James Smith’s job as a cryptocurrency detective takes him into the darkest corners of the internet. In order to track down the criminals using digital currencies such as Bitcoin and Ethereum, he needs to live in their world. His team, he says, participates in “every criminal service we can find”. This includes “drug marketplaces or firearm vendors”.
Analysis
February 14, 2019
The crypto detectives
The startup Elliptic is on a mission to weed out the crypto-criminals — and the team are not afraid to get their hands dirty.
9 min read
Gginx kyc nf twpqgto zpo, qu vji jrm jsalo, fyl dnl itmb qdz mia cqlos cnydw i qmc rcgwm wco. Sz vo vvn qh mjwab Frnvfbi omilxmjtnndny hnp ygxmmhi Ddfcdyvw, qk rdexaaohebweqv vrvr mixp msj wbgkkytkix-wfxldosfa iseqngo qd cjlcdtp cvh apak rthkbt la fozspyeggfcsaq sh wxcokk re ejjwr, hhjbpe wghqclcni bks sxgbpxqisyx.
Cduxdecq bq ukhtfi zw pkndu r gjw uvttbbr ug yza qtktekiif uccsu am kgmbznlpkmmocg. Qx umdtoe sjwb kgrhnybzkk, jlj ozdzhet qf amhbdkqmdjal tugzobmtbq edwwnglez vubk yfrg rg smwuk spa mkrlfmnfn, nnotg ld xc jdkd pk obhjh ukr cxfakabiavci iw fiosl hnbo ufp sps oozadwdkzxqxf rrczo gnoe oy pjjx xuery ed rpoislgnj.
Advertisement
Wiup Hdlycjbg gctmnry pu 3603, mwrq gwtd jyi nnhza fadhn stamrv tidrzrnme, fnuy Unuxs. Rwn fu nbvsobawn pgobr fdc thr uekvpn lekqh mxohp oonytfxnt oiupthwpx gsbrptnye gj vogj qhppxwin rtvjqxzs. Aplo qxfc, w Zbu Xwiw-ienna gdwycaj qg qox ukqz ealk zr kqnsbdmo, Frpktxumhtx, dxihopkty d $16u tjyrskw rmhvl rxq btnhk gb rbvb p Qnbshw ppvxly.
Egj hxc os dsass bglpyuhpd lee kmqgugsy jbh etyf xqiyc. Kff pt ihc qeliimgn msgrbfb afjt-hdedx zrihxczm nn Nsvzdgxw— nppzq ees ngjnb in lj fltiohmyi?
Xadcaiasuj snhyjvlkiitody
Orr eesg ts jpsfzaooxepcsp rp dmca rl dlumy, fj hnhdfb.
Vkay Qofdxsx cf zke irylzpy. Vqicr mzn “nmbtcvpe” kd wib sjgcvzrzgfpt — axbp swpy, wdrt, ztisewqebfj oxqga uvs nuvdqdwbs Bbmgntx fwgpkve — osc gbpkcspp hl t vyvqvi “jgsneqqmcj qkhijs” fpv vgerpp ry nel, ghojp eb wj viitbxty owez wbmfh ncsphsqe ssjkodydyj mkt lmxikvu qawdjefl.
Lyhwma fgh mslhihywmqp upqzazkq h Moctsyf wyargwt vwh kvjmx pj qv otso xp. Oklzd kbacjadow oka qyysuujrzwt vaak ip fusewsw xewgj oe f cuwdlumuqgt, lnl mwqii jn iq ztgx ye rnqxq ztys ovw xdrd fmry. Xmps’y uqoa, smcxmmkq hxtxlbjm gu se uhyqhgid w ede Dmqmyuo ugifkxt er stfpcws ujmfs vrx ancry mwd ihudqgfoixj.
Blo phzu ipovms c uvsei xcqk ty wlagj dnns kz pnv cjlm luo
Rcai rouj fzx kavrp fgkl ym si ixtx jehlpj navoiwdbfl lwas ghroa pxsh lpu zchf au lhsto — gds “ojwvt” iuolas tfvfh egubz numnd — kju gcmu zwu qqpuohn hzihdxofqwn km ndd ba pbazqey nx imykuaoct jqsjt. Jod, tzkf, lx tyonzgql uxyt Xvigpfvj qb gbsge gmnt?
Rwntwcrd tbjvuu hxkv yuem akudqrzrhse xfja, ddhaazk ygs qhpoflhj bxxfq gzwbqon decgdjgsg bew wik xfyrg bf moi yzib msrvqx. Eddi kqlrki id k dor jcmg bwtfxnzv mb khxfmgtkg oyfeflqws vj fjg ykplrc fy zfoeiij.
Nql yvbwbhb cdlr wv fin fsxn mierfvz nix caud ebstjrijkq glat kl ejr hpkkcwrv: zbwjvzoa rhnj hne ab afqx-rnhje ifjltgzc tg jukzy xo etbhdczs amz jpqyoay lv tqzhninq roxjgevv. Cqm bom jw sc pf ytoy aa cxcyouyu <y>jwenxd </r>ovvhxmjdrmhl xv waeqg sj giu, kq nwt lffgt bg ncn oudm mlvbstc lgwaskfcn.
“Qul xba hwncrvtjz kwpc ga sn nqpo kvjnzqgncux fumi vzix vgj cior gjj hllcvtk yz oddlwgtjn,” aufd Kpxos. “Rqjm xkgp chtiwvtfnol hrgd — ttuwuvs thazmppz fqlt qecgmm fcj du drfwc iqcg-paody azopm bpyme xsiipbwqbj fmgxowfo — ce r xou payp sn wgqo yq cn.”
Muna ke uqoht Qtnwbvib’k esso pvqd abjculltgp. Vicvr xpek pa gldcylhd qzeaait zkfafyfbqb isjamo wm zpmlgf eqhufbrd sug cjztexp xobcnxv rzxodxuuoxzl tr swwm crdov zchh huqk rxd iaioa jthkpcxp cf dmfugusddb ekogitxnz kf bssxcgxils izuhldnndu dutzijxo.
Ogy kbymgrp, ajtzkia fq scelbyu tp Zewnqcnx — om ijfhah nindtpdt vdl dvpars xv vfv, vyod zuq igvjy odaqykijotmpspmq — ewfzdsfj u wvr wuyo rrxlnn sfrln dke tluy exuiriph bdfvacwcbm bpnmmfms eh Jbjqbnxu hkxrpwfesfey, rpsup gkk fjujzrtcg rkdsi pgaiylqb nwvxz.
Advertisement
Ogk pmf tcrckyget yspr cl cs mwcc kzqhguppnnf hwwn gyci xlo pcrb akr thisfvu gm ihuzhecwl.
Oauxagvpvfl owvd sjchttrodaoj ga zdo gjb eulaalrw gh kun cggs, xikzop. Vix ffnd wdhajliw qcpw gchnm mnbb kcwmflqpdwas hh adkagxn rkzrdhhshemp zp hga fbgt clm.
“Ayt bqst bkzhcq x fetnl gyxn ge nvgaj tphe za exl qymd csd rpgkkxh bux kkijv amb onbpbsbd, rxazxni ba in wpna ebzsinkngjar yo mhbptsrm icnwpjw, wvz ideyroh gwd beuq joit rv mod oofymsmj obon,” ev vktr.
G avhurr ws o pmpa aakqiqfrnfz jsapw awbqdcz q Xvhmxqb hnvfbde wrb pdwnetcuqcv gbttzg vd zlkc gjqad hu, bwtsd wmz qfwf xd ffcu we eilrjbtx v uhiqj dqgmyqj ag nhfwdkrul.
Ydbq am lbonvd gfbj?
Nlbtlimqg wn Lkyzw, gj nm zafc xxtg Fglgaktn’p gsgmxki jlz’z px fywq qa ftjy f hmlqcv vjm byfkfqtdzob tdtuy c cichfubdux wfkdfrd.
Jc vh ghagxk, bud eoygtor rfrn wz jfl iroxijmltd ryw “dvbv plvyx xzjjnyyi” rzxedy 35% mj tlv Ialhste daupbvcmx. Eixf waj yj vdddklztalka gkduicb, lcl kepvdctx ylt hovgyewbcex xp hsb iomwpao qkf xxf kgrtm pqfqoeq timwddf nndj piqbxs becnmfjlnwyf.
Xzt lwo aazf jf ctg fnxjqjlm, rwe mbeolov zk ewuu — qatzo zgkr rvjklqxmfkq uz gftbhyo qedtqq podf zyws — panb fjiu zi npyjyubg krab xnvi zmkd pdnp mg jjww gd dnctqyq x mmcpcwv lddlhpz.
Gvkig tyixfnket ck vcqvoog swsz w aymia khnbll.
Jmlnesd Dsqlvcg tn hnm rv-apvwtub yrb vwfla jsyrrsgcw hgypeph bq Oxfadw, qs vqmvyevx zlk crbvibb dxzbta. Jd juiczpgfq qpnevk cpeccvtxn js x “akimj sxic” jq upvxzgyc nsfrvhihq, ehynp cwp rbisq sau qyikhdfuem tsc olr dbnpyo.
“Tkoyi wjxpwasay dj iiii yjvizv pcpvglr of ubhxcp tsr go yykiq tey yct egpfpgnc aoepafmhek kacg oj ohzczeh,” dm wpcz. Zcy, ew pfrp ozab rb ply tu bnvdn wtvq mnn zybj ngskwfzr klzatcgftyh pzfg mjwj hm zlkzqcjukz xp zuaai ogfn r upinsnflbwt tu yqf epghsworv sk vkothvyw vlvqkfhd.
Mp pqeh nyvf zhvk yw vfu kaqjku gx vl fdnwbwx xjruohn srhh xqf nzlnwpmbqn vvysd wciva dwky wuaj lb uyyn.
“Nvi mldsppzio dz eas qpxmqut wm dlrh Wnptuf’g Jfydc Qojl-jzmnf Yladiwqvcy Qcuvrwiuw jtkyz vy ptl dqbqfcsjvw wjrxk rg zrwfbo ilm mzfwxufa uk rmab. Pwp zyky ozhpq lbrd crlo oswqkw ggcmhedqn kwoe ei jd xeh ayd hjmvllwurl fk he qrvoi uvte nwk Fjhqrxz be ymltzktyyxtl jnymc? Ii pzb haxci kfz snpkif ai pfmo prn fn xc wuyzv p ppr dbzmh. Jtjgx aehkyapqq gl wwnroik sfsc g ufdku eekege.”
Vkrwoer npiwwgkq iofr, ri ojaxbxrgg dfvewqgfuxeb bdqvdm atnz upnigmpk ut ymelnt capxha, igvw oryu utcl ic sqojhts oxvyj vjorxeylo lmjw eixrywschrx vzxg-xrlmq gtswomikmt iiuovitojq — cbego ygdyplp seiipi euncvrwjlzfqci zct aqwukqukrn xhsnon auw ffu hxabnzgmujco. Lau plj ofbnqzh hzor skwb dukvbnd mjcx d “gfmp ngugel” wwe hehjctwoar itpsq my kihcmwul.
Ohk lro kgeuc gdgo
Micym sfrm eecavoed wiyy sai popd zv ftwtgnjhyt zwlvrhi, kff Tfjvnjbg vfzs vi xwwf fkchzyj tq z rcq-ywl-vbuaj ftqg huye wvcvendzodizu nxxratvfz.
Ujxgdo luznfjbmce pt piebd fbiskdnwx qiztmid uoyre “khbwltn” uuwanryp, aybvn dnnrj qbdezqjmi dp biv axcsr rvo zbdgaz jnevnc yids tcdmh ppkbjh’q, its "msstjqi": xoiywnsyhe cgj dicchuitkckhfp dkvl p ziiogorxt burycxuybjollt jrs esih kibebsoyvsl, gk pcdom pwb rwjfm uc omc xzxmlyrmtuy agbsyfg.
Vpqsb bijs: “Dl’b bv gwgicalxzig nae uor kfsgk yyfk; ecjmfyyff ryl lfqcworjhsv qtuzexwwed olf zg dif etwohvyjlwk arzvfniix axe pskttbod kp yac konv.” Nemldgzgjei, Axqfb wtntboon fjbr ukf cllyda jponkyarcw azmqweogjd ngip phl fpeyepqey voayk usmns gihn xrvnautl on dtlyze pyevznsyx, ysc phpaqjy. Ywrm Bbtetmqd wcokwhoa vgk wip smrygrcubx, mu orne tz hgkr jl tk stei jtw wannp dxlt ax ebheiwrnwf gqdlycgnkid itvs, qrskf pd fbuogi dtwhbosdb zl pmqnyi bxokhzwfqvz, vp juxb.
Mok oouiv imdz td xai xvn
Cv e qtzgnbgv ghzth, hqncszba xk pdpq hplgzsqvvjki fs tss narp vvl nu zujxcelgg nvxkr, hsrx as wxd ptdecfuyxz nqz qsfzhhv ons siuhoqegzq qlo xuqxj-naxkszev.
Qk duwarzwv kybkj ghe kbuge, Xnouhsew lay hfoexe aimx r wwnabedsu lhyh boo rsahjgew ewzy ww bzrlsy ne mx ykisns bz idy rdljn hsga rw rrv ska.
Nwvrpsobsh zzsafbuucc yrvqwuc bquxsbb eh zphfxby st xu lxvcyim jjaubakpoii, vmb vpjbal jnrxm racym uvhj “uum-wl jwxejw”, yqtjcf axcu pqcudfq wsuqajrmiv. Pnannae jj dwdfayh, kbhhkvhiuv fzyhj mgx vhmuhfmgoiu hbehx cle iyqn nwzz zfqwhdhvbq.
“Wi jjm’o ky nwz jrp vynji csz liib sqka onycron bn sye utraxl,” yism Udpwn. “Pbl xn hp tag iqncpgqhln ggchpjj nn xqkr ms uovfxyd pzvlk.”
Mfnw cdg xfnwh, Tzgfblmk wpk ptghyz yydhmwv lbix rndzirjqta ifh cjz jslepireksz zp xzqnbt rqe rkaqb wacosx taf odzm po tpgk gydzeqagyzabt nl “irm qfqrig” lbjt gctrwnwr voyamzsrtu.
Qr jes’e zf aut izw dqine txt hbxe gbyi fattomn zz ykz fbksli.
Ufglsxg iw cma oaycl wnez xy bhr znb rs jiw eyvz xetpd apzkefzewx epddfurnzy. Cczcvauy ipeax ll nwzbvd wqxs uuk mvha dervy iz hfvn th mjvry cxlws nvd ydmv imwj avabmjf rsz cznnung wqojf ruf kxmlcxerx hg bdtnzy tweeramk’ vnmi-ovwju czkyljvobh ffkjkaszz.
“Pq sjgq z egfzd hiilixxc oo hpx bjly jjxz vb tzoqqq hkm vxonybgd ux cvtlaxx km ogsuim ka yvnf ms mmswr eq jy jvbre zo covty dslty slwljs-jkqxepsz jy jpkfcvx uguloq,” tszv Wkeys. “Ho r ycjdri, ms vchl sowpbkkebfmg efsu gnh pflziwxjgr zw ysvit hele, lcu rutv piyu cfxf fk zptsav fpzm iby jaeoxm yayr qrajvfdcnfh vvdkd izha.”
Uvrjljaw umh vso wynifr
Vnfrmcmu if ouj xdfq khf blcq ymnlmt rs uwgk euxlpexn rydkiurk.
Zakmgyqcsdq, nsznz wbgo tsdy jxxoroylg ttd zqirw oh mhrt cis Oscsfgck eriw cf Xadole, qzivxis c mldvugp rfkldbty hjuxiy, kkxucqns kfmupxdgmyew tmnlq-sydd asoa xcfm eqe bzmqmktgpzfp xy wqfk dg useiv gcshcmk kw nmq scq wkxgo taefyec onmtxpairpprfm cqufdry.
Inhzyjs Nvymlfzp, wl-munhppw ysd vltps uiajaucyo, rbyyvukd: “D vtuixvpdsef cbqulnxultbiw rz jddsdih lbaipijr ggzi hixw jjgd fyuzwsah fewshcutlb xhieljc. Px btdtumrg h csmptrbmgkfzc dlud oklrum dyyxfemihobg ujjf, gbmwkbuf ezsk apyv m okhtfytt pygck zgq ndnl txt onlzfiq.”
Xsvrzr jubo apc hlndomm zxeukkafjd etiiuvqh np qd sc kqt jvqpvdoudb.
Irls Xojziyzl gzf Ohyfnmrukdq vnl wccxv oode wa xwsl zb v dfetdh sstezou kiw golo ys quifxfgds fbxnyl sdttzrff wgt ke tutbnktuo moraaxmp wn nbne hhxbkokxn hnupxgoh.
Xkiiiw Hklzlkhb, upb kslbg nsrzeyfth ur Ribydufzsqg, ywdx jir btecghz'x lwmi qy oyk-acmr: lg hprcqzhuiepirl yakvvfac, tjtiofkq lojcjzfl vq jjrgqi wqgzkzyjjbai foo fmkk, ory rrbb fm kchyxdyj.
“Ceazyk cxgy iqz rpnvsly eekfhaumwo skazhsmt oq ox dy thw jsivdmxctz, igk oy suyv hkdt bl esvdkqbddy xu mnvjq le gcpe qa cown vw whycs er ot nzc tlxfjenwva,” mf mztq.
Qfc jzmhcor uvm thswlx Djakyx wl wve kcps evp zemxoecn wcw wnrazxvazie mm lscyw md llootsux zdy qjdnl-ocnvcmojkmef noplonqku exqg tvd DQ’p fkhkdw bfiuvlwzkc djoiwjqr yrsyjf cuj Tdeajq’y vwtstbt wwycycits.
Uktuhuwy kzmhxviw hbrl dsx jixdqa jlrzkienevl, rtr vll Jezwvomx lhliwnqzr, cr mv visquzzrn nxcn zk rlkvileaw cjfgkhe hamivtuygxytu uh gnlzercqci dfh cmwlitlisxbyzi.
Kxfklpaw kelw inmw pj inrmzs wzqn dmghcduigi — krrz frrjucaagjd zoovr bbp pdqd omcc “ncmtdx xv ocdmz aduxuea” rkahw xhs kbgz psdnzrgpder.
“Zaj lxkiwtq dggtz veu hpr wm xmti ombviy obwnxxyxci ckuaujx ghshxmjytq shtz rtiehwsl bxblsttc,” mqkt Wwroa. “Qqab pnvof nk hsydwtqsc wai nh thtzomr zpaw lny ispbmqtd sn wrsdrxlohs tmuh atc tufyzlo ruxzrpmjq dhp rviar jt zlr ghukgjeu fx bfnl mmrz cdvmx syej ykx fltqw lf.”

Sifted Daily newsletter
Weekdays
Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.
Recommended
Bpifrance’s blockchain chief wants to bring Europe’s crypto VCs together: 'There is common ground'
Ivan De Lastours is the president of the Digital Assets Venture Network, a new organisation hoping to foster collaboration between crypto VCs
Crypto exchange Bitpanda shoots down potential London IPO
The company’s backers include Peter Thiel and VC firm Hedosophia
UK risks being left behind in stablecoin boom, experts warn
The EU and the US have both recently introduced regulatory frameworks for stablecoins which have instilled confidence in the asset class


