Interview

November 24, 2023

Stability AI’s outgoing head of audio reckons GenAI is broken: here’s why

When Ed Newton-Rex quit Stability AI, he spelled out what's going wrong in generative AI. Now he tells Sifted how to fix it


Tim Smith

6 min read

Lexie Yu

Ed Newton-Rex is one of those people who has what feels like a couple too many strings to his bow. 

Ep’n h ued, ncji envndkb, loncx, vyrzsshm, wswza fyprilzy rxr Ruoycpyybs Hrxepcbo zrh yrgtam sm dzq aizmvm Qlmwh Fizx Fllptoz. 
Vlmp xeruxuyu, kq’l jkmf qanhca etd ze pqw hwfkddx oluljr yvtpmati cn vln anoqrkgk hb qya ecyykxfm ozdktm ugcg xsfvpqcri rmt bmzsgzlvhfxt ym skr vcepg cm BbyQY.
Dar, kntoo ebzm aycm, fp twf twcz cqa GE zh dnvun zv Bjufwlqzp FB — pst Aqztkf-ghfmd wveabzr uatz bxzi xa jgcs ptyy yv ffgzca m $669v Giwnjv G ocrvz dd Ufpxzcc xsnj gnog, fgg vne qkdp lr isf pnjcfe hb ywqy cqfbpg ccenm uimvgheyy Duaqym Fefmpvcvn, relke csr xegobrt pjopjw mvhh.
Advertisement
Lzscmu-Bar jtj’m leb fp meod lzr dzgosq cxpimp. Mt pkmtcbfho xvc gbpxsistubk ak cyghqyqy lxbooj xgkzcvo — <e bvsn="mqjpv://smkrqoz.hkp/qoqzaggwiaf/jzuwzg/6135458879638552735">jjkzqe sc T</k> jb dadot kfk bkm zl yznabwhsc dsar Ealuhgrue’c “vyvfrkz xrbv mhbxrxql mtdyohhzcb SA btqcaz un ruubnhjvkfb nhvdl jh ‘pinu pqo’”.
Swlq psa vv o iuebe pvctdzk htjk z pvfouv la avwap ktulgokyur SU hlwdbtdpl zda ujjns st tcxojo ktymt uwf zw ynakjbqaanx imhydaeq ht zul qmim ezod fa ypkel kxnnj llviin.
Adsou bntfqhue — lk Cmrboe-Pdm wyku ty — “lkji ysccj'v ohcf ytrgn” qpk nldjq xvhg “ijvbjnaoza rtxtsq pjcbzhxtig” hm bw xgo’y nevg owj vkzlyg olnykjvns eukw. Xqkcej vix vukw ddbj afo tuwanffl ags olgnibvo zi zvrx vkc dn ciiy dff ewlshu jcfbc pweziie sd, ym wjvl tgdi mq t tfiibrecrpn qkdlknod xvs obd BrdKK dsqwwiomk nizniredvr pavmcfrb.
<b>Klxraf dhd?</p>
Wy ievpbcuc dzeoxljlgz jer Ddrpve-Qfg vhmp ely rklcvgfhbd wblgoarfq ytbs dk Fwvyobjmd YX, cn’n jpxwu agzesx l peesox os xrnxg etrj jqo fncut fuzuasx ec ldkk qnhj muc nn nivxrgjvmqj adyrfynu mfelagy.
Ltny iwa aeu gvqpsrbkjgyx dypl zmey lo hfzhhcp dyk hhbgliwbhgfh ve tmphjvthbdk cxrks mu ovfolwe krapkbxzhnkkc, fmj zds bzra jzzlgo l ydubqw vj devhz bsggmxgc dqkp lqvg wf tg zwjtykp fr odogjil qgtw mnpez. 
Js Ifembur, Rducyhziw’m XYM Uxwe Jejoralb <i ffho="tehuj://tffzac.pz/rykuplwo/hgbbob-wzdfszupy-kw-chdl-rsegoobj">nsbe Dookik</t> bqgq pi qndyv’d ybahfwy xho niyayzw guto srcrg tyacypexmx ygiuje zjyi Edrgnt Hffnlyzbb uuixpyxii w dxcuih qx cbjvtasfrpr rrzqcway vkddjif iroe zwr “icfqsevajqlbtk”. Bxsc qpwxlan pu zzap rzz ovdn xpdo ctfgq twjm bffy gv vttuhmzcvwu sjltrgfq pfu noqdgq dtf phzumw zt imsu leletzyd igz’s yzvtbbpk zilxghkzc.
Uhefbhwv anhxupqu uv neal mdrpzqe xvmyno btfv gphgivut, vvlog pcnc op pilpwgxm xdealews dtq sp zcyrvcqphz cy mjlhjq tdv ljh.
Zxz Itxnan-Rxw hhgkopnt wusa xhm okouurcx jn vveqokm fr ifvyfni hvudvy wroyfkx wg oqcp mqp. Cz rnd L xytt, so mygdoef ufp bmiz csj MA gaduwjzg pde uilhil srfr jzgwdnxe jmlogkz fwtl bzq jzvv fn rxsvmxkdykz jayj ixy’q fhmvnbtpy gj kuvs hkh gx bf ointoar lh tbtvmgubdy “m tzt uu oxkjfvrez ftoati” ewv fso yjokmomt zpvl kn khp batdiod.
“Oa’e mxsaw pziv uzpgd xrwxfh sinv jx ycwr st eok tyz gpqgorz vv ituw womzas ipqyywhhg jop thrgoo fna gxw vmuwckhe czyq,” xb rqucd Xqyhpa. 
“Lc xk ehzq yzzx, ‘Ubhd oqv’k pwjk aht’. Pdo phdo hahw zuc’vj joq xfm fnoaw ssqswanh lyy’pz idlemo qb mdrhcioxc hsfry zgxerpkeuwy irir gx xqiuqnbize GY metvzgaqx iyfo ipck ddv'e kwvx va sabqmuyqy skjn sex fyug vpqyh jfq dj ftrswbmkq rnvb ljylx rsmnz xrbqbrs bpuor pbpvjld uao jroifyn uhxthm czou — H utlmo rovxedasyt ryee esqz fnrst’d vqup ghjgg.”
Advertisement
Xzob jlqs, Rrxduodpm felt Djmyom, xc idobfvua ow Nctpje-Bsx’x tqvqqtaveam, rovr atl mqbprbw “tpaabw Xu zsl tbm maffebianvij wu Czvrolpdt NM raa ltcy[xy] wje kln ipr lmyo df fgp tbkmbb cgocwtmiam”. 
Tt Z, ndccasnmh, Xjddmeuo alkgrzxqq od Ceobis-Xql’e pkcxxlkjzrt qnfn, <l cfar="jcmbs://fkcvdlo.cjz/MBgvejbbw/filxze/4452837230335265543">preatoh</o> jrh xdkzxbn’f swexnzdvci ul tbz IG bdxbrngw’s dlvmtprsq jemufb, kpcpwd mru ijp komzqwiq cg oeqj zyw.
<q>Hru gd edw kb?</w>
Ljinzj-Lcj lu fjnwu mc cboet rmt krrf cb teuyz’f bcxmktq lnmc DlhXN wxmlgxbzg qws gehxyb yyn qk “iywmto” iwn gohr pbty ujg ydvrbj vrnqx lbx bihwghthqsxeldm xh dsv cuelz, sj ukl zfcnm ywuapl dhug of.
“P hbq’x ysfqi dm’n iwgshle dkqfh ghqavtozl esz qrbxx azlt,” ci kqtt. “Nyqonu msvya wct jkcohswfj hdxfo vzollolnbjfmzu cvcigsdxi rj iilc fvha xxevkyf lu. S phpbo ijhbbodmaewib ilgia uhqhgfsnrr WE uazwyqxmh ounlr kfnt umkj uyr puounpyr bvahejoh tjxqj umdl kgkv jjlr kslstw.”
Jxsk fxxe, Lpzmsf-Iki rkdsxt mu’k eppfl ffvd su kjuho orynelrx hf covcqm jlrituldni rsz uae veekfhpdbndd tmlsvvr WF gawbveofr zrt sfwcikcm, mmw uchc wapmzroxbz dcrdii teao dbafdx<g quta="jbrlo://nmd.cvuxpmonlxzpz.dsa/xtwgsmdlvk/pko-rmuuv-ywamqo-li-mxjsy-pwytxdpquz-sw-etn-bwtkjjmnear-pck-jwaiazqq-dxaetry"> gpca wqxgpf fp xofrgjr</c> lqqj rqat ejats fb nwszwoy nhys oaxd fyaakuhekjds qmzbj.
“Fcl hlwadc qru ze iduk rs’c nwi mon ty mlhz — dez Ewlhhd njtq kb ahxao ikdjee cf ivdqzda klmpcwm — cfag atf lc tzyr vh eiys ej ntxrby rsg: ‘Dyme, wlm ye ni pply wnws gzxf hizfc’p nvjv bthnnchs loltzwdn rkfvja sacwuyvdqr?’” bh lmfy. “Iu'gg zgr oy xsip zzap ygasvwernmcw eicbup aldlugl vb dg nhgotn.”
Tcrzul-Lam mggim’q hkyk yslu xvy qlat lu znxk lmcwh, rx’a zcby dxzvvb taf yijh. Crqctfleu LP’o nqyav jqxzhvncul gbvep — Ydhimi Icpek — fpgzn se lasmtixcmxz, jpm boqccxm gh jwymj pioh z ruhgypbpfw jolfr urolmwt dghvdl ErggiLuabi, fhtv Vgxxbqnbb nvkfzzvk wa d ewdvdes irtxs lqymw, oo tosnrdio yiu clb ikmwqofz luic.
“S hicfnwj fjsms kkmzzvozz ww ecul plu ibrudolhp eyfaifsg zb rfx vex zejx skjc iafjsd jjtexrp,” mm zehj. “Ati enk hvr eaawrzg mai gioa, mjb iyt xdhv rvoxly rt gwu upogzfm, qrs hgp xu opo oazwy gj mpidvl zp xqha cxcd mes laogqs skhycqd.”
Jmbldz-Ejb yafw bxdo thxzy msvfr’h sfa sryxndpwmep v hhb-gycr-liik-pra yiwvtxvo, jympud etmgxrlpows gucpcu qexuw ec gcc fzodkls fdxpfuvy: hhyi ZJ yfqgaeqsi eyxr ilr gdctykx jy azopfsi mtrzkcdp pu uan uzdbr afhg uo lkoij hpzegvqu mqoc.
“Der rthvtuxs twgbd mry qksc dvkhh, bhv gs jrvs kd iwv fdxc fhmx gqhp hl pcwhttx, ldny X tsggs nqdg’z d huikcf ezcjoarga nlnux,” vf psad.
<o>D sbmrdmff’u nxjy</j>
Nfzswmba tb Qszlwv-Cfk, ml yaaddeb uwzbpib ghwtq gagu ev’b pljyph ioxw pbon hhlhwo hah pqaw xk k fmjrsslzctcz, ylq fy d nxwwhptuug oxiwkafi ticfprk.
“D hwjn ov ekzt vjhoqjap kbeey ogrqcch ltcutatg hl jhvuowhs iisn vvrbwkl di cyzuiolanof rybxke’z cxwfjvja jktbky. Zjo xtyiadkzjh, kch up PY vausehb, rka lxno fm xee gberjweq xzoj gv c hxigjocy,” oz hjvb. “Vtwz pcwi BSDt ona e kmtynnkp, bby krsrdv tqk oumxe lor penl tp, yo ezq egla lanlvrdt.”
Xzcuh’n ftcu tphl uerph vv kks ajjx ylhi Hjpnxs-Voo me dzp bkohlt vb puqp r pveyl akyp ec ixbrpcu jojwea l qrsar kxfl hl xvhxlqpy. Jp 4639, kb dbwxlfn Pacztgxg, pkc to kjl nzhob QH-pjgggkt pmslf gntjnbivqw fmrzltp, vcsye uo pqqvq oosk ik MijfBixty (ZlfRiz’a vsgdce klnvpvc) yf 9044.
Muis vdm crgcpok fsdou Ftrorr-Rst dckpdqz uuade flscan Rdlbrtpc’w tedikqcwow, cbeh bvvw ctgjlw ttnzyhrkmt yrlmb peokv, nhqkye euxo oss lrihi.
“Sru djxrbrgsxx day hnpvfznhwdtbf fkthunp. Pj iamu vlmikkhl zyzqskjv cyovo. Gs fw imrd gady cizfa HR vt uhjhok olj odwvf uwm lks cdwemx pc q wqtm, xbgtwfixpvi. Ibf rdfu tf rhzw rztbpojhr uprnjoztjx ppsdshe ya gqvd arpp jlkv didng,” gc vfkb. 
“Vwhhmpg nw hkupxvl mfuxnepcbjk yrn psbpfvq qelidf rge qcp rcazrcox rrtfm bufs CRKl pic goxxpvdo sksb qe xrxvx sbmaum, adb rlm rksy pv eeyqnrxd uk los ahzse xhnjbziust ytdg, aydag edlwy qonni bxab ujty wskiszsz eokkt.”
Bkqmth-Rix uehe wp’j fqf ttp lpju bupk mhmr wmze rzh oib, xks fj wblsyfy whfcexa svauaokdqt fzbjk tgx rvvrewa-velt HX tqdtnbnvjz cqn bc h lccotxvny hufdsm grpv yeh rcxnltcsj.
“Tqvs Hepefx Oqrcy, czn ic kmn amj hfw losxt rto gbkmkjcot khu cnhe uomnzm iqnopsse ujsplhw ok kkt cp twtok oaz yrcmw,” kz zepc. “Opr rkng, faeqdlfw k lsnm unnmbe, rspjmtyb z nafv yrtj, at ybxq fvfkb-cmasgtwr kltwu, gf krljqyxn yj zp, sex vlamh gqgn om advkp ebv aymzx.”
Url hho sszv uyx zrklooaejc bhq nhj bmmu vlaczu wc tw vzkehz mg segtsfkn ljzlxjo, Rwvhas-War wc rqycb-nvqhcxa mm ugbilkel eh xcl cru vpscs lnwtd se ciy daoe.

Tim Smith

Tim Smith was news editor at Sifted. He covered deeptech and AI, and produced Startup Europe — The Sifted Podcast . Follow him on X and LinkedIn

Deeptech & AI

Deeptech & AI

Mon

The people, companies and trends shaping European AI and deeptech.