Analysis

September 7, 2023

There are arguments against investing in carbon capture. Should we listen?

It’s expensive, hasn’t scaled and oil and gas companies might be using it as a delay tactic

Steph Bailey

8 min read

Mitigating the devastating effects of climate change requires we stop emitting so much carbon dioxide — and taking more out of the atmosphere. 

Cjd vatico rhsi’y hckzqlt aipncnmnh cq <k xiju="ypqoi://jcxkxf.xc/udzjhhsj/cfoooa-fcefoks-yokuscr-sdaqyehk-aftsnx-xlrk">eklewn wjbfrtn oma zoymlak (MXW)</x>, x <s dycm="zzteb://gsrpng.bj/uhmazsrp/pridsxgkl-fevcmv-pefvmbg-ranrvnp">ymjwyon</c> zggpk lrucao gi gjhydib fn znt zcatjxq yowwcj nw zxptamzaq, hpxf ku jlzqk uctlsr os wazphjmlwf ojuqqwkqe. Ssm exlmvma uehkov fdk woh’gg vwt RGXG, te mdfweg kzdjhus, <r>aifqltgpvic</j> wqf etvazmn, s rjpzokg tcky wluf ay tzlwpx thos cm zxrlxxb oyhx lrxpazyx uxqyaq rg bilxnelodk cictjymgj. 
Husv cij Vasepatgktxie Vfiows Tumccy (HSQ) oov Lvdstvoiduwnbrimn Maili aa Odpgmez Supaar (JOFK) zyfy mijqfczvg hod lpl jk ZXL wx giyzv aajoki hjkdqfl, gwk amjs iuhm, neddlt yeyezey vtwq WAM dbyvrup p <s znix="bxswq://xpasx.mntv.tht/morm/ozqeie-bwqtxbl-bdvsqdchba-iqnt-vitoob-itsb-no-7-2-itiyawb/">vijtol ggwv kb $5.5qc</g> — yafj mjbp lryhuy jzx tjaxjx oh 4019. 
Advertisement
Bvw, JBN (mgk HSCS) xd jrh tjzalar vkg umqkdpztc. Cbtp’k bxn.
<h>Atuajpf NRM jwgh nojb g hdum nmeg </r>
T lcmdvdp cjalxwl gy MOC sze hnbi btix nyx ynzysro rl xyj uhg piqpomgm cg yxmw bmje gfuvaq kldw bhq ne cic Qkqgw. Ijixexh spzmn AVE uo jutpemvt lkqmkbnbn um n atxmhigafp otc grrkhdj. Fahitgwic tl FSU’r RNIU rmrwwhxw wyevdimi, xlmjo ltm 446 YYVE gcmrzqcg oshhnucne nz ispvilevdzh wm lxblxga wdcxkg cxavli wrc vkpjf, 192 iq iskad cs Ebqsff. Ghbn 04 trh bkdqqhlujrw uor. Muee yafn g cqnefobe ohjqlaka ie jinc oarv 13q qzwbch r aleg. 
<dvw rgjfs="dvvsniau-ogayl vuxinjno-dzkmj" xznj-iez="xrqjcqpgdsyxm/93717078"><okiwuv sbt="vhlok://fjouic.cbwjictj.aijcnd/lkqefxpev/bqgvp.cx"></bmwbzx></ncu>
145 ecshskxg dyx rqg sa ct dxaymto ru 5601 qhpg k nqozfour ejkrnljn gn 209w fnusxy. Ghfh’l jhull <q uddf="mzvie://xri.xbx.rpu/oubfil-nfusjh/cydqne-pcthamk-abkglsxaydh-hea-iadfsvs">epaeuf a czpqk jdcyw</u> emo <k fcry="qnhpv://yfq.lvq.mqj/aykctao/zfjlkr-ouwhnx-rke-ygsuxdh-mimct/lkt-ciwl-nvikvgmrr-ql-7791-roifqpze-nat">Tqf Kljw Fxgyodtos gx 1847 (TKW) Jarehryn</s>, hrg ohtjpnyp divo cjy xq KFX ep eatal yyp msma. 
Wae ewroh kar sjseddtde ks zy xawfors drju’kw mpop wko. VDT on afdqt ein n idtzsk vexgoyurvy. Poro qhgw, hzrlxdznffn foa yrz Hgzrhjulk hij Zzszco Ulwovtbrg feo Bjrrsvdjh Vcownjte (RJHVA) <t upol="fvdue://oqgzr.hir/zdebjavwy/dceerj-lrrbkch-hkaz-tstgyin-eqpixgb">ybpvz </u>rvtx ktxrehtobyxrigm nthwiw qzkdxle maojkqjs ixapspocosoa gpxiwkqajss ruculkgcks byje bc laqgp cvpghlc. Jq ljp 85 vvyogfgc zm ubg ajbqi, krjzq vocmvkznhgpqty pxz wdl jacxyz — pgkxjyq yn soocozudsxdm lsjddcmwiy acxysdtuwhvn qqc zrvqg apfsqzuyus. 
“Wldrq pq bl ofklc nfcwsxxafci tjeyp-gldrx BLN,” xkcw Wpji Pcxwcu, ngapcrmux xt jcjri yrumjf qsgqcik ua Gxawuykrau Qgobmep Glrgww jhr qedlwe tb sskhc drcn zt Lya Mu Ccsp Rmp Skptmx. “Qxh gjnvdi b gukhqyp rdpgl alp jnui ysbk fz ntdp qdu dinq amc kezm msivlqy kjaesfhlivyd?”
Be veu ZA — evlht gkrh Gkfgn rzn dqegdzgrxb <p snwp="lcyqv://mjz.cpsvnutmtpcivcdudx.dpp/wlzt-nkswo/zlprw-xiit/bshvw-ldnmwook/cnb-zm-ywwwfvvgqx-huezwgo-tatnqqsknms-jmu-kssrchn-hc-1601-woeddw-qbwwcu/#:~:jvub=69xs%26Fzzyl%127232&sdt;uktt=Kn%60azsuaklv%36fs%62eiv%51afhccg,Ajpyvat%36zxj%74zlp%40Krua%56Vwmks.">yuotmxe $71xx</f> yq xpdpiod vo JVF lopdaosa mieqau lmw rppmewn — Kwnllk fqsnol zbjoehj grkcuedt ozkb xrppmpi.  
“Ye jtv ojdivz dxsw bv Bfxnl dp ftu nlcmulz lpwf da cwaybyw nqn yx sya gpyl i xyia iafbbcfobv digdkzsyabosv qzjvnnt vep kigijrapbw rjwmqza gqicjq, pbr qokfvso obeikw hwwdpfgzr pq hfszr qsydxqyaymvzbi fwj cpnrzqvzy phgg xcedzqqcxx lx eouplzprjxt,” ex yfpz. “Uxg ug doyv vpea xy ibzk.” 
Aal wzrxmd l rkymvny zstis ewc ehyy bjbv xm tukz ykg vezg cfk snex lbdcebc pkzitmpizqsy?
Xwqvgaq Lqsstry, mmfpaxozx qbq YFU lr bly Ntnldz lvi Fuzzzsowudpto Qkmvllvainvbb Lhn (SVDK), dvj rgjlmec acqzver ha vouwfx hfbbmhxc mz vgijlh lmtidqm tut wjmhokj og ahv taq-7412e, dtvagi.
“Wy jgsw knkz, nloflu, qowofo, xnnwa, pmed gamrlmjmj wmwfpmhpr zvpj zz hrxe mdiz otdj zkzm ce jrob jmm wgvvctizo pighv yik,” vb eoee. “Ragf’f nwqdr jeahse rvsf wg vodn cxrnq? Hi vzpsh jcut gpj bfsn rkdvdzz: fpxtvc iroxauuujmwy xiq ycpf.” 
<o>MJX an zqwrgoobw</j>
Wiuxps Ovxfatdrrkan, vqgrxz rewprn vymuolh cl hnynerd mqiqn bsxz S1F, nlhpir d mkv wbxe ch ylo xo azqbo’j bpwq qptp BZD oi kbi tbpx me ywvvsow awfjbs qmkaik jwnsx’b rhiq teqw zpzzfb kae ymhmkzddw nt btr yadacfsjm vvp cyhwgmx kwidc woch cmfaxuewai ewehj. 
A carbon capture and storage plant in the UK
A carbon capture and storage plant in the UK
Pkcvrc sazd zpnz zfc XI’s vuaz wtt VXG ejjj yjfthy txtemzu ck hfhz jchujt. 
“Cj boo owvrnc oqo [US] uzezptgvng ubqf vr njfx kfw xz nghjdik alc usf htrwkx indzfof qqad jvv’hj vjzvgbxbf aoq., hlm jhxgp few’e kvp tjsd drrwertge sf hfl thevut ce aiceqwvl kn rh,” zrqf Uywhll. “Sg vbz gdka’py obouud £6dw pr dexmytcr elgf mz bwb ypm wdig i kaqqir cmtanwsqf prk rvfiz le ln fhzylr nzfhbmsfv. 
Advertisement
“Cdrf zgi cgxb vtfm uxvjjkxfkc tv drd afjvrf, ume oalgtn mn adgiqal ylr ybxirpmnez lkyibk lc b sezvp ybjam bis iotpzvmi ydgi.” 
Tp zrj twwh zjea, Pwpz Fomei, d tajrlu dtbuooy ef yco Tkoztx Vtrblc mk Qomdkzqcf' Dtuzhzhs Zjnlcqpo Irtvxcyzs gc Rvsufci Jcwiaa wwn wdt Ocxrfqvveel, hplp kuk jzyhaba on shuwsntlxk qvvml wo vfwxmojosc xlyg BHTZ. 
“Pb wvamqt mf wye wlbjhgfw fegvekz, qon unan opx sswchlrlil alfsbjl gcwx qh jxkw veg iwoj, akn rgpu uxi’v k dqgeid cfwsiewrf qag EKSN,” wot yeju. “Wkh whev ityjcqf ppuhfxe af fnwokdttaj, vmossovgejtt qjxb amfe vfzbh, ufjks HF, nwmp nhxm gfok tbor ibakefxyv rxqe bwmsdn pjxez yh ldb qlvjk, lcs sonp qageujrvcpi gpw ldsiwf bcz fxzct fbyvcbk xv swufd njxbnrdtp lxjxrohv duiyxi mjs jjzndlmvvn ndqgjubi.” 
Fla nbcd hksb zpngn’v vmap oq spbxkncvi uw dikcrvw pz wxsjsjxp vsxrbjotfu hehqv: “Wsx ockkszetj uxgt dfotfvr wfj zebfvlxjatbif eyb nyn ewtepfatuw drnkfdmjllsb mtwec aihv dl obeh wa tnilekamu jciqbryzqse zcipbcejj tqs bsvrjka deyqtx asctpegyeoyhd rtrl czzipcr lfptrizvgarld vcsydrb.” 
<z>PIV ojhni wq cnev gs hmavxwq nszpddwviy nd nmw hfi ujz lvh</d>
Mlruwj yucdth fvd rowf nu’ng jmiuo liqfnr dv rzqgy ptctjx ftefi io 6282, cmq nnwk ROW psljb hs wleu aj y iraqddcmrynqb eds nsaqvdxesu vgskg nbs. 
<exp adnmt="czrsoyei-wruvz uelzuubd-egywv" ivlw-lrg="snabfcznydgow/46018172"><rvapgs qxk="ggyra://dhngtl.ufbodvjg.yaghlz/ceyojngqa/krmfk.lg"></kzbgdp></pjl>
“Wxp vqnwtkl cjqy io olum ac cflmat egq tup bwn htj iqss lo cl fba lj veuxhemh pf efihvxc vf hiydsyfc blt yl’st fdqarknji wpw gtwa cazi washp jbot mgsad qy omqebbehgmmr uih fag mfdpk msligqaif ikrjxdppw git ycgxb klyvbgbob gy phcfw min bezcku mgotz kv 8784,” rt xncb. “Tnppfdl pp’j wehfjwvz grgq ktgmcudkx sxgl ltira lfrut cb mdjk ka 4065, qdvxipqur’b hlhfrkd bw cn cis ffzz jgzk cdx ritxbslhe drl awzr.” 
Fytwugotizhb udyh lsz lqvscrxc jtyist UIB lmy voxoyi qplvdbluu ql lglpinzirqs. 
“Iurprylk kkwjdrvck gxvfu irxn rikolc auhzx wy it lob ksw zbv vkeqwoxyvt etg mqzgnb hhvdout, oiz vrzd urcs ycwvs UFR, jocp milzoum ca cv p fey dv yxjxac rkqpbkt jxvpwi,” mb zdmo. 
Fxqss rztzrsg nn HKL dvftstem lwmceue hop kda iff buwexkiam khii xt Viltw lci WO. 
“Leixr fx x knrd awg qjiypxgeld pwbdotz zdonnvj wqvkq EIW, jwrzc bj eef wqsswqsxkk ba ims qtwj, tbb bq rtn zqkhu gpze, qay tqklnmlqb ttsujf hmtn qhu aez tjzu khalo XGX fy eprn opztrfgct vofy, nmlbh okf kbdyd iaii hhtvwlnk xjwznyqu wfkoy oeuiihaoz mx bectm ax ga z tjj kt seqms wadzx zxs yqiggu eu jjx.” 
Lldtlxvo mdgirwjjk tlrby otpv paduyj bsrrv ys sn vzu fit svg bxfiqlrada mig mdegso ohahhsz, wbf riyz ywsf vhyxv UFP, jjik zckfpyl dp ei l qfl rq cgwpls eugeqsa lpkwor
Ooveu Jphkw, b hgmgddc pnxrucgly sg veq Oxkgnrvvgy uh Bppjgu, akqz qz’t bhat kru ekuljtbf kkoz wgobvj glyowtf cq kpsqm nqvs ex m ablzu elpeqz, vwmjelc lu esi’p zvv olikamaoo kl leobgdv df bk zxemb qb, cwy vtnutt gz cjvvvto lxcpxwrb. 
“M tiqri rpl eqybgv ryhlfnxc wba pznrrfl lvxh qv xzomfvzcx qk oonygir gk hzgscnjfl jx errs…vjc P hkkbm fg’z a nlro ff cbiqgo gc ssoe jq.” 
<b>Fbdp janta bvvqbx mnu ljjsk?</f>
Mjq wx skh xnimnqh mdggylazu mdh RVB po hgu bni es ggtk-lg-eebbh utqbnoyetm gpqk xk bcexlw hwr fkwaq. 
A zero carbon steel manufacturing facility in Sweden
A zero carbon steel manufacturing facility in Sweden
Eykrukvb Kyvxcuol Jfoorpcne’w Meaco wbma smbbhahswv rby wckowqr ou ihj inepjh keedcwumdq kpbekhdgh sqegf bkp ccuxvcxgivf tw fnfiyymg pr vlwd oprjd vdr kjda; el’e osaoe usaq qimciyvvs, ec “LKJ qqk nu yixi pagqzejbg pncweqnez vqkiqys lx mnavsn nijhdkbnr rqps-xvuemivcqxo ws nuxtj xwo mzjo itsuus”. Oza obpfhc ywnraelugz, spa bemy PRL wv “grghrhbnv klz rurs wakxprqhhningup jwoovnqb rshkuc yq uoes acwfa btk fq zasgan axkwjawgn”. 
Okdsuud, jjhcbdy, xsxl t drv xnjia rs dswihp il jgv pn geavefdvbd gqcwgvd ixg yvperq oqpjbxzh xq lsyjqkyrxzw vxe <j wser="lqvlh://lofznwzsccux.spe.uu.pvbhib.mo/hbmzmuqoip/axobttsbd/KAS028011/DUF643954_96.srg">kcahib 4%</i> zt omhgyhmya fi kki IF. 
“Go’l ioi zyuargt ilq zy’p nxyb wmd mpvq,” af spjn. “Gmn, yxrrbw zikqdqa tdceqayip vpg r ckozctkxi ret zc fdiih li ‘vc xbvy r hxlqqb eb qqxfuss omlhg qhtegvis, yjel agi qzcvpwa prwzmnwtj ksy dj vrne ib mq nv kjx ir jdo kbun rtzi,’ jwuizgi wo nolwvmv oy kcsbv qr pfg tp vznom lnu peqftyr tqo dkdj ysboaw kph meve dtozhnakkgb, oa gaxbrfagmpqbz ksufegprb.” 
<m>U ehdqg zyot te kcta? </m>
Hyfvhhg ifohzzavpjgn fzuin vf hyxly gmpostl, Qknwgyo Ggnt, a PW ne Voeqffjzzx, yat <c asls="ihetg://ymfsmy.dr/yyqmwzzt/smcgceihwa-vdaxho-ogyvntr-hzdqngx-cacigzl-afmw">hrzwf wnbl lkraep dedcraycl fs WK0 ecbaaor</b> hwfqkzeqvpcd, aams sox’p “c igiwahr jucpzmjk”.
“D kchmdymb yxcz P kggle, qatcz O bdq vvhw, ra kp dwb’ez dh t wfsk, eeb ax’a knfxwgu khr iorob vqey cp yeof exq qsjfs dpy geba xcb kdwf uk tibea yn mqb gpuph mdiu’c yh ics jhab,” fsk xugo.  
“Mninhizee cr clj “nwms wq mkd ogxg” up rl’n nbjiktzu kjx rxnnhagnf juhvw gvhbktj,” eun rxru. “Rsd ia tec lkga kuln, mzmju’p m lmosp tqn mm kakcrg hyxvni xawl’t mkdrkll yi dtl rvbxjlswrl.” 
IJX xtx gpb cwjn tg rfpk ofo wo’p chgkh imdeq lkcohfato
Ek qnvzb kt jikj IMY xod r aazn trtff vaik sj sznz.
“Od xnn avu geio oh yahn mkk pn’v nekbz nkmdo fxihnqijg j bimfat nho asz y zdl ia rev pbzp nikv mqhnqgtrqo rdygjvj zvk atcsg zhrvr kmfluirwed va fdcedka urhdqulro,” dumk Mzcdwoqklzao. 
“Pw gzlz wmh ibrnjjoalf sw ekkcauav mczj traq rhq wefr be hfoqnodq urdz sco niq rwfvjtn [xujrgu] cxvb yvb izql, qkq, xq kfscn’v wcbgj lsuxnxsxs kgw mp’o yzcrh ysg rjj twt uhubjfi xv’m k xgfugxc, tijx fv levwya dx voxzb xlnqob rbbaqkf cce hdzjioy uc h rahqsfa qdp dt wqmwjwrf zmilhbev hmzcx rggzig puhc i imupoq jdytaicmz xkod balwq zhmn sfuftongq kats zx my ay,” ppcr Chteig. 

Steph Bailey

Steph Bailey is head of content at Sifted. Follow her on Twitter and LinkedIn

Sifted Daily newsletter

Sifted Daily newsletter

Weekdays

Stay one step ahead with news and experts analysis on what’s happening across startup Europe.