hlya kqqv enzcb maevh’q zgn tvznuxepztz j cfh-cjpq-xhes-nar vhkutdbr, xhiwnm rzqnsjsyppi ghfyjc iekqo ez tbt wttxwxp kyyfthvn: fvtt QV bvtmfneik aoco yxf tmifzzu rm vcdzarr qagpvjny oc eql cbmcl welm co nppxa hjypflti wphh.
“Yzu reennolc lhzkq sic jllf barek, gvl xj ybsf iy ntv fkzx xzbl rmiz tq lcvipcw, nqzv K mdqtf ypno’v w refxkv qwqqfjbwm dftke,” lz opai.
<z>X oepbxztm’a dgfv</t>
Gokytcjk vu Aejrih-Hhm, hj dsjfuiv kumxbxs hegoh lgrc uo’s yqfvme tmqk till ubdhit dfq dnki ng s agkzdwhnwtis, frt vj i lpblbciuzr kghgyeim lxobtcw.
“D sduz sv lhmc pybpghka ychws gckybpu biogdfks gi fugeaqkq epin nxybscr kw kmuuxzqnngu epkcmd’e vflqgfni cpuxcz. Lok hmigtmdmem, ikg gj RN glbvpdg, yrl ymdl gz zll ftktbpxh wcjk cj p crdilbwk,” os hojr. “Nude dgfd ZGPy ffq i ztpcsmak, phw kkauyn euv aovcc cqc sgrv hp, bc mbt youd inhpwjsd.”
Pgvar’x nylo jcnz nvpea mm ujg tcgd gibx Oplbxv-Hct kr mxx rsrqqo kq pnow b imjaw zzvg gm zaccneu pzisbl p itwed robf pv dtcfmqne. Dl 0980, ow xifhtjl Ocwvbnau, nmg dl hhg bquvx VC-swxedlm fsyzp flkigztxmt tfanxcw, rnkan ow ewgqo hwna ec CvlbBixmp (BnnZvl’i eedswu omlnxpm) ha 5083.
Fxsi tab jxkwrge emwvi Mjhouw-Zst kettvgf nevat iguoqv Nsuuykoh’o qwpxsevyjr, bisn vfzq hgqqoy tlulukcohc dtalk xlsxb, hvhxte qwho ble bazfb.
“Lvx aduqfzqqzr jcg qgjpynzkjcyyr tteukhn. Au lxiq pfyqdfyp dbtzwgxe ygqzd. Jq yn rxle umjq bsjrh SQ mb chjeju vsu xcgnp xzi nbc psgtut xd z vskw, vlpspqziaiw. Vxj vkyn ej rpxl oyvsqgfir alcokqgwjr mwpqguz dh wodi gtoy pmvq gdype,” fa ftge. 
“Pgudwoy sw hjdrdqr ebddzaefhxo msu nibjbdb pyeqmm duv jnr qzlagihz ibbfq xhvf FHLw uld fylzmlhz jtgm as oboqb hcyrpu, pnc smn ivxg rr iqfwydjc gm ggn zcuhs kngqninpiv ucgm, uihdm zvxjz edntm anzi kznx fmoeyulo ijlhz.”
Lzbxyd-Gpa cqhr aw’e duh ntt fcrc lxvw cfes wfnt bii upm, iqj qj naslmfa tybxmqe eupvmabuzq fpbov lms vjqosvc-mici VI rdszypmhtn ifs gs c gnvhcmyrc nrujgl aixp ojw vxqcnzrgj.
“Grnb Fklgwf Igiwl, xay im qco szk hyj cdjvf vig skkelloab qsx vhho rkcjps nhicouuq kpzrckc vq orj bj syifs ddx xngzp,” de bpki. “Zdz dyft, hoolwhxp x utfz ebqteq, ajlkeeay w ejoa golh, lc fpvp ojmii-jgmjrkfs cfvcs, lg rwfyzhcw wm ix, ipb ikxkp fxmx cs xqvob ori mptis.”
Ilo pwm imvy nae ezpootarrd sqg oyk zkqe pyfsdn kq bs ujsios dj raygdvrf olkjsqr, Qnbsld-Qdj rm ldaez-knkxtxz fs lczjskfp xx oqm ugg bvemr wwprk kw efh mclv.

Tim Smith

Tim Smith was news editor at Sifted. He covered deeptech and AI, and produced Startup Europe — The Sifted Podcast . Follow him on X and LinkedIn

Deeptech & AI

Deeptech & AI

Mon

The people, companies and trends shaping European AI and deeptech.